It is fascinating, yet also bewildering, how political parties come round to drawing up their plans, especially a political party that’s in government.
Last Tuesday I was invited by the Nationalist Party for what they called a Round-table Conference on Work and Investment.
It was, one could say, the beginning of the political season after the summer lull.
Without any prompting on my part, the party decided I was to be invited for the whole session, whereas the rest of the media was allowed to stay there for the Prime Minister’s introduction and the keynote speech.
I could feel inquiring – and worse – looks boring into my back as the time came for them to leave.
I would like to be able to titillate them with stories of hot controversy, with ministers arguing with each other, with people making accusations over this or that. But, sorry to say, nothing like that happened. It was the most anodyne and, yes, boring conference I have ever had to attend and after an hour-and-a-half we packed up and went home.
At no point was I bound to keep secret what I heard, so I will not. My basic point, however, is how easy it is for parties to be given a partial appreciation of reality on which they then go and base their policies.
I know the PN had a business breakfast on Thursday and will have another one on Wednesday, so nothing that was said on Tuesday was carved in stone. Nor have I any knowledge of who decided on the invitations and who did not bother to turn up. Nor did I know all the (few) people there.
Many of those present (or at least, many of those who spoke up) were from the financial services sector. Even they had their own complaints to make. For while it is true that the sector has been steadily growing, and we say it is a success story, it could have had a far greater success. At one point it was said that Malta could benefit from what happened in Ireland, but there is no sign of this so far. Malta has attracted less business than have smaller islands outside the UK.
Perhaps it is just as well. We congratulate ourselves that the Maltese banks and financial services sector has kept away from the naughty things that brought huge US banks to grief, but there may be a simpler reason for this: the university law course simply does not teach budding lawyers about derivatives and other financial toys, or at least so someone said.
That’s one curb on potential growth. Another was also identified. Despite all that has been done, the situation still depends on five or six people who hold all the power in their hands and who, deliberately or not, hold back developments and real growth.
There is a parallel to this in IT. In recent years we have seen the introduction of IT in schools and government offices. But still you get schools not maximising the potential of what they have (from accessing websites to allowing parents to know what their children are learning and access their marks, etc). You get many government websites that are simply dead (my gripe is Parliament: you still cannot access papers tabled, when this was available some years ago) and many supposedly accessible offices still insist on doing things on paper or getting people to go there. The worst is trying to get what is called a government e-ID. You have to go to Evans Building to get this simple ID and they have to take a photo of you and so on and so forth.
My point? That so many years after liberalising and opening up areas of our country, the nets have somehow become restricted again. You still need a permit here and a permit there. Ultimately, as I said, it all depends on five or six people.
There is an ancillary point to make. I hurry to clarify this was not made at the round-table conference. In certain sectors, the same people have been there for years. And we still have no culture of preparing a succession in an orderly manner, as if some people think they will last forever. And “après” them, there will be “le déluge”.
This is the gist of the complaints from the financial sector. That is what the government (in the form of the Prime Minister and ministers Austin Gatt and John Dalli – Tonio Fenech was at Ecofin) was hearing. However, it is only part of what the government must be told.
It’s not as if everyone will be employed by the financial services sector. At the same time, we must get the high fliers, the high value-added. If anything, we missed the bus when Lebanon imploded. And we seem to have missed the bus again when the sub-prime crisis brought about the collapse of other economies.
The government (see Tonio Fenech’s interview in The Times on Thursday and the minister’s subsequent concession to those who have not paid their income tax dues) seems mesmerised by the fall in its revenue, as well it should. Mr Fenech said the shortfall in income tax, VAT and Customs duty this year could amount to e80 million. That’s just about what was paid last year in higher oil prices.
It is under more extreme pressure than we care to admit from the European Commission, which would like Malta on the good and virtuous path of balancing its budgets according to what the government rashly stated as its aim for 2010 when 2010 was far away enough.
That, too, is a consideration that the government must keep in mind, but not the only one by far.
There is also the impending collapse of much of the tourism industry, brilliantly described by Alfred Mifsud in The Malta Independent on Friday. He said what all those in the sector know is happening.
There is also the beating being taken by the manufacturing industry, mainly as expressed in the Malta Employers’ Association survey published on Thursday. Employers have taken a year of recession hoping it will soon be over, and have tried hard to keep their employees, knowing it costs more to train a new employee than keep a trained one, but now they face a staggering COLA increase of e7 a week per person.
Although The Times was wrong to interpret the survey as saying that 20 per cent of employers will sack people if they are faced with so high a COLA (the report is far more vague than that), and it must not be interpreted as an either/or threat by the employers. A recession that goes on and on will inevitably produce job losses.
Add to that problems inherent in so many sectors of the economy, from retailers facing increased (sometimes disloyal) competition with very few rules in play, to a construction industry faced with a glut of finished or semi-finished properties unable to find a market.
There is also uncertainty over specific sectors on which we had pinned so much hope – SmartCity Malta for instance. One can understand international principals currently taking a beating for being cautious about new investment, although one wonders what the country will do about training people for an industry that may come or not. But look at Lufthansa Technik Malta and how it found young, eager and able people to work in an area unknown to us a few years ago.
All this and more must go into the government’s crucible before it plans the next step in the country’s economic direction. Normally we would say the next Budget, but I’m afraid this will only mean considerations about the government’s revenue and expenditure. There is more, much more, than this. The coming Budget must enable people to understand in which direction the government wants to direct the economy and the government must be sensitive enough to hear all the voices coming from the economy and then wise enough to take the right decisions.
There is one simple point I wanted to make last Tuesday: there is no way the economy can grow when more people lose jobs than get one. There is no way the economy can grow if we still hold the European trophy for lowest female participation (even though it’s growing) and the other European trophy for the lowest employment of people over 55. Human resources is all this country has and with two such trophies it is throwing away its best potential.
Hence the emphasis placed by the Prime Minister on education and more education. Pity he was not aware at that point that of all those who wanted to study nursing, only a fraction will get training. Last year we had the same wasting scenario in the IT sector, which later seems to have been ironed out.
It is still a pity that there are so many who would, or could, get retraining and do not seem attracted to it. And that the social security network still covers many people who could be made to work rather than scrounge.
Maybe we have all becomes Cassandras but earlier optimism that the recession is over just does not seem true even in those big countries that say they’ve beaten it, let alone here. There are no simple solutions. MEA estimated its COLA proposal to cost e4 million. The government said it would cost e8 million and was unthinkable. People realise that there can be no reduction in taxation in these circumstances. Some still think that fixing the price levels of fuels is up to the government, not the international market, or that the government could cushion the real prices only for the country to fork out the difference through taxes.
Then there is a further consideration to make: given the government’s pledge that health care must remain completely free, it makes little sense to build a wonderful hospital only to starve it of proper staffing. Or create a free medicine system, only for the government to fall back on its payments to importers. Think also of the social services we ought to have but just cannot get. If today we pay, say, 35 per cent of our income as taxes, in order to get the standard we deserve as EU citizens this must go up. If we want a Scandinavian society, we must pay Scandinavian taxes – and get Scandinavian wages.
In refusing MEA’s COLA proposal, the government seems to have chosen balance: COLA may be, as IMF and others have said, a structural distortion but it has enabled industrial peace and a certain stability. Balance is of the essence in the coming Budget, but balance alone will not get us out of recession. The government must get down to untying the many knots that make up this small country of ours.
[email protected]