The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

Law Report: Actions Against molestation and spoliation

Malta Independent Wednesday, 21 October 2009, 00:00 Last update: about 13 years ago

This case concerned an action instituted by the plaintiff against the defendant to be reinstated in possession of a property.

The plaintiff held that the parties were tenants of a property situated in Sliema, which property they leased from Mrs Violet Micallef acting as the testamentary executor of the late Ms Beatrice Galea Preca. The property was leased to the deceased parents of the parties, Angelo and Josephine Camilleri. Upon the demise of Mr Camilleri, the rent devolved on his wife who eventually passed away in May 2007. At the time of her death, the parties were living with their mother and had been so living there since their respective separations from their spouses. The rent therefore then devolved on the parties being family members residing with the tenant at the time of her demise.

On 15 December 2007, the defendant allegedly changed the lock of the property thereby preventing the plaintiff’s access to the same property.

The plaintiff held that this amounted to a violation of her rights as a co-tenant and constituted spoliation. The plaintiff requested that she be at least reintegrated in possession of her residence since she had no other place to live and was forced to rent another property. The plaintiff claimed that being barred from the disputed property was resulting in her having to pay rent for another property and furthermore, prevented her access to her books she required for her profession and telephone and internet services, for which she continued paying the bills.

The plaintiff therefore requested the Court to:

1. Declare and decide that the parties were co-tenants of the disputed property and that she had been despoiled by the defendant who abusively and illegally changed the lock to the property without her knowledge;

2. Order that within a short time, the plaintiff be restored in her possession of the disputed property and in case of the defendant’s default that the plaintiff be authorised to change the lock to the same property.

3. Declare that the defendant was responsible for damages suffered by the plaintiff, to liquidate such damages accordingly and condemn the defendant to the payment of such damages.

The defendant, amongst other things, claimed that he should not have been sued and furthermore that the plaintiff could not institute the action for spoliation in terms of Article 535 since this Article contemplates bringing such action for the reinstatement of possession within two months from the spoliation. Therefore the time frame established by law had, according to the defendant, expired. The defendant also held that in any case, the plaintiff enjoyed no title over the disputed property since she did fall within the definition of a ‘tenant’ in terms of the Reletting of Urban Property (Regulation) Ordinance (Chapter 69 – Laws of Malta) and was not recognised as a tenant by the owner.

The Court took into account all the requests and claims. It immediately noted that the plaintiff did not make it clear as to the action she was instituting since while her application included many terms and requests usually found in an action for the restoration of possession in the case of spoliation in terms of Article 535 of the Civil Code, specific reference was then made to Article 534 of the Civil Code which considers the action to secure the possessor in his/her rights in the case of molestation.

Article 535 concerning the action against spoliation known as the actio spolii holds that ‘Where any person is by violence or clandestinely despoiled of the possession, of whatever kind, or of the detention of a movable or an immovable thing, he may, within two months from the spoliation, bring an action against the author thereof demanding that he be reinstated in his possession or retention, as provided in article 791 of the Code of Organisation and Civil Procedure.”

Article 534 which considers the action against molestation known as the actio manutentionis holds that ‘Where any person, being in possession, of whatever kind, of an immovable thing, or of a universitas of movables, is molested in such possession, he may, within one year from the molestation, demand that his possession be retained, provided he shall not have usurped such possession from the defendant by violence or clandestinely nor obtained it from him precariously.’

The Court made reference to a series of judgements particularly the case Cachia vs Caruana (Court of Appeal – 2004) wherein it was held that as general principal, the nature of the action, should be determined by the act instituting proceedings. However, it may so happen that the nature of the action is uncertain from such act. Yet, the Court of Appeal acknowledged that such ambiguity may have been the plaintiff’s intention so as to be guaranteed the protection of either of the actions. The Court of Appeal held that these actions contemplated by Articles 534 and 535 are absolutely distinct and are regulated by different procedural laws and may therefore not be exercised simultaneously.

In this case, it was clear that the plaintiff cited Article 534 of the Civil Code as opposed to Article 535, since the latter Article holds that the action must be brought within two months from the spoliation and in this case, the alleged spoliation had taken place six months before the action was instituted. In the case Tabone vs Flavia it was in fact held that the actio spolii in terms of Article 535 would fail if not instituted within the two month period prescribed by law since such time frame is one of the essential conditions established by law for the action to succeed.

On the basis of the above, the Court held that should the action instituted be considered as the actio spolii in terms of Article 535 of the Civil Code, the defendant’s claims that the action has been prescribed should be upheld although reference is made to Article 534. The Court also held that should it not be rigid in its application and accept that this was an action under Article 534, the plaintiff’s claims could still not be upheld since the action contemplated by Article 534 was limited by the following conditions: (i) possession of whatever kind, of an immovable thing, or of a universitas of movables, (ii) molestation of such possession, (iii) the action must be brought within one year from the molestation, (iv) the Plaintiff must not have usurped such possession from the Defendant by violence or clandestinely nor obtained it from the defendant precariously.

On the basis of these conditions, the Court referred to recent case law which has clearly held that the Article 534 action cannot be instituted by tenants but caters more for possessors as defined by the law.

The Court therefore concluded by rejecting the plaintiff’s requests. This case may be the subject of an appeal.

  • don't miss