The question of the morning-after pill (emergency contraception) has touched the political scene again and as a consequence the media, in which I was invited to participate. How these questions tend to resurface every now and then shows that we are not settled as a people on many issues. However there are inherent difficulties in understanding the pharmacological issues on both sides of the argument.
That emergency contraception should not be used as an abortificient should not give us cause to argue. It is immoral and indeed illegal in our country, which not only still cherishes the fact that it upholds certain traditional values due to Catholic origins, but has asserted even in our constitution that our parliamentarians are bound by our normative values in the laws they make. This does not mean they should follow canon law, but certainly should reflect the general population’s assertion in the constitution. The protection of the embryo and of the family is usually the highest on these agendas. I cannot see parliament as saying that life begins at any stage other than conception, notwithstanding many different philosophical positions.
Emergency contraception has two functions. It is a contraceptive, as the name implies, but if used after ovulation, it has the potential of not allowing any fertilised eggs to implant. It works in three ways, First it changes the lining of the uterine wall and of the fallopian tubes (more popularly known as ‘the tubes’). This lining would usually facilitate the movement of sperm and ova towards each other. The resultant change in lining therefore counters this function. This is the first conception function that this medication has. Secondly, if used before ovulation, it will send forward (and thus prolong) the date of ovulation. If someone is due to ovulate, this will come at a later stage. Ovulation is the process where the female gametes (the ova) are released into the fallopian tubes from the ovaries. If this is halted for a while, the result is also a contraceptive effect.
However due to the first contraceptive effect described above, if it is used after ovulation, and therefore you have eggs released into the system, there is of course a good chance that after intercourse, a sperm reaches and fertilises it. It has been shown that the earlier these emergency contraceptives are used, the more effective they are, which implies that the longer you wait to use them the more chance there is that you are targeting a fertilised egg. But for our purposes, we must not use a qualitative, but a quantitative argument, and having a one per cent chance or a 10 per cent chance (numbers are fictitious and used only for argument), one still stands a risk of aborting this fertilised egg. Since the lining of the uterus has been changed, this fertilised egg cannot implant itself and is aborted. It has been known to fail however and therefore one is never completely protected. When it fails, no resultant defects in the foetus have been shown.
There are a number of important points at this stage. The conclusion that if one uses the morning after pill before ovulation, one is using it as a contraceptive, and if one uses it after ovulation, one is risking an abortion, is safe but makes its use difficult nevertheless. Newer contraceptives are said not to affect fertilised eggs’ chances of implantation and will therefore change the matter. For how is one to ascertain that ovulation has indeed not occurred. Doctors usually rely on a history of one’s menstrual cycles to calculate whether ovulation can occur. Moreover many women do feel that they are ovulating. However there is always the risk of abuse. A doctor must always base the doctor-patient relationship on trust and therefore the doctor certainly cannot carry any moral responsibility if the patient lies. But this is really beyond the point. Conversely there are tests available which may tell if one has ovulated or not. But the patient must consent to such tests, and it goes without saying that if she refuses, the doctor has a right to an objection on grounds of conscience – a conscientious objection.
It goes without saying that just because one is using it as a contraceptive before ovulation, it does not mean there is no moral agenda or that we are condoning contraception. But certainly contraception on its own has less moral gravity than when there is a risk of an abortion. We are talking here from the premise of taking for granted that contraception is used locally, and therefore not confusing the issue. But one must, when taking a holistic view, also take into account contraception from a moral aspect. In cases of rape, it has been put forward by the Catholic British Episcopal Conference that the woman has a right to protect herself from pregnancy if she has not ovulated. Since on an RTK programme someone called in querying an Episcopal conference, it is worth pointing out that this is a well-organised event which is vetted through Rome, although not an official central document of the Church. It is not however similar to when a Bishop speaks his mind on an issue. It is a pastoral document to guide Catholics in the area. Since by definition, Catholic means universal, it would apply in theory to the rest of the Catholic world. An important other Episcopal Conference was that of the Belgian Bishops, who in 1985 asserted that women can get treatment during pregnancy even if it results in harm or death of the foetus, as this would be considered a foreseen but unintended harm. The principle of double effect was thus asserted.
I have written on instances of rape, invoking the principle of double effect, by arguing that when a woman is raped one has to look at the problem holistically and in that dire situation, asking about ovulation and indeed giving a conditional option of an ovulation test, may not be putting the woman through a humane procedure. However double effect, by definition, requires proportionality, and what I had written is of course challengeable. It was asserted only for rape however and not under the circumstances of use as a morning-after contraceptive under normal conditions. But rape has a much broader definition than we tend to think. It need not be a dramatised situation. Any intercourse to which the woman objects and is forced to undergo under some form of duress, even in marriage, can legally constitute unconsensual sex, which amounts to rape. Such is the case of drunken men going home and forcing their wives, with or without violence.
To come back to the subject however we must answer the pertinent question: Should government legalise the morning after pill. Under the present circumstances one has to give a clear ‘no’. One cannot afford to have such a drug which risks being given over the counter as contraceptives are often given. In theory any form of hormonal contraception requires the prescription of the doctor, but in practice I have many patients who tell me they simply asked for it over the counter. That this is the practice in some countries does not make it right. Conversely, a clear ‘yes’ can be given if the newer forms do not endanger fertilised eggs.
Before discussing regulation, one has to assert another important fact. Doctors, with or without the emergency contraceptive pill can still use the normal contraceptive pill in what is known as an ‘off-label’ manner. Off label simply means not using the drug in the dose or frequency it was packaged for. Since emergency contraception is a high dose of oestrogen a doctor can titrate the dose and give it using the available products. Although this cannot be classified as bad clinical practice, since one packet with proper doses exists, this correct pharmacological practice is put into question. Now if one asserts that, given the moral burden of contraception itself, there are instances in which the doctor may help a woman (before ovulation – and thus being certain of not procuring an abortion) to prolong her ovulation and thus offer some protection against fertilisation, it would mean that the only method available to the doctor is this off-label method.
The question arises as to how much the doctor wishes to risk using this method. If a complication had to occur, which most hormonal treatment carry, it would certainly be more difficult to defend oneself in front of a medical council or in a court of law. If on the other hand there is an available titred-dose package, one is clearly safe and one simply has to explain the risks involved. It is also much safer for the patient to use as it is not uncommon, especially in a situation which is causing anxiety, that patients fail to remember the instructions given.
But this leaves the government with a dilemma. Certainly I would say that unless one makes a framework for the correct usage and dispensing of such material, to avoid abuse and its use as an abortificient, the government would not be in a position to legalise this drug. If the government however introduces measures to provide tools for doctors to work with, one can never make a fool proof system. The question is whether we trust people, and more importantly whether we trust doctors. Until such time as these issues are resolved, one cannot merely legalise the use of a drug, which in the UK, for example, has found itself as an over-the-counter drug. I honestly do not think it is merely a question of rights. If we honestly believe that life begins at conception, we must protect that life. An architect declares a house uninhabitable if the beams are rotten so as to protect life, even if the chances of them giving in are small. In the same way our government is upheld to a moral status to protect life, even if the chances of killing it are slim.
One may argue, but we import guns for legitimate reasons, and these not only can also be used to kill, but have proved themselves to be dangerous in this regard. The difference is that here you can prove and take action, and by no means is the argument of weapons in society exhausted.
I was a fan of M.A.S.H. when it was on Paramount Comedy. This was about a group of surgeons and doctors working in the Korean war. They saw the results of war every single day of their lives. Soldiers came in wounded into the operating theatre and many left it dead. Death was very dramatic down there. But once a fighter pilot came in with a minor wound. When asked how he was coping with the war he seemed quite jolly about it. He said that his work was simple – flying a jet, dropping bombs and leaving. His job was simple and there was no mental burden for him. Since he was not seeing the people he was killing, his conscience seemed to have absolved him. In contrast another pilot went mad because he realised the damage he was causing on a daily basis. The first pilot went into a denial.
Once I am not seeing that microscopic fertilised egg which I can hold on the tip of a needle, I can easily deny myself the reality that I am killing someone who in a few years time would be grown like us.
Pierre Mallia is Associate Professor in Family Medicine, Patients’ Rights and Bioethics at the University of Malta; he is also Ethics Advisor to the Medical Council of Malta. He is also former president of the Malta College of Family Doctors.