Two weeks ago, Vodafone, in its wisdom, decided to distribute condoms to university students. It seems that qualifications and experience in management do not include a moral dimension. Am I shocked? Yes, but then I am one of those who believe, like Lord Bingham, a senior law lord, that it seems clear that the last half century has seen an erosion of values once held dear.
This is not erosion due to any particular political party, or government, or the markets, or an institution like the media among others, but nevertheless erosion there has been and all the above have to carry their burden of responsibility not only for its birth but also its continued nourishment.
But then I am old-fashioned and I tend to hold fast to those eroded values. Am I alone?
Oliver Friggieri’s famous phrase Fil-Parlament ma jikbrux fjuri is as relevant today as it was yesteryear. I was there and I know. The public rot started with the very personal war between Dom Mintoff and the leader of the mightiest institution in the land, Archbishop Gonzi. That war is well documented; the shortcomings of one of the parties perhaps less so. But, like all wars, it had its victims.
The most obvious were the three main contenders, for there are no winners in war. The PN came out of it recast in Dom’s image; the PL is apologising to this very day for its dark past and for events which should not have happened, but which did even while the perpetrators seem to have got away with it; the Church is still wary of any pronouncement that might be interpreted as political interference. That war was fought by all parties in the name of the people whose real needs and aspirations played second to the overriding interests of the parties in conflict. Today, luckily, civil society has come of age and is rightly demanding that it be treated as an equal partner when it comes to deciding what is in its best interest.
The hurt caused by that war extended not only to people but also to values and traditions. Many Maltese lost not only their faith but also any respect for authority. They are the fathers and mothers of our young generation, forming part of that large group of parents who complain they cannot control their children. This of course, is not to say that the crisis in the family we are witnessing now is solely due to the political climate created that time, but it certainly opened the door to what followed.
These shocks that ran through Malta’s fissures were further reinforced when the culture that money was no problem took root and hedonism became the basis of the good life. At the same time, Malta’s doors were suddenly blown open to foreign influences when we were hardly in a position to evaluate and judge let alone adopt or discard. Neither are we ready now, so many years later, when the EU tells us that Malta has one of the highest rates of student drop-outs in Europe.
The pervasive strength of the market which through television has entered into our bedrooms and living rooms has left its mark as well. If the mentality is based on market values, then it is no wonder that a commercial company sees nothing wrong in distributing condoms to young people, and that wedding vows are broken at times, on the flimsiest of excuses.
My experience as a doctor belies what one reads, that couples do not split up without very good reasons. While there are those who take this step out of sheer desperation, I could also provide long lists of people who did give up on their responsibilities without a care in the world. For a considerable proportion, their pain was self-inflicted.
So what Maltese students need is not more schooling, not just a longer time spent between the four walls of a classroom or a lecture theatre, but more education based on thinking, evaluating and problem-solving among other virtues. We are now being promised that we shall no longer just focus on exam results resulting in dreadful achievement leagues between one college and another, between the state and private educational sector. Unfortunately, political promises in Malta tend to end up tasting like last nights beer.
But then I am old fashioned and still believe that spin should not come before principle. Am I alone?
The media too is now composed of a new breed of reporters and commentators, seemingly in tune with present trends (like the protagonists in the TV comedy Ab.Fab) and, in general, supporting modern-day relativism which is often superficially expressed as everything is relative or that more popular phrase everything goes. The suggestion for example, that the basic principles of natural law can apply to some in a different way they apply to others, if correct, would have a dramatic impact on the most fundamental issues. For if we accept that everything goes, based on the dictum that it’s my life and I do with it what I want, then we are accepting a total breakdown of our society. What makes such thinking particularly short-sighted is that this concept has been tested before in several cultures and found to be seriously flawed.
It is however, a highly seductive concept for the young to whom nothing is dearer than doing what they want without any restraint. That I can understand; what beats me is that even some not-so-young seem to reason along these lines. And it cuts right across class and educational backgrounds. Is the acceptance of relationships seemingly based on an easy-come-easy-go attitude on the part of highly educated and intelligent people different from the woman who brought her daughter to see me? The young woman had enjoyed several partners but when I told her mother that she was not pregnant, all this mother could do was to express disappointment that she was not going to be a grandmother.
But then I am old fashioned; is it possible that I am alone?
Dr Josie Muscat is Leader Azzjoni Nazzjonali