This week in Parliament we started the process for the Second Reading of the bill proposing amendments to Chapter 88 which regulates the expropriation of land from private owners for public purposes. These amendments are designed to supply the public with further rights, within a background of a better structure to protect our cultural heritage. It is also very encouraging to note that the opposition is supporting the government in this initiative which will promote every citizen’s rights further.
The opposition’s decision to back the government on these amendments is logical, as through them the public will be supplied with legal powers that were never available. On these lines, Labour MP Owen Bonnici in his contribution to the debate last Monday outlined very successfully the whole gist of these amendments. He pointed out how a government shows its true strenghth according to the extent that the same government is willing to supply its citizens with rights. And this is exactly what we are doing – putting the public on a level playingfield with the government, highlighting once again the democratic credentials of this government.
The government is demonstrating humility with these amendments providing more rights to each citizen. A practical example is that till this day, a land owner whose land is required for a public purpose was not in any position to question the public purpose for which his land is required.
According to the law, the President’s declaration was legally sufficient to prove the public purpose, and he could not even ask the Courts to investigate it in order to justify the expropriation. This is going to be amended in a way that a land owner will be able to ask the Courts to investigate the public purpose. Hence the land owner will be able to do this within 21 days from the President’s declaration.
Another practical example that will deliver more rights to the public is that the report which is prepared by the two architects who form the Land Arbitration Board (LAB) together with the Magistrate, will be available to all parties, at least one sitting before the sentence is delivered, while it should also include a set of criteria for it to be valid. One of the most important criteria being that the report should contain comparable transactions that validate the estimate of the property in question – ie. the value should be comparable to other values given to other properties in the vicinity, recently and within the same range of dimensions.
It is also noteworthy to mention that till this day, in the case of the two architects preparing a unanimous estimate report, this tied the hands of the Magistrate. This is going to change in order to give more power to the Magistrate, who has security of tenure. This goes hand in hand with the furthering of every citizen’s rights, who in the past couldn’t appeal from the LAB’s sentence, and who thanks to these amendments, for the first time, he or she will be able to do so.
The above are only a few examples of the tangible difference these amendments will bring to the ways things are done when Government is expropriating land. If I had to forget the legalisims of the actual bill for a moment, and condense the principles behind it in just three words, I would comfortably choose transparency, accountability and justice.
Dr Jason Azzopardi is parliamentary secretary in the Finance Ministry