The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

This Time, Malta beats Spain

Malta Independent Friday, 30 October 2009, 00:00 Last update: about 15 years ago

Despite the indefatigable efforts by the Maltese national football team, unfortunately our track record in this particular sport trails at the bottom of the listings. One of the major blows experienced by our national football team will definitely remain to be the unfortunate and embarrassing result of the match held on 21 December, 1983 – Malta ‘s 77th international “A” match and one of the last in the qualifications of the European Championship. This match was played in the context of a peculiar pre-condition. Spain required more than a simple win to maintain its lead over the 10-goal advantage enjoyed by Holland. To everyone’s surprise, Spain indeed succeeded in achieving this giant feat and secured its lead by achieving a 12 to 1 win against Malta.

However, football is not the only arena where these two countries compete. Malta and Spain, both member states of the European Union possess significant similarities in both culture and customs. Both countries are on the southern rim of the EU and as expected, they face similar challenges. Nevertheless, recent attempts to address the current economic crisis indicated that strategies diverged between the two countries. A simple analysis of the proposed budget measures of both countries suffices to explain this.

Zapatero is the current Socialist Prime Minister. His recent measures aim to reduce public expenditure in order to control the haemorrhage of the ever increasing public deficit. His short-term solution is to increase the top VAT rate – a move similarly adopted by Lithuania, a country in deeper economic trouble. To the contrary, the VAT exemption granted to Malta by the EU on food and medicines gives us a competitive advantage in this regard, especially when one considers that both these goods are basic and primary needs.

In addition, the Maltese government has wisely widened the tax bands for the last three consecutive years, at each time pushing taxpayers to lower tax bracket. Our Spanish counterparts, on the other hand, are exposed to higher income tax ceilings all together. The point here is not the taxing principle applied, whereby the wealthier bears the heftier burden and makes good for the less financially-able, but the fact that our government introduces a short term cessation for the introduction of new taxes in these financially turbulent times.

With the adoption of unpopular tax hikes the Spanish government will increase its revenue to 21.2 per cent. However, with its grotesque unemployment rate standing at 18 per cent, half of Spain’s generated revenue will be immediately redirected outwards once again into public expenditure mainly in the form of social welfare assistance. We are in advantage on this point of unemployment – as Eurostat’s latest unemployment figures place Malta at the lower part of the list, benefiting from the relatively lowest decreases in employment growth rates. Estimates in employment growth released in mid-September show that the percentage change for the second quarter of 2009 when compared with the same quarter for 2008, Spain experienced a decrease of seven percentage points, a sharp contrast with Malta’s mere 0.8% decrease. In simple terms, Spain lost seven times as many jobs than Malta did on a pro-rata basis. Moreover, our standing is also superior to the average of the EU’s 27 member states and that for the Eurozone area, with decreases of 1.9 and 1.8% respectively.

I happened to discuss this Malta-Spain comparison with a lady at a local club, after she complained about the current downturn prevalent in our islands. After listening to what I had been saying, she queried on the relevance this comparison ought to have on herself and her family members. At which point I asked – wouldn’t you have complained had our government raised the VAT top rate, simultaneously increasing our cost of living? Wouldn’t you also have whined and protested had our government increased the levy in income on savings? Or reduced any of the current benefits, be it student stipends or the children’s allowance? Anyone would have complained had there been an increase in the income tax rates to provide for increased social welfare benefits to cater for the increases in unemployment rates since any of these measures, had they been adopted, would in some way tarnish the level of our current standard of living.

However, despite all the difficulties and the harsh economic reality in the countries where we export our products and services, the Maltese government still pledged and maintained the promise not to introduce new taxes. This was made possible because the decisions which are being made are sensible to the current difficulties brought about by the international recession. Instead of addressing the taxable, our government is addressing abusers, which is the more logical thing to do in these turbulent times. The Malta-Spain comparison is ample proof of this.

This time Malta beats Spain!

David Agius is the government whip

[email protected]

  • don't miss