The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

There’s No going back now

Malta Independent Sunday, 1 November 2009, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

As I mentioned in a previous column, Oliver Friggieri’s opus Fjuri li ma Jinxfux has been my Maltese reading “assignment” of the last few months. With uncanny precision I always seem to come to a definitive chapter that is then reflected in the unfolding of present day events.

So, as I read about the inflexible, undisputed influence which the Church and the Catholic faith had on Malta in the 1950s and 1960s, talk shows are hotly debating the Church’s decision to take the festas back firmly in its grip and clamp down on what has become almost a pagan orgy of drunkenness, half-naked teenagers and obscene chants. “You want to take us back to the 50s when the Church controlled everything!” one agitated club president accused Dun Anton Gouder.

Sometimes the images between the way Malta used to be a mere 40 years ago and today’s reality are brought up in such sharp contrast that it takes your breath away.

As I read about how the young, devout Oliver wrestled with his decision to abandon his vocation, risking the wrath of his father whose dream was to have a priest in the family, I paused to turn on the TV to hear a discussion about common law marriage with young people openly arguing and challenging the priest sitting almost apologetically in their midst.

Even in his 20s when he was going out with the girl who would later become his wife, Oliver had a rigidly imposed curfew – 10pm – and if he failed to respect it he would find the door firmly bolted. As the author points out, by the 1990s, 10pm became the time when young people went out, only for them to stagger back home in the early hours of the morning.

But just like the Church is going to find it almost impossible to rein in the festa supporters who have been allowed to run riot for so long, so too will parents find it impossible now to impose curfews especially if they themselves stagger home as late as their own children.

No wonder my mother often cannot believe the changes that have taken place in her lifetime – “Malta saret aghar minn barra!” is one of her favourite expressions, meaning that Malta has become worse than other countries when it comes to social upheaval.

If Herbert Ganado famously saw Malta change, then people of my mother’s generation have seen the whole world as they knew it turned upside down in the last 20 years. Those of Prof. Friggieri’s generation, on the other hand, are the last bridge between the Malta my mother grew up in and mine. The baby boomers, as they are known, have an understandable sense of bewilderment at how the rapid pace of change seems to have accelerated beyond their control.

The book describes a Malta where Church and home were one and the same (“il-knisja kienet id-dar, id-dar kienet il-knisja”), and Maltese culture was intrinsically at one with the Roman Catholic Church. The Catholic faith defined the Maltese identity, and, as Prof. Friggieri continuously reminds us, it gave people a clear, almost soothing, point of reference. But Malta could not remain cocooned and untouched by the outside world forever, and external influences (which Prof. Friggieri traces to the introduction of cable television in the 1990s) saw an explosion of new ideas, lifestyles and mentalities that landed with unabashed clamour smack in the middle of our living rooms.

From a homogenised nation where practically everyone was raised with the same traditions and beliefs, it seemed as if Malta suddenly splintered into a number of mini-Maltas, each with its own sub-culture. One of the casualties of this explosion was people’s blind fervour and loyalty towards the Church.

As the very foundations of what people always believed in have been shaken to the core, it is often pointed out that – with the loss of this religious identity – Malta seems to be adrift and does not know where it’s going. In other words, as large sections of the population continue to turn their backs on the Catholic faith, they seem to have lost their moral compass altogether. There does not seem to be a middle ground either – one is either pious and church going, living one’s life according to the diktats of the Church, or else, nothing... mayhem and complete social disarray.

Pretending to be Catholic?

This does not mean that the chasm between practising and non-practising Catholics is complete. The fierce hold of the Church on people’s psychological make-up is still very powerful. I often see a paradox between the way people are choosing to live and the fact that they continue to want to be “accepted” by the Church.

For example, those who have left their marriage and are living with someone else “in sin” are often indignant that the Church does not want to treat them like a married couple, does not allow them to take Communion and does not want to baptise any children born from their union with other babies. This attitude always baffles me.

Frankly, if you got married in Church and took vows before God to live together “for better or for worse” – and you had no qualms about breaking those vows – you are already a lapsed Catholic anyway. So why should you care so much and are so desperate to be allowed back into the fold?

I feel the same way about girls who choose to get pregnant when they are not married (and yes, I’m sorry, but the way I see it, they have made the choice because they are in control of their own bodies). Before they get so hot and bothered about the Church not treating their babies like everyone else’s, they should remember that by having sex before marriage they were already not practising their faith anyway. The irony of course is that these girls’ babies get first preference for Church schools, before the babies of married couples. I’m not saying that the children should be “punished” for the indiscretions of the mother, but the hypocrisy is just too much for me.

Let’s be honest – does a newborn baby know whether he is being baptised with the other babies? Does a three-year-old know or care which school he is going to be despatched to? No – this is all about the mother’s hang-ups and her high-handed demands that the Church she has turned her back on should now bow down to her wishes.

Certainly, my own life choices have not exactly been those of a good Catholic girl, but I never expected the Church to change for me, and that is something I came to terms with long ago. I’m definitely not going to get all puce with rage or stamp my feet, because if belonging to the Church had figured so prominently in my life, I would not have made the decisions I did.

There are those who argue that the Church needs to be more open to those who have made these types of “mistakes” as it risks becoming more and more irrelevant. I would add that it also risks having more and more empty pews during Mass – but that is something that the Church authorities need to decide for themselves, as some priests are already doing.

Meanwhile, I really wish that those who are not living by the “rules” of the Church would just stop being so self-righteous and face facts that they can’t have it both ways.

[email protected]

  • don't miss