So after seven years, the trial of former chief justice Noel Arrigo has begun. He has chosen to be tried by a judge and not by a jury, presumably in the belief that jurors would not have been sympathetic to his cause. A judge is perhaps even less likely to be sympathetic, given that the man before him has, with one of his colleagues, brought the bench into disrepute and shaken people's trust in it. But judges, unlike jurors, take their decisions according to the letter of the law and don't go on gut instinct as so many jurors do.
Arrigo is pleading not guilty, but his remarks on the interrogation tapes played in court just reek of sleaze and that chummy-chummy attitude that makes my skin crawl. But guess what? I believe him when he says he doesn't think he did anything wrong. He doesn't come across as a bad man who would go out of his way to do people harm or who takes pleasure in causing harm. He should never have been appointed to the bench - a disastrous decision with entirely foreseeable consequences - still less chief justice, a shockingly disgraceful parody of an appointment.
This was, after all, a judge who thought nothing of taking to the witness stand in the trial of a cocaine courier from a privileged background who ended up in a chaotic mess through a series of poor decisions(the infamous "but I thought it was emeralds" case), to give a character reference to the defendant on the grounds that he had known him at school and, take his word for it, he would never courier cocaine. No, he would only smuggle emeralds.
I had laughed out loud at the time. A character reference from Noel Arrigo, in a sort of birds-of-a-feather flocking together scenario, would have been hilarious irony were it not for the fact that Noel Arrigo was a judge at the time and his decision to take to the witness stand was entirely out of order. But, I imagine, as with the current case for which he now stands trial, he thought there was nothing wrong in doing so. He was only sticking up for an old friend.
In the police interrogation tapes played in court yesterday, Arrigo is heard telling the police commissioner that he planned to reduce the drug trafficker's sentence in any case, and that he wasn't influenced to do so. He refused all offers of gifts, he said. He wishes to convince that the decision was his alone and he was not persuaded by third parties. The other two appeals court judges - one of whom has been imprisoned already for taking bribes to reduce that sentence, and the other completely innocent of all aspersions - agreed with him, he said. How he imagines that this is anything other than a non sequitur is beyond me to understand, but then at the time he wasn't aware that the other judge would plead guilty and end up in prison. All I can say is that with his kind of reasoning, I pity the people over whom he stood in judgement.
Arrigo told the police commissioner that he wanted to give the drug trafficker's intermediary the impression that he was accommodating his request, even though he had taken the decision to reduce the sentence already, and had done so independently of any such influence.
As the police commissioner told him (and interrogating the chief justice must have been one of the high - or should that be low? - points of the police commissioner's career) instead of reporting the intermediary to the police for criminal investigation, Arrigo hadn't just carried on chatting to him, but had actually given him information about his decision on the judgement, before the Appeals Court delivered it. One assumes that the chief justice, of all people, knows what any lawyer and even many civilians do: that approaching a judge directly to discuss a case or judgement, still more to persuade him one way or the other, is a criminal offence.
The trial should prove interesting, not least because Arrigo's supporters, aside from his long-suffering wife, include Jo Said, that man who popped up all over the place in the last general election, doing his damnedest to bring back Sant as prime minister because GonziPN is riddled with corruption. Now there he is, lending his moral support, such as it is, to a man who stands accused of being unduly influenced to reduce the sentence of a drug trafficker, when he was - of all things - chief justice. But the magnificent irony almost certainly slips over Said's head.
Well, what can I say? It's no coincidence that no one, to my knowledge, has ever said of Arrigo and his disgrace that they expected better of him. And that was precisely because nobody did expect better of him. Is that an awful thing to say? No. What was awful, on the other hand, is the insult to democracy and the standing of the court when he was made first a judge and then chief justice. That was unforgiveable.
www.daphnecaruana
galizia.com