So Fr Mark Montebello is in trouble again. I got my first and only poster (the main news blurb advertising newspapers outside newsagents) in the early 90s with a news item saying that the then Archbishop Joseph Mercieca had stopped Mark from writing articles in the newspapers.
I cannot remember what that controversy was about, but he obviously was, as he is now, not towing the Church line.
Over a decade-and-a-half later he is in trouble again and I am sure it will not be the last time, either. I believe it is water off a duck’s back as far as he is concerned.
The reactions from people to the latest news vary from those who think that since he has taken a vow of obedience, he should just shut up, or leave the Church, to those – and they seemed to be in the majority – who think he should stick to his guns and stay and be a rebel within the Church.
I like rebels, they are usually sensitive and intelligent and do not use sophistry. It is a shame that Father Renè Camilleri was sucked into the Church establishment as soon as the Dominican Paul Cremona became Archbishop.
I do not always agree with Mark Montebello, although I regard him as a friend and have worked with him on Victim Support.
For example, I think he needs to rethink his views on a paedophile register. He does sometimes let himself be used by some in the media looking for the sensational and he does like the limelight.
But, love him or hate him, Mark has worked very hard to help the most vulnerable in our society. He is generous (not with money, he does not have any) and unstinting in trying to create a better society, which is truly Christian.
Even the Curia, while trying to shut him up, acknowledged its “appreciation for other initiatives taken by Fr Montebello, particularly those relating to the marginalised, detained and victims of criminality.”
So it is all right for Fr Mark to be associated with the Curia when he is giving the institution good PR, but not when his opinion threatens the Curia’s control.
The Curia claimed Fr Montebello’s “views tend to offend the sentiments of many”.
His views are against hypocrisy and dishonest arguments and one must wonder why the sentiments of many were offended by those views.
But according to comments online, many are also not offended and agree with him.
I read his article on the crucifix controversy in The Times and the only thing that upset me was his use of the word “flaunted”.
“We had, and still have, the cross flaunted in our homes and, yet, people still commit adultery, swear, mistreat their wives, husbands and children. We had, and still have, the cross flaunted in our streets and, yet, people still abuse each other.
“...it is not flaunting the cross that is a true sign of faith but gratitude to God’s love expressed in charity. My whole point is that who really believes in the most Holy Cross (not as a political tool but as a sign of a personal relationship) does not fear its being removed from public places”, wrote Fr Mark.
I just wish he had chosen a more appropriate word than “flaunted”. I don’t think that an “ostentatious display” is the right description for what he was trying to convey.
Some of us do have crucifixes in our homes and they are certainly not a display of ostentation. Unfortunately, the word “flaunted” tended to take the impact away from the crucial message, which was appropriate in that just displaying the crucifix means nothing if one’s lifestyle defies Christ’s teaching.
Fr Montebello said he has now been told to give his superiors prior copies of contributions he has made to the press and to inform them beforehand of invitations to participate in TV programmes.
Can the Curia not see the irony of criticising Mepa for its behaviour towards its auditor last week, stating: “by its actions Mepa would also be promoting a culture of omertà”, while not applying the same line of thinking to its own institution?
Unfortunately, the Curia’s statement on omertà was also published a week before a damning report on child sex abuse in Ireland was released.
The Catholic Church has been outed for its omertà on child abuse by Catholic priests for over 30 years.
The Report of the Commission of Investigation into the Catholic Archdiocese of Dublin, which was published on Thursday, covered a period from 1975 to 2004.
It condemned Church leaders for covering-up abuse for decades. The inquiry disclosed that the Vatican ignored formal requests for information. According to the report, the Vatican did not reply when asked for details of reports on abuse sent to it by the Dublin archdiocese in 2006.
The Vatican told The Irish Times it “was a matter for the local church involved”. A request for information from the Papal Nuncio was also ignored.
“Earlier this year, the commission again failed to receive a reply after sending the Papal Nuncio extracts from its draft report which referred to him and his office, as it was required to do”, reported the BBC.
“The welfare of children, which should have been the first priority, was not even a factor to be considered in the early stages. Instead the focus was on the avoidance of scandal and the preservation of the good name, status and assets of the institution and of what the institution regarded as its most important members – the priests,” said the report.
Not one of them” (four archbishops: John Charles McQuaid, Dermot Ryan, Kevin McNamara and Desmond Connell) who served during the time period covered by the report “reported his knowledge of child sexual abuse to the Gardai (the Irish police force) throughout the 1960s, 1970s, or 1980s,” the report said.
It also said Church officials perpetuated the problem by ignoring allegations and in some cases simply moved an alleged abuser on to another parish, leaving him free to abuse another group of children.
This, of course, has not only been documented in Ireland but also in the US, in Latin America and elsewhere.
“In many cases, the welfare of children counted for nothing and abusers were left free to abuse – to visit evil on the innocent,” said Irish Justice Minister Dermot Ahern.
“There is no escaping the cruel irony that the Church, partly motivated by a desire to avoid scandal, in fact created a scandal on an astonishing scale... It is not now – nor has it ever been – acceptable that institutions behave or are treated as being above the law of the State,” said Mr Ahern.
The report also found that senior police officers colluded in the cover-up on occasion.
Another investigative document, the Ryan Report published in May 2009, detailed 70 years of abuse allegations in Ireland from the 1940s to the present, not all in strictly religious institutions.
It detailed decades of abuse in lay institutions – schools, borstals, hospitals, orphanages, children’s homes, industrial schools and reformatories run by religious orders. Thousands of children were affected.
Though both reports deal with child abuse, they are not related, having been written by two separate commissions investigating two different subjects.
I wish those people who have been harping on about children’s responsibilities and duties rather than their rights would give the subject a little more thought and allocate responsibility and duty where it is due.
[email protected]