Every so often the abortion issue hits the headlines showing how real the problem still is outside our country. One often hears comments that Malta is too far behind and that we try to be more puritan than others. The reality is that the abortion issue is far from over and even in countries where the problem is put under the carpet, there is still much to be said.
Ireland is one of the last countries where abortion is banned. An abortion law allows a termination of pregnancy only if the mother’s life is in danger. On an ethical level this can be acceptable to many. But there is a difference between this direct form of abortion and a foreseen but indirect killing of a baby, where the intent is not to kill the baby but to save the life of the mother and where the killing does not bring about the cure directly. The latter follows the principle of double effect which is allowed in the Catholic world as well.
Therefore if a woman has an ectopic pregnancy, the tube can be removed with the embryo and all, as it is a pathological tissue which so happens to have an embryo. Not removing the tube would result in the death of both mother and child. The same holds true where a woman has a tumour of her pregnancy uterus and treatment which can endanger or indeed kill the baby is necessary. In this case, by killing the baby you are not bringing about the good effect; the good is the removal of the cancerous uterus.
Hence it is called indirect. A direct killing would be something like when a baby being delivered is caught in the passage resulting in an emergency which requires a mutilatory operation which opens the neck of the uterus, vagina and pubic area to deliver the baby. The operation is dangerous to the lives of the mother and child for the mere fact that it is an emergency and is not foreseen. The saving of the mother however necessitates the direct killing of the baby in order to deliver it in parts. This cannot be allowed therefore by the principle of double effect.
Which is why even the Irish law allowing a termination of pregnancy when the life of the mother is in danger can be ethical to an extent but in reality may involve the direct killing of a baby which would result in a therapeutic abortion which may be objected to on moral grounds. Yet Ireland has allowed for this possibility. Notwithstanding, it is estimated that over the past 30 years, 140,000 women have therefore gone to the UK to have abortion.
Three Irish women are now challenging this law saying that the European Convention on Human Rights should allow abortions when the “health and well-being” of the woman is being challenged. Now even someone who would favour abortions must agree that using such a definition as “health” and “well-being” are so scant and frivolous to define that should the European court find in their favour one would have to question whether this would simply be allowing an abortion under any circumstance. For I can even argue that if a pregnancy is not allowing me to further my carrier, than it is affecting my well-being; or if I am depressed because I do not want a child, then my “health” is being effected. One would have bypassed the argument of “women’s rights over their bodies”, by using (or abusing) definitions of health.
Now in the UK abortion is illegal as well but the Abortion Act, especially after the 1967 amendments has liberalised the act. Women in the UK are allowed to terminate their pregnancy if they have a “serious medical or psychological problem that endangers their life if they continue with the pregnancy”. The 1967 amendment however included termination even if the woman has severe learning difficulties or if the doctors detect foetal abnormalities. Social abortions are less easily accessible according to the BBC website but critics do say that the law is unclear in this respect.
The point being stressed here is to show that should the EU favour these women, one already has a clear example in the UK on what a more liberalised law on abortion can do. Experts agree that the law is open to interpretation on many counts and the reality is that if an abortion is wanted, there are many channels for one to pass through. Maltese women are known to go to the UK for an abortion, as Irish women do and this clearly shows that no serious medical threat is necessary and what we define as a serious psychological threat is a scientific term for a very subjective and unscientific evaluative truth. For it is very subjective and probably no psychologist can measure what would be in reality a serious psychological threat. Even if it were possible, the very fact that people going there seem to get the service means that the moral agent filling out the forms are quite broad in their interpretation. No wonder people smile or stare when I usually point out that abortion is illegal in the UK and that abortions can only be carried out under the Abortion Act.
Moreover, when the Society for the Protection of the Unborn Child challenged the drug company which produces the emergency contraction pill, they lost with the verdict that “you cannot miscarry what you do not carry”, showing that a technical detail protected the woman from being “forced” to accept a fertilised egg floating in her tubal and uterine fluids from implanting itself in her.
What is disconcerting is that people have come to view the moral weight we put on a human embryo as similar to the moral weight we put on a cow. There are countries where a cow is sacred. But it is all relative. For India, it is quit natural to celebrate the dung of a cow and even have visitors taste its urine and dung in a mixture of other products from the animal, in order to bless the house. The sacredness of the cow has to be tied to religion to ensure its perpetuity. But Christians have a notorious way of frowning upon their own religion in the name of freedom, that when you speak about a foetus, it is true that many equate this with a religious condition. In many countries, religions have become institutions of worship rather than participant in moral order and law. I have students from Belgium and Holland where the Catholic faith is proclaimed in many areas but where the students tell you that they would not raise controversy about abortion, divorces, surrogate motherhood etc. In many European states that Church has taken deliberately the same level that the Muslim religion has taken in Turkey. We pride ourselves with secular states.
In the meantime the government of Northern Ireland has issued guidelines to help health care professionals and women in the choice of when the life of the woman is at risk. Nurses and doctors who have an objection on termination need not participate in it. This shows that there is a clear difficulty in choosing between the life of a woman in danger and that of the foetus, even where you have these laws. Clearly the Irish government said that it does not want to change the law and neither to liberalise it. Rather the guidelines were in answer to queries that many had in particular clinical situations.
What it all centres around is what weight one will attach to certain clinical situations. Is the woman’s life clearly and imminently in danger, or is there a mere possibility of danger? Or are we looking at evidence – for example that a pregnancy at an older age may be detrimental to a woman’s health? There are pregnancies which by their very nature are high-risk (pregnancies – from twins to some young teenage pregnancies to having a medical condition. If we include all these conditions, lock, stock and barrel, then clearly we cannot have clear ethical guidelines.
Guidelines, must not only fulfil objective criteria but also subjective ones, for a woman with a medical condition may clearly fall under high-risk and therefore “qualify” for a termination, but her life need not necessarily, with the appropriate care, be in danger of death. The problem with laws is that they are followed and interpreted to the word and not to the spirit in which they were living. The latter is left to the moral agent making the choice. And that can be questionable.
It may make ethical sense to many to save the life of the mother even if the principle of double effect is not fulfilled. Many do agree that once you are saving the life of the woman, whether the killing of the foetus is direct or indirect is not relevant. It is relevant however to the extent that it prevents abuse. One clear abuse is the subjective interpretation of what constitutes psychological harm. If it were not due to our contorted nature – the way we all want to interpret things according to our necessities, it may not be necessary to have seal-proof laws and principles which sound hypocritical.
Clearly if the woman is going to die, should it matter whether the death brought about is direct or indirect – as if this were going to make any difference to the innocent foetus whose life still has to be sacrificed. But there is a difference between one’s life being at risk and one’s life being in danger. It is because we do not agree on where to draw the line of this difference that moral rules such as the principle of double effect tend to be too stringent as to not allow the saving of the life of the woman in all circumstances possible.
It is people’s lives which determine attitudes to abortion. The European Court of Human Rights at the end of the day is made up of individuals who have personal lives and you are determined by the environment that they live in. We cannot change attitudes to abortion by street protests and slander.
In his address on the occasion of the ‘Solemnity of the Immaculate Conception of the Blessed Virgin Mary’, on Tuesday 8 December, His Holiness Benedict XVI said, “I want to pay homage publicly to all those who in silence, not with words but with deeds, strive to practise this evangelical law of love that propels the world forward. There are so many of them even here in Rome and they rarely hit the headlines. They are men and women of all ages, who have realised that it is not worth condemning, complaining or accusing; that it is better to respond to evil by doing good. This changes things; or rather it changes people, and hence improves society”. (Italics mine). This, in my humble opinion, is the only path if we really want to remove abortion. Laws may help. But people make laws. If they are made solely through political lobby, they do not change hearts and probably affect little outcomes either – as this case has shown, many will travel to where the law suits them.
Pierre Mallia is Associate Professor in Family Medicine, Patients' Rights and Bioethics at the University of Malta; he is also Ethics Advisor to the Medical Council of Malta. He is also former president of the Malta College of Family Doctors.