At the end of every year it is a good idea to look back and take stock of the year that has gone by and, with the benefit of hindsight, look to the year that is opening in the hope it will be a better one. This cannot be truer for my Ministry, which has worked tirelessly over the last year to bring Malta’s foreign policy ideas to the forefront, especially at European level but also on the Mediterranean and international stage.
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs is probably one of the least known ministries in the government line-up, due to its dealings with high politics. Its exposure during Malta’s EU entry negotiations gave the general public an insight as to its workings and its role in Malta, as well as overseas. In effect, through the workings of MEUSAC which, at the time, was firmly embedded in this Ministry, all the social and economic spheres were in touch and, indeed, participated in what in hindsight could be said to be an exercise in Maltese democracy at its best.
Today, five years into our membership of the European Union, with our foreign policy firmly embedded in the values of the Union, our Ministry has undergone radical changes in order to better represent our islands overseas. A major restructuring of our Ministry and reorganisation of our representative offices abroad has ensured that slowly but surely the Ministry of Foreign Affairs lives up to the challenges and commitment that the EU poses. As the smallest country in the Union, Malta has risen to the challenge and, despite the obvious strain on our human resources, has nonetheless, in a relatively short time, managed to navigate the EU waters well, ensuring that our voice is heard and our interests defended. What exactly are our interests?
Our interests are clearly laid out in our strategic objectives set out a few years ago. The intention was simple – it was time to pen Malta’s foreign policy that would lead us into the 21st century. This would take stock of our reality. We are a small island state with what has, over the centuries, always been a strategic geographic location in the middle of the Mediterranean at the cultural crossroads between Europe and North Africa. This, together with our timeless values of solidarity, democracy and human rights, and our propensity for giving, have shaped and will continue to shape our foreign policy for years to come.
In a nutshell, Malta’s foreign policy is three-pronged – based on the European Union, the Mediterranean and the world at large. Taking this approach allows me to dwell on our achievements in each area over the last year while at the same time looking at the year ahead.
The European Union
During 2009, we continued to pursue our policy of being effective without being presumptuous. Making full use of the opportunity the EU has given us to be able to participate and influence decisions on an international level, this year could be considered an excellent year for our country. Suffice it to mention three firsts for Malta. To begin with, we were given the position of deputy Secretary-General in the newly-formed Union for the Mediterranean (UfM), which brings together over 50 EU and Mediterranean states in an attempt to cooperate on a variety of pressing issues such as pollution, energy security, deforestation and water security. However, the workings of this new Union have stalled, due to the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict, which often dominates relations and which reached an impasse over the last year.
The Spanish presidency, as part of the new triad presidencies under the Lisbon Treaty that has only just come into effect, has pledged to work hard to revive the UfM and work towards concrete projects that bring mutual benefits to both shores of the Mediterranean.
The second achievement can be seen in the area of Euro-Arab relations. Malta has always worked towards more cooperation between the Arab and European worlds. At every opportunity, we have put forward our ideas on projects in the region and on the crisis in peace talks in the Middle East. Recognising Israel’s right to be a secure and functional state, Malta has always spoken out in favour of a two-state solution to the Middle East question. For us, the time has come for a serious effort to bring peace to the region. It is with great sadness that such an agreement has been so elusive and, while looking to work hand-in-had with the Arabs and Israelis on the issue, we hope that 2010 will bring positive signs of peace to a region plagued by over half a century of bloody conflict.
A testimony of our commitment to the region is the setting up of the European Commission – League of Arab States (ECLAS) Liaison Office in Malta in November of this year. For the first time, the European Commission has established an office with the Arab world and this is in Malta. This office will coordinate projects of mutual interest aimed at working towards closer, more fruitful, relationship between the two realities. In this project, Malta will take the lead to ensure that meaningful projects are put into effect and a true dialogue between cultures will emerge. We have always taken our Euro-Mediterranean identity seriously and will work steadily within the Liaison Office’s framework in order to make the words of the Secretary-General of the League of Arab States, Amre Moussa, that “Malta is the embodiment of Mediter-ranean society and culture” ring true. For us, it is important that we continue to act as the go-between the EU and the Arab world to ensure that the Arab League is recognised as a serious interlocutor and that every effort is made to strengthen it. This office is already functioning and we look forward to 2010 for the first projects to be put into effect.
The third first for Malta is the winning of the bid to host the European Asylum Office (EASO). For the last five or so years, we have most certainly been at the frontier of illegal migrants crossing the Mediterranean from Africa to Europe. With our entry into the EU, numbers have increased, as have the problems that come with this phenomenon. Recognition of the fact that we are on the front line of this European problem strengthened our bid for this office and will surely put us at the centre of a solution to it. Efforts on the EU front need to continue especially, through the strengthening of Frontex and persisting with the signing of re-admission agreements with countries of origin and transit. We have pledged our unwavering support to this office, which will be a testimony of our credentials in being able to deal with the issue of migration.
Slowly but surely, Malta is working towards being a consistent and reliable partner in the European Union. This will be even more evident within the framework of the Lisbon Treaty that has just come into effect. My Ministry is more than satisfied with the outcome of the Irish ‘Yes’ vote, which will grant Malta a sixth seat in the European Parliament, which we have been working towards since membership. Additionally, the profile for foreign affairs and external relations of the EU has been raised with the new posts of President of the Council and High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy. This will enable the Union to engage constructively and positively in global affairs and make it more effective on the international stage. While still working with the principle of unanimity, these two new positions will enable the EU to be better placed to work towards a common foreign policy. In this area, Malta stands only to gain, with its contributions to a European Foreign Policy far outweighing its size.
In this context, we look forward to the Spanish Presidency, which will be the first test for the new Treaty and the shape of a new Europe to come.
The Mediterranean
Malta is intrinsically bound to the Mediterranean region. Our culture, character and identity are derived from and dependent upon this great sea, and thus it is in our interests and, indeed, is our duty to work towards more cooperation between the states flanking the Mediterranean. A secure and prosperous Mediterranean region is something towards which Malta has always worked. Recognising the highly-charged issue of the Israeli-Palestinian issue as a Damocles’ sword hanging over any initiative that has emerged for the region – and evidenced clearly by the problems encountered by the UfM – Malta has spoken clearly as to the direction that needs to be taken.
While recognising the importance of the Middle East question, and advocating a clear two-state solution with the possibility for both to live in peace and security, with the space to flourish economically, we feel that there are other pressing issues that need to be tackled quickly. The issues of energy security and environmental security are at the forefront of any cooperation between Mediterranean states. In line with our policy, Malta voted in favour of the Goldstone Report in the United Nations General Assembly on the atrocities perpetrated against the Palestinian population in Gaza during the war. We have always highlighted the plight of the Palestinians and have worked hard to assist in any way we can. Indeed, only last week we donated e25,000 worth of equipment to the University of Bethlehem for their use in higher education.
For Malta, 2009 brought to the table the UfM as well as the EC-LAS Liaison Office, two initiatives that put the region at the centre of European policy and that will give our country more opportunities to push the Mediterranean agenda even more to the European forefront, recognising that there cannot be stability in Europe without stability in the Mediterranean.
To this end, we have also led the efforts of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Mediterranean and its call to gain observer status at the United Nations. This is in keeping with our policy of ensuring the region is represented at all levels and in all fora internationally.
For us, the region is an intricate and interesting one that offers our country a multitude of opportunities for exchange and trade. With this in mind, over the course of this year I have led delegations to Syria, Lebanon and Jordan in the Middle East. These visits were aimed at enhancing our ties with these countries as well as looking to use persuasion in order to break the impasse that has emerged in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, being reflected in the effective start up of the Union for the Mediterranean. In this area, Malta is using its geo-strategic and cultural positioning to its full advantage.
Slowly but surely, Malta has taken its rightful place at the centre of EU-Mediterranean affairs, working on all fronts in order to ensure better cooperation and the opening of more alleyways for mutual benefit. This year, we have also been elected to the chair of the Defence Initiative of the 5+5 Dialogue, which gives us the benefit of setting the agenda for the initiative.
Other trips to the region that I have taken were to Spain, Israel, the Palestinian Territories, Italy, Turkey, Croatia, Portugal, France and Slovakia. Although the nature of the trips varied, according to the state of our bilateral relations, there was always a common thread when conducting talks in these countries – the importance for the Mediterranean to move away from the present impasse and work towards a scenario of more cooperation and solidarity among the nations that it borders. Through its mixed commissions with Tunisia and Libya, Malta has proved that economic, political and social cooperation is indeed possible. What is now needed is to widen this to a full-blown Mediterranean agenda.
The International Stage
Since gaining our independence in 1964, Malta has participated fully in all the international organisations of which it is a member, be it the United Nations and its organisations, the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) or the Commonwealth. In all cases we have not only participated but have also contributed to the better functioning of the organisation in spite of our size. Suffice it to mention the universal proposals of the Law of the Sea and the question of aging as a matter of international concern, brought to the UN agenda by President Emeritus Censu Tabone, as well as the subsequent election of President Emeritus Guido de Marco as President of the United Nations to realise how active Malta has been within the United Nations and how relevant to the political scene.
This year marked another proposal to the United Nations, with the Prime Minister calling on the General Assembly to revise the Law of the Sea in order to make it more relevant to the challenges being faced today, such as international piracy as well as terrorism and illegal migration.
During the next year we will be looking at continuing our work within the international and regional organisations with the same commitment as always.
On a final note, we are pleased to note that, in time, and especially over the last five years as members of the European Union, Malta has managed to develop a dynamic and serious foreign policy that is ambitious but not pretentious. Recognising our limitations but not allowing them to discourage our efforts to be relevant on a European and international stage, we have built, and will continue to build upon our diplomatic network ensuring that we reap the greatest benefits for our country. Malta has now earned a reputation as a reliable and worthy partner and it is this reputation that we will strive to maintain and develop. While looking back at 2009 as a good year for foreign policy, we look forward to 2010 with optimism and enthusiasm of the challenges that it will bring.
Dr Borg is Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Affairs Minister