The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

The Malta Community Chest Fund And l-iStrina 2009

Malta Independent Friday, 8 January 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Though I have no desire to fuel the present controversy with the Malta Community Chest Fund, the statement released by the Department of Information on 1 January 2010 in response to The Times article of 31 December 2009 and the way it has conditioned public reaction to it since has left me with no option but to reply.

First I want to clarify that I have every respect for the President and admiration for his honest dedication to assist good causes and individuals in need, and for the work and drive of the MCCF and the hundreds of volunteers it mobilises for its noble cause. However, among the many responsibilities laid on my office by the Voluntary Organisations Act (2007) one charges me with “monitoring the promotion of voluntary organisations and the behaviour of administrators of such organisations to ensure the observance of high standards of accountability and transparency and compliance with law” (Article 7(h)). This is the only consideration that has motivated my action as Commissioner with respect to the MCCF, no other.

I have never contested the Attorney General’s advice to MCCF that it “is not in duty bound to enroll and register itself as a Voluntary Organisation”. This is not the issue with regards to l-iStrina. The issue arises from Article 4 of the law which states that to “be the beneficiary of grants, sponsorships or other financial aid from Government, any entity controlled by the Government or the Voluntary Organisations Fund” a voluntary organisation must be enrolled with the Commissioner.

Though the MCCF and the Dar tal-Providenza have every right not to enroll with the Commissioner, the PBS as a state entity is in breach of the law in allowing either of them to use its resources, never mind, in the case of the MCCF, turning l-iStrina entirely over to it. In the case of Dar tal-Providenza, which is a Church organisation following the Curia’s directive not to enroll with the Commissioner, this is a flagrant example of abuse of the law by the PBS because there was no Ministerial exemption for Dar il-Providenza, as there was in the case of the MCCF. Again this is not a reflection of my personal view of the institution which I admire very much.

The DOI statement is wrong to refer to the Commissioner as a civil servant. He is not, nor is the Council for the Voluntary Sector Chairperson. Although my office falls within the Ministry for Social Policy, I was appointed Commissioner by the Minister consulting with the Social Affairs Committee of the House of Representatives. The law reads “In the exercise of his functions, the Commissioner shall act impartially and shall not be subject to the direction of any other person or authority.” (Article 7(2)) It thus both guarantees my autonomy (otherwise I would not have accepted the job), and obliges me to observe it against the MCCF’s advice to defer to the authority of the Attorney General.

In its daily scan of the press, my office has been, and still is, unable to turn up a list of beneficiaries for l-iStrina 2009. Nor is any such list included in the MCCF web site as one would expect. In short, it is not in the public realm. The MCCF’s publication of its audited accounts in leading newspapers is what is required by law and in accordance with the Public Collections Act. However, “transparency and accountability” means more.

The DOI statement criticises me for ignoring “repeated invitations” to nominate a representative of the Council for the Voluntary Sector ex-ufficio on the MCCF board. However, it is not in my legal power to make any such nomination. This should, if anything, come from the Council itself. For correctness sake there was only one such invitation addressed to me by letter on 17 August.

I first discussed the MCCF with the President personally in a courtesy visit he kindly made to my office on 23 March 2009 when I encouraged him to consider enrolling the Fund. In early September 2009 my office received an inquiry from the MCCF signaling that it was considering enrolment. My legal consultants advised me that, with some changes to its statute, the MCCF could enroll with the Commissioner. The MCCF’s inquiry, however, was not pursued further.

In a letter dated 3 July 2009 I wrote to the President encouraging him to commence enrolment procedures. I ended my letter with this appeal: “Such enrolment will also send a strong signal of your support in the current drive my office is making to encourage voluntary organisations to follow suit in the interest of transparency and accountability in the administration of funds collected from the public”.

On 22 September 2009 I wrote again in reply to a 17 August 2009 letter from MCCF enclosing my legal consultants’ full advice that the MCCF qualifies for enrolment with the Commissioner in terms of the law. It included advice on the problems that would be encountered with l-iStrina were it not to enroll. My covering letter said “I think that at this stage a personal meeting between myself and His Excellency the President, as MCCF, Chairman, rather than a further exchange of letters, is probably the best way forward.”

This letter was acknowledged on 27 October 2009 but not replied to. On 7 November 2009 I wrote again repeating my advice on l-iStrina, which letter was unacknowledged. On 10 December 2009 I wrote to the Chairperson of PBS once more pointing out its violation of the law if l-iStrina went on. I had no desire to interfere with the event. As in everything else, I did my duty. At this point the Minister for Social Policy intervened and used his powers under the law to grant the MCCF blanket dispensation from its provisions for l-iStrina 2009.

Prof. Kenneth Wain is Commissioner for Voluntary Organisations

  • don't miss