The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

The Men who stare at fields

Malta Independent Sunday, 31 January 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 18 years ago

I am not a George Clooney fan. I prefer the curves of Elisabetta Canalis, the Italian showgirl he is currently living with. But the title of his latest film, The men who stare at goats, intrigued me. Who would want to watch a film with that name? Who would want to stare at goats? It’s not as if they are among the most beautiful of animal species. Yet, it could be that such a name was chosen precisely to make people curious and go to watch the film. Producers will do anything to turn a profit.

Whatever the case, the title of this film came to mind over the past few weeks when I was reporting on the way environmentalists pick and choose who to attack in their quest to keep everything green; how environmentalists think that they should not be harassed in the same way they harass other people and, more importantly, how one of their leaders bought pristine land in Marsascala with the intention of developing it "when the permits are issued".

I took the liberty of changing the last word of the film title, and use ‘fields’ instead of ‘goats’. Because this is precisely what Ramblers Association president Lino Bugeja, and all those who support him, would like us to think: that Mr Bugeja bought that land in Marsascala just to stare at it.

Yes, Mr Bugeja never applied for a building permit. That’s a fact. But the intention to build on that piece of land was there when he signed the contract. Otherwise, he would not have bothered to include the phrase "building permits" four times. And that’s a fact too.

Let’s face it – who would buy a parcel of land just to stare at it? Nobody. You either buy it for agricultural purposes, or to sell it again at a higher price, or to develop it. And, by adding "building permits" in the contract, and allowing the land user to continue tilling it "until the permits are issued", it clearly indicates that Mr Bugeja had every intention of developing that land.

No matter how Mr Bugeja defends himself, while his supporters show sympathy and write letters to express their support – turning things around to say that the fact that he never developed the land in question proves his integrity – it is evident that Mr Bugeja had every intention of building on that land.

Without intending to, one such letter, published in this newspaper last week, confirmed what I am saying. It said that, in the 1960s, people bought land "in the hope that some day it would be included in a development zone".

So, there you have it from someone who wrote in defence of Mr Bugeja. Buy the land, wait a few years and, when possible, develop it. That is what Mr Bugeja must have thought when he bought it, and why he, and the people he bought the land with, allowed the user of the field to continue tilling it "until the building permits are issued". The intention to develop it was there all along.

This piece of land was not built on only because it was never included in a development zone. Otherwise, it would be a block of flats or a house – like the many that those environmentalists complain about.

There’s another thing. How many times have environmentalists complained that successive governments widened development zones to cover areas that were previously not earmarked for building? Would have they complained had this piece of land been included in a development zone? Or would they have kept their mouths shut just because it belongs to one of them?

Speaking of mouths kept shut, why do environmentalists use two weights and two measures when it comes to protesting about what they call the abuse of the environment?

At the height of their protests on the Victor Scerri development in Bahrija, Mepa served Anton Refalo, a Labour MP, with an enforcement notice for carrying out work in an outside development zone in Qala.

If they felt they had to complain about the Victor Scerri development, then they should have complained about the Anton Refalo development as well. If they think that building in an outside development zone in Bahrija is wrong – although Dr Scerri had obtained the permits to carry out the work – then it is also wrong to build in an outside development zone in Qala, this time without the necessary permits, and have the development sanctioned at a later stage.

This lack of consistency dents the credibility of environmentalists, and leads to suspicions that they have a political agenda hidden behind their green credentials. Environmentalists often complain that Mepa is not consistent in its decisions, and they are probably right, but then they should not do the same thing.

* * *

You remember the MUT-Oliver Twist article I wrote a few weeks ago?

Well, unfortunately, what I predicted has come true, as I had no doubt it would.

This week, the union ordered industrial action over an issue it has with the government about remuneration.

And, just as I had written, it did so on the eve of the mid-term examinations. It said that it wants to take the necessary precautions in order to avoid disrupting students, but by ordering industrial action at a time when students are already tense because examinations are around the corner, it has done the complete opposite of what it is saying.

Once again, the students will be the main victims of the MUT’s action. But then what else can you expect from a greedy union?

[email protected].

  • don't miss