Since the hearings for the Barroso II commission began, the various groups that make up the EU Parliament have been having some fun giving Commissioner-designates from opposing groups a tough time during the vetting process to test their ability for the job.
The Bulgarian Minister for Foreign Affairs, Rumiana Jeleva, was savaged on the grounds of alleged financial corruption; she broke down in tears and later sent a bitter letter of resignation. Marcos Sefcovic who wants the administration portfolio may be in trouble because he had once alleged that the Roma were the exploiters of the Slovak welfare system. Of such stuff is political correctness composed. Dutch girl Nellie Kroes, seeking a second term, failed to pass due to poor performance but is going to be given a second chance.
Up to now, the EU Parliament has expressed doubt about six commissioners: Two have PPE (centre right) affiliation, two have S&D (socialist) affiliation and two commissioners are linked to the ALDE-group (liberals). That seems fair doesn’t it? However, since Parliament has to provide a hearing for Rumiana Jeleva’s substitute, which jeopardises having the new Commission in place by February, the groups might well decide to use the guillotine on more heads on the principle that delaying for one is equal to delaying for many. In the normal world that is called tit-for-tat.
Then there are other things of a more comprehensible nature locally. Maria Damanaki, born in Crete and angling to get the fishing portfolio, gave a good show at her hearing, apparently often quoting from Malta’s former Commissioner Joe Borg. Now that is an independent mark for achievement. One looks forward to John Dalli performing just as well, certainly better than he did in the post he left behind.
Parliament flexes its muscles
Political games apart however, this is the right time for the EU Parliament to develop its muscles and, since it is the only directly elected component of the EU, the more muscle it acquires the less the EU’s democratic deficit will be. Parliament has come a long way and all European citizens hope that it will have the motivation to go further. Only when elected representatives govern the EU will it become the people’s voice as opposed to an elitist vision of power. One problem will linger on however. There are far too many MEPs of mediocre quality since, as a general rule, a country only sends to Brussels people it either can do without or those it wants to do without.
Clashes are therefore inevitable. The Lisbon Treaty, for example, states that international agreements of which the EU is part need the assent of the European Parliament. For the MEPs to demand that heads of delegations in the European External Action Service appear for hearings of approval in Parliament seems a logical step. But Baroness Ashton, the new Foreign Secretary, flatly rejected this demand. It is in this light that one should consider the jibes aimed at her not going to Haiti to see the victims of the terrible earthquake that has devastated an already poor nation.
The EU Parliament has quite a wish list and is quietly threatening to refuse to play cricket if it is not fulfilled. It is in this sense that one should understand the threats to boycott this or that Commissioner-designate. Parliament is reminding Barroso that his Commission might well be voted out unless he concedes some of the items on the wish list. The result of the present on-going vetting has yet to be seen. The EU however works on a quid pro quo basis so there will be no revolutions. This is the year after all, when we shall begin to see the implementation of the Treaty of Lisbon. The gravest question for the EU is not how to regulate its administration and strengthen its voice, but how to win the confidence of the electorate, how to interest the citizens of Europe to an extent that will get them to start bothering to go out and vote for it, even perhaps to consider it as relevant to their needs. And one of the greatest of needs at the moment is job reassurance, which is tied to the very thorny question of immigration.
A small matter of values
A referendum in neutrally-minded Switzerland has just forbidden the construction of new minarets. Racial violence has exploded in the southern Italian region of Calabria. An intense and controversial debate is taking place in France on the issue of national identity. The UK has refused to accept an EU ruling regarding stop-and-search of possible suspects and has instructed its security forces to carry on with random searches. These events may have little in common, yet they all point to a growing European trend, the fear on the part of Europe’s citizens that they might end up a minority in the continent they created and developed.
Identity is not a matter of mere ethnicity or religion. Europe’s wars of religion taught the continent how divisive such matters are. For those who want to join the European project, it is values that count. If a country is split between two huge, culturally different camps – the native people and the immigrants, then it will likely see a power struggle for cultural domination. When immigration is controlled, then there is a better chance of slowly bringing up newcomers in the values and traditions that have created the laws, the culture, and the way of thinking of the host nation.
The EU must be an instrument for social harmony, a close observer of people’s needs and not a well-paid bureaucracy immersed in its own dreams and defending a life of its own. Its Parliament must make itself relevant if the European dream is to become what people and states originally approved.
Dr Muscat is leader of Azzjoni Nazzjonali