The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

Time To take the medicine

Malta Independent Sunday, 7 March 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

As from last Monday, people just stopped buying.

That’s an exaggeration, of course, but there has been a significant decrease in purchases and purchasers. Ask outlet owners. Ask Monti owners, if you like. You will get the same response. People are all of a sudden holding back.

For it was last Monday when the collective consciousness of the country understood that the water and electricity rates were there to stay.

For weeks, if not months, the country had been taken up the garden path by the pernicious illusion that rates were a sort of optional and that the government, as indeed it used to do in the times when it fixed almost all prices, could put the rates down if it wanted.

At the last minute, after popular pressure on the streets of Valletta did not look like working, a subversive element crept in and a second mass demonstration was held on Monday, in the expectation, that is Tony Zarb’s fateful words on Bondiplus, that one or other of the government MPs would vote against the government.

For to protest is one thing, to try and shake a government majority of one by bringing about this kind of public pressure is subversion by my book.

End of the illusion: the government did not fall, all government MPs did their duty, and the rates have to be paid.

Hence the dawning on collective consciousness that the bills must be paid. Hence the hiatus on spending.

To which one must also add, for objectivity and fairness’ sake, that, as I have been writing for many weeks, the situation has been rendered even more complicated by the delays in the issuing of bills, due to the changeover at this crucial time, of the system of billing, a hair-brained idea if there ever was one, which now means that every family in this country owes six months’ consumption and has no idea how much that could be.

One can at best extrapolate from past bills but one has still to factor in the increase which came into effect on 1 January.

This affects people at all levels: I have even heard a high official with a very good salary telling me he cannot afford air-conditioning. Others with an equally high salary told me they simply cannot make ends meet, try as they can.

One has to carefully analyse and examine the bills. The bill of a one-car garage in Qormi shown on TVM last Friday for €2 million is real. The garage, incidentally, belongs to a cousin of John Dalli. How such a bill could be issued is mysterious: don’t they check the bills before they go out?

Last Tuesday, our sister paper also revealed that the people at the lower end of the social structure, the elderly and the people on social assistance, who last year (and this one too) have been given an energy voucher are finding real problems in encashing them. For the problem, you see, is that they are valid only for six months and, since the bills stopped coming for quite some time, the vouchers became obsolete. So when the old and the people on social assistance took the bills and the vouchers to pay, they were turned back and told the vouchers were useless.

This is a fact, although Minister Dolores Cristina told me she had given an order that the vouchers had to have a new date stamped on them and they would become valid again, and although the Prime Minister assured me during his press conference the government has no intention of skimping on the €7 million allocated for these vouchers last year and this one and indeed has added a further €10 million for energy benefits based on consumption which should benefit 97% of households.

Anyway, the situation, brought to light by TMID has now been cleared: the government issued a clarificatory press release and Social Services are rushing out amended vouchers. Thanks to TMID. And no thanks to One News who seems to find greater scope for its news coverage in roaming the streets around the Law Courts than in going to the WSC offices in Freedom Square (before they close it down) and listen to the many and vociferous complaints by the crowds queuing to either pay their bills or to complain, mostly the latter.

Speaking of which, it is indeed extraordinary for Minister Tonio Fenech, now responsible for Enemalta, to say, as he was reported as saying on Realta, that no one had complained to him about the rates. He has either stopped talking to ordinary constituents or else he should perhaps make it a point to go down to Freedom Square and face the people.

At the end of it all, the country’s oil bill has to be paid by those who consume, that is by us. We can continue arguing till the cows come home whether Enemalta should put its finances in order (indeed it should) and cut out wastage, inefficiencies, and above all not hide any other cost in the price. Now that there is a change of minister, it is time to put some order in Enemalta’s complex finances, and at least get the corporation to finalise its accounts and give itself a business structure and strategy.

But for all of us it is now time to take the medicine. This is a hump that we have to get over. We must understand that the oil bill has to be paid by whoever consumes it. In full. And that only by facing the real price can we ever hope to get consumption under control as households, as families, as a nation. Only when we face the real cost will we understand whether we are actually competitive in the world market, and whether our salaries can cope with our stressful life. Then, as always, adjustments will be made but there can be no adjustment were we to continue to live in a dream world where prices are artificially kept low or are paid out of somewhere else in the national expenditure.

But the whole rates issue cannot be looked at in isolation from everything else. Granted we must pay what we consume, what are the wider picture. What is the prognosis for the Maltese economy as Malta, and the rest of the world, prepare to exit from the recession, a tentative exit, to be sure, still fragile and delicate?

At a recent The Malta Business Weekly business breakfast in conjunction with the Malta Chamber of Commerce, Enterprise and Industry, rather poorly reported, economist Gordon Cordina explained the findings of a Business Confidence survey conducted by PriceWaterhouseCoopers.

Responses from most sectors indicated there was a tentative recovery across the EU 27 and also in Malta over the last three quarters of 2009 but registered a slight decrease in January. To link this to the new electricity rates is obvious.

In the manufacturing sector, wages remained stable but jobs were cut. And, equally important, profits were down by 70% compared to the previous year. While the average compensation to employees rose by 1.4%, due to collective agreements, COLA and restructuring, the average value added per employee fell by 5.7% per annum.

While the current recessionary conditions have been registering an adverse impact on the Maltese economy, these effects have not been as pronounced as those of the EU economy as a whole. In good part, however, this may be due to the stability of the financial system in Malta rather than to the fundamental competitiveness of industry.

Hotels and restaurants are seasonal in their profitability but not in wages. There has been a cyclical downturn in profits of some €20 million.

Wholesale and retail, which employ some 20,000 people, remained stable but the downturn has affected profitability.

How much can companies continue to suffer lost profits while keeping people in employment unless the recession ends soon?

The services sector has remained very resilient. It employs 60,000 persons and wages here have increased by 5.3% and profits by 10.2%. Business confidence in research and development activities exhibited an unusually strong upward trend in the last two quarters. This indicates that most of the services sector is responding to the recovery. It may also reflect the fact that the sector is less susceptible to the negative effects of the rising utility rates which may have caused the manufacturing confidence index to contract.

As for the public sector, wages have increased by 6.4% from 2007 to 2009 due to the collective agreement but one asks whether this has been accompanied by any increased productivity.

More importantly, the public sector’s share in the economy has risen from 20 to 25% while manufacturing has decreased from 17 to 13% and services increased from 41 to 43%. The gross value added has increased by 2.7% but inflation, at 3.6%, was higher.

Indeed, Malta’s economy has proved to be more resilient than in other EU countries, but one must ask whether this will remain so when other countries return to financial stability and regain a competitive edge, find again availability of credit and new sources of growth.

Crucially, investment in Malta is at a lower level than in competing countries. Whereas investment as a proportion of GDP remained steady at around 20 per cent in the eurozone countries between 2007 and 2009, in Malta the proportion was 15 per cent, a fall of five per cent. As for the Maltese economy in general, this has been stuck for a number of years at 76% of the EU 27 average and can never improve unless there is an increase in productivity. Prof. Cordina said that we either increase productivity by 26% or increase jobs by 25,000 or somewhere in between to get the growth we need.

Malta is not doing well either in the competitiveness stakes and other countries from the new EU member states are catching up. Innovation will be critical in the coming years. We must have access to energy security through a diversification of sources and also through getting lower costs. We must find other sources of growth other than an expansionary fiscal stance.

The efficiency and effectiveness of the public sector will be more and more crucial: productivity gains will depend on an efficient government.

Prof. Cordina ended: There is a very limited margin of error and the government must base its performance more and more on efficiency. Knowledge will be critical.

Above all, one could add, any instability introduced at this time could complicate matters incredibly at a time when we can ill afford such distractions.

Which brings me back to my first point.

[email protected]

  • don't miss