The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

People Are smarter than the Smart

Malta Independent Sunday, 21 March 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 15 years ago

My wife and I had just enjoyed seeing an exhibition of the work of the great Catalan architect Antonio Gaudi, which featured among others his Park Guell, Casa Batllo and the great La Sagrada Familia church, a masterpiece of imagination and interpretation, symbolising and transforming nature into a place for quiet meditation and prayer. It all looked so exotic and otherwordly. It was only when I started thinking about this great architect’s life and work that I started to really appreciate his great architectural achievements.

Inevitably, perhaps, my thoughts flew to our tiny Malta and Piano’s plans for the entrance to Valletta. I tried to enter this undoubtedly great architect’s mind and understand what he might have recommended to our Prime Minister. Recalling his address (as reported in the press) to invited personalities in Republic Street, he spoke about sounds, music and his inner feelings as he studied Valletta, even if the language he used may have been incomprehensible to many, or even the majority, as is the case when artists eschew the normal speech of mankind.

Despite all this, I cannot remember any project that drew so much criticism and so many objections, both when an attempt was made some 15 years ago and again today. The Qui-si-Sana car park project raised an uproar, but mainly affected a few. The proposed underground car park at St Julian’s was abandoned when residents objected vehemently. The plan for a museum beneath St John’s Co-Cathedral was dropped after objections from several quarters, including the Church. But the Valletta entrance project, maybe because of all the above aborted projects, has not met with the same fate. I personally still hope it will become a reality, albeit in a different and more welcome way. It seems that Dr Gonzi is now in an awkward position from which he believes he cannot politically or even personally retreat. Can we possibly shelve Piano’s plans again? I can understand the embarrassment, but then, would that embarrassment have arisen if things had been done differently?

H.L. Mencken claims that no one in this world has ever lost money by underestimating the intelligence of the great masses of ordinary people. It has become increasingly accepted that large groups of people are smarter then an elite few (no matter how brilliant); better at solving problems, fostering innovation, arriving at wise decisions and even predicting the future. Any study of our history, however brief, demonstrates that, as a people, we have always made the right choice from what was available to us at any specific time.

It is an undeniable fact that the voice of the people, sounded through the large number of letters and objections that have appeared in the media, are all expressions of the people’s adverse feelings to the project. Ignoring, or worse still, misinterpreting these objections would unpardonably and deeply hurt the feelings of the many that bothered to express their sincere thoughts and feelings. It is unfortunate that, in this tiny island of ours, everything is politicised and disagreement is interpreted as tantamount to injuring the honourable gentlemen in Parliament.

Let us not forget that it was Piano himself who admitted that 15 years ago he had got it wrong. Did any of the cognoscenti think so then? Weren’t we told then, as we are told now, that to criticise the great master is unthinkable? Yet it was the voice of the objecting citizen who has been proved right, and by Piano himself. Had the previous project materialised, we might be thinking today of replacing it as we are doing with the present Valletta entrance, which replaced the old entrance to give access to Carnival floats!

Surprisingly, when Piano was asked for the second time to come up with a plan for the Valletta entrance, the public was not only not informed about a new building to house parliament but also subsequently informed that no brief actually existed. In last week’s interview, the Prime Minister informed us that he had left it all to Piano. Not quite, of course, because the provision to build a parliament was the chief condition. I suspect it was more ‘build us a parliament and see what you can do with the rest’ sort of thing.

That is really a pity. It took courage on Dr Gonzi’s part to renew the challenge of redeveloping the Old Opera House site in the teeth of a political superstition that says that whoever dares build the Opera House would lose the government. His choice to ignore the cry of the people might very well yet give the truth to the superstition. However, I believe that the Prime Minister is still in time to save the day. For while there is a real outcry against the entrance itself, (would Piano dare name an Italian walled city that would accept its entrance being breached in the way he is proposing for the Valletta gate?), the main objections centre on the plans to allow a ruin to replace the beautiful Barry building that so dignified Valletta’s entrance, together with a parliament that nobody believes is necessary or even affordable.

Maybe our Prime Minister might yet accept, at the eleventh hour, a solution that might garner the approval of the vast majority and be acceptable to both Piano and the Prime Minister.

I think Piano’s idea of making a monument out of the ruins of our Opera House could still stand if it is incorporated within a fully fledged national theatre that would turn the whole area into something like the vibrant Covent Garden, with its street theatre, its craft stalls and commercial establishments. That would bring upper Valletta to life with a vengeance. Parliament could well be built on the site of the Central Bank. This would give it an imposing position, which would still retain Piano’s vision and would also balance the Office of the Prime Minister across the wide space that is Castille. It would also restore to St James Cavalier the freedom it still enjoys. In effect, however, it would be simply an interchange of sites.

I believe that in this way we would be giving new life to the entrance of our City, since music and entertainment would not disturb parliamentary sittings and, at the same time, the security that a parliament demands would not intrude on the public’s right to enjoy and use the area. The Central Bank could be accommodated elsewhere, perhaps even in lower Valletta, which is crying out for restoration. In this way the Prime Minister would still have his parliament, while Valletta would have the National Theatre it needs.

Renzo Piano has stated that not only is listening important, but that he is prepared to change the plans if the need is indicated by widespread dialogue. He actually said humility is important. Dr Gonzi seems to have shown humility when he listened to his MPs; will he show the same humility by listening to the voice of the people?

  • don't miss