The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Neither Heaven nor earth

Malta Independent Friday, 26 March 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 18 years ago

The so-called Mother of Parliaments in the UK was rocked by fresh scandals last week. Twenty MPs, some of whom were former ministers, were invited to attend meetings to discuss joining an advisory board and 10 duly turned up. An undercover Sunday Times (UK) journalist asked them how the company could go about influencing policy and how it could improve its chances of winning a government contract. The answers were devastating.

Cabs for hire

Stephen Byers, a former minister for transport, allegedly told the bogus lobbyists he had saved hundreds of millions of pounds for a transport company and had influenced food labelling proposals for a supermarket chain after phoning the minister for business. For £5000 a day he was prepared to represent anyone.

Among those present in this undercover operation was the former minister for defence, Geoff Hoon (he asked for £8000 a day) and Patricia Hewitt former minister for health and now working for a health company. It was reported that Byers had actually described himself, and presumably the others, as a cab for hire. They have all denied involvement but at the time of writing they have been suspended by Gordon Brown.

Following the expenses scandal, where MPs were shown to be making huge sums of money by jiggling their expenses system, the British parliament could ill afford more scandals. Britain is a country where the rule of law is held to be sacrosanct and its citizens like to believe that their leaders obey the rules that govern the lives of all the people in the country. And in fact, the constant excuse that the defaulting MPs gave for enriching themselves through fake expenses was that they had played by the book and had not broken any rules.

This has brought once more to the fore the question of conflicts of interest. Should MPs and others in politics use the contacts they make in office to secure jobs once they leave? In other words, should they smile at influential people on the way up in the hope that they will be rewarded with smiles on the way out? Doesn’t this raise the possibility of using public office for eventual private gain? This in turn puts on the table another problem: That of MPs or other political figures who are not sufficiently professionally qualified to make an independent living once their parliamentary salaries and perks come to an end.

The fact that parliaments everywhere have been reluctant to put into practice all the recommendations of the Nolan report which stated that public life should be run on the seven principles of selflessness, integrity, objectivity, accountability, openness, honesty and leadership, speaks for itself. A country is truly free, just and democratic when its citizens see holders of public office offering sacrifices to these principles.

It was hard for the British public to accept that the venerable institution of Parliament of which they are so proud, built as it is on the blood spilt during a civil war which ended with the execution of a king, could have sunken so low. Trust, once lost, is not easily regained. It is no wonder that all the talk in the UK at the moment is of a hung parliament and one of the most prominent members of the Liberal Democrats, Vince Cable, is already being sounded for his views should he end up Chancellor of the Exchequer. That may be a wee premature as the British political tradition has little place for coalitions but in the present environment of mistrust and disgust anything can happen.

Interestingly, an article in another section of the local English speaking press suggested that the appointment of parliamentary assistants came about because of the panic that overtook some PN deputies at the realisation that should the party not win the next election, their career would not survive a period of five to 10 years in the opposition. While of course losing office is not something that attracts, it is not a reason for throwing the country to the dogs either. But then if politics has become just another career choice, should one be surprised that love of country plays second fiddle to personal ambitions?

In the UK, Foreign Secretary David Milliband, a serious contender for the Labour crown should it become vacant, disowned the cash for influence reports and insisted that in his view, people come into politics because of what they want to do for the country. Other scandals however like the ones called cash for titles where if the sum was right the donor was made a Peer of the Realm, and cash for parliamentary questions, seem to have shown him to be sadly out of touch with the present mood.

Both the main parties are now promising to regulate lobbying. One British MP stated that we need to know who is lobbying whom about what. Perhaps he should come and ask that in Malta.

A Church in crisis?

Another truly venerable organisation was desperately defending its position last week as well. That was the Catholic Church, my Church, which was reeling under a veritable mountain of scandal. Whether it will have the strength to initiate reforms that many have long been urging her to bring in if it is to prevent a deep and serious fracture remains to be seen. The furore does not seem likely to go away soon and the longer it lasts the greater will be the damage done to the fabric of the oldest organisation in Europe, one whose roots are the basis of our culture. The storm has engulfed almost every country in Europe together with Australia, New Zealand and the whole of the American continent. Yet it had to be revelations of unsavoury goings-on in the very shadow of Peter’s Chair that finally encouraged the Church to stir.

With its empty church pews, Europe is now considered to be a missionary country. The continent is inhabited by a generation of young people with an incalculable amount of information at their finger tips, an easy access to all sorts of research and a higher level of education than in the past. These young people are members of a multinational and a multicultural society and they are less willing to accept an authority that does not speak for all of them and that can be at odds with what they believe and how they reason. I presume that while they are more than ready to accept that we are all human and therefore frail and prone to error (youth can be very generous and forgiving), they might find it easier to forgive personal failings rather than the application of polices that offend their sense of justice.

Weakening power centres

The fact that nowadays society is so fractured and politicians so distant has encouraged the growth of the NGOs, pressure groups with very specific agendas and with no intention of winning power. Indeed they go out of their way to distance themselves from the political class and in some ways that is their strength. Certainly in Malta that counts for a lot, as can be seen by the at times desperate attempts to attach a political label to them. This phenomenon is still relatively new to Malta and many people seem unable to accept that criticism can actually be devoid of any party-political agenda.

The force surrounding a magnet is not uniform. It is greatly concentrated at each end of the magnet, leaving the centre very weak. Magnets have two magnetic poles and both poles have equal magnetic strength. One always points to the north and the other end always points to the south. Malta follows the rules of magnetism and has not yet found a way of empowering the centre.

Hopefully that vacuum will be filled by more NGOs and other pressure groups. Malta needs to do more than struggle to conserve its heritage, its natural environment (which includes the seas around us), and its wild life. There are many important issues that people have not yet had the courage to attempt to redress. But it will come. Undoubtedly it will come.

  • don't miss