The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

Letting The people decide

Malta Independent Friday, 23 April 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 18 years ago

“Nick Clegg however remains suspicious of Brown. His answer was that Labour had done nothing for 13 years and then right at the last moment was proposing a referendum on a system that offered the very bare minimum of change in that it was not even a fully proportional change”

The UK’s approaching elections – scheduled for the 6 May – have been galvanised by the unexpected surge in popularity for the Liberal Democrats or the Lib Dems as they are known. What has changed this party of also-rans into one that is threatening to break the stranglehold of the Conservative and Labour parties on British politics?

All voices should be equal

Well the immediate cause has been the innovative Three Leaders Debate on TV. Like in Malta, the third party does not really get much of a chance to reach people during election time which is the time when it is most crucial for the electorate to hear all voices before they form their final opinion. By giving the Liberal Democrats equal billing with Labour and the Tories, the debate gave Nick Clegg, the Lib Dem leader, the chance to pose as the new advocate of change, marshalling messages on the need for reform of the voting system and the way politics are conducted. Millions of viewers were finally given the chance of listening to the “silent” voice of British politics. And it seems that so far, they have liked what they heard.

I followed the debate on YouTube. To me the supreme moment was when the Lib Dem leader, Nick Clegg, stopped the usual rhetorical rush of promises by asking Brown and Cameron why they had voted against Lib Dem proposals in Parliament that would have given people what they were now promising to deliver if they obtained power. His persistent spur was “How can you be believed when you had the chance and failed to take it?”

Perhaps that is why Gordon Brown repeatedly said “I agree with Nick” during the debate. He seems to be already thinking of the possibility of a coalition with the Lib Dems. In fact, in an interview with the Sunday Telegraph newspaper he emphasised the common ground between Labour and the Lib Dems on electoral reform.

“I want people to know that I’ve thought very hard about constitutional issues since the MPs’ expenses scandal and I do think we’ve got to address the public’s trust in politics – and I think Labour and the Liberal Democrats have similar policies about the scale of political reform that is needed,” Gordon Brown coyly said.

What value electoral promises?

Nick Clegg however remains suspicious of Brown. His answer was that Labour had done nothing for 13 years and then right at the last moment was proposing a referendum on a system that offered the very bare minimum of change in that it was not even a fully proportional change. The Lib Dems want to see a real wholesale reform of party funding, of electoral reform, making the House of Lords a fully elected chamber to kill once and for all the granting of privileges to the wealthy, and giving people the right to sack their MPs if their MPs have been shown to be corrupt. That is where a third party can help democracy. It can provide people with a real choice about the issues they feel strongly about. Duopolies rarely address that sufficiently well. It’s too cosy a system.

The Quango State

Another factor is that this is no ordinary election in the UK. A huge number of voters are disillusioned with politicians following the expenses scandal. It is equal to much of the disgust that European voters feel for the elites living well off the gold mine of Brussels and which is largely responsible for a persistent fall in the voting rate in EU elections. In the UK, that disgust with politics seems to be making voters less inclined to follow the usual routine of switching support between Labour and the Tories. Because Clegg was, before last week, little known to most voters, he is also seen as being largely untainted.

And there is need for reform, and not only in the UK. The combination of the inherited powers from the monarchical era, the modern media’s concentration on the Prime Minister and the overuse of the party whip in Britain at least, has turned that country together with many others into one of the most centralised countries in Europe. The quango state – unelected and unaccountable bodies which have a direct impact on ordinary people’s lives – has become a common feature of our political life, and that includes our tiny island, where government seems determined to shed all blame for its actions by passing its responsibilities to unaccountable others.

Whereto representative democracy?

Is representative democracy in long-term decline? I wonder. When a simple agreement in Parliament between the representatives of our two parties was enough to deny our people their opinion on the Treaty of Lisbon which is already beginning to look feeble in the face of the new challenges; and when a simple agreement changes the clauses of our Constitution to favour the PNLP in elections; and when despite the voices raised in protest, the government forces on to the nation a new parliament building whose cost will inevitably be met from the citizens’ taxes, can there possibly be any other conclusion?

We are continually told that people are being consulted, all the time and about everything as if that were the beginning and end of the democratic process. But consultation does not equal participation. Nothing encourages cynicism more than a public body asking for views on an issue that has already been decided upon. The public should be given a real say in issues that concern them, using tools that provide genuine participation. Citizens should be given the right to petition for Parliamentary debates, public inquiries and, where necessary, referendums on issues that concern them.

Power need restraints

“If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, no controls on government would be necessary. In framing a government of men over men, the great difficulty lies in this: You must first enable the government to control the governed, and in the next place oblige it to control itself. Just as we have civil laws to restrain men in society, so we have constitutional laws to restrain men in power” – Former US President James Madison (1751-1836).

  • don't miss