The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

The Delimara Extension: When Accountability turns into arrogance

Malta Independent Sunday, 25 April 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 18 years ago

We need an efficient and clean power station that is best value for our money. This is the underling reasoning behind all the criticism lodged by the PL on this issue.

Instead of listening and acting on the PL’s concerns, as a responsible and accountable government should have done, the GonziPN administration went full heavy fuel oil ahead. Now that the Auditor General has confirmed all our worst suspicions, the government has bizarrely gone into attack mode.

It is now appropriate for us to evaluate and react to the crystal clear transgressions identified in the report of the Auditor General and inform the general public why accountability has become arrogance.

These transgressions are manifold. I will mainly touch on the health and environmental issues highlighted in the report.

Notwithstanding that one of the tender clauses stipulated that Enemalta sought a “tried and tested” solution to produce its electricity needs, an untried prototype combination was chosen instead of a “tried and tested” solution.

Lahmeyer International advice swayed the decision to go for the untried prototype combinations rather than complying with the original tender clauses. One must recall the fact that Lahmeyer International was selected by Enemalta through a direct order, when this consultant was blacklisted by the World Bank

Lahmeyer International, as “independent” consultants, were engaged to draw up a report on BWSC, the eventual winners of the multi-million euro tender, even though Lahmeyer International had been previously engaged in a joint project with the very same BWSC. Moreover, Joseph Mizzi, BWSC’s agent in Malta, had acted as Lahmeyer’s agent up to 2007. What a coincidence, what independence!

The Auditor General underlines the fact that when the BWSC agent, who also acted in the past as Lahmayer’s agent, was summoned on three separate occasions by the Auditor General, he repeatedly cited lack of memory when asked certain questions.   

According to Environmental Impact Assessment estimates, the untried and untested prototype chosen by the GonziPN government will produce some 15 containers of hazardous fly ash daily. A prominent official of Enemalta has declared that arrangements have been made with regard to the disposal of this, yet now it is confirmed that there is no place to dispose of this hazardous waste.

So why did the government, supposedly acting in the people’s interests, even begin to contemplate, let alone accept, that our country should act as a guinea pig for this prototype solution?

This is but one worrying aspect of a very sad sequence of events that have potentially very serious repercussions on us all. 

We cannot be satisfied just because the appalling sequence of events of this bad deal has come to light as a result of the Auditor General’s report. We now need to do all in our power to mitigate the resulting fallout.

As a next step, the government needs to make available for public scrutiny the multi-million euro contract signed in haste on 26 May 2009. This will permit a thorough analysis of the document that has such an important impact on the quality of our lives. It is the least we can accept as a nation and as a responsible Opposition. This analysis will bring us all together to evaluate all possible viable alternatives.    

Good governance emanates from the manner in which organisations such as Enemalta Corporation are administered, particularly when the appointment of the corporation’s board is a result of ministerial decisions. We cannot simply rely only on political will or strong leadership: political responsibility must be shouldered.

The report by the Auditor General strongly suggests that, at best, the organisation fell short of fulfilling its responsibilities towards us all. It gave us all a bad deal.

It will therefore be a serious indiscretion if the government is seen to condone the performance of Enemalta Corporation. Responsibilities need to be shouldered by those to blame for this state of affairs. 

The government must now do the right and sensible thing. It needs to show basic respect for us all, and leave arrogance behind.

With more facts being made public, and in the light of the gaze of all, we can and we must together, give our country the minimum it deserves – good decisions across a spectrum of economic, social, environmental and other areas, in the best interests of us all.

Stefan Zrinzo Azzopardi is the President of the Labour Party

  • don't miss