The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

‘Three-person IVF’

Malta Independent Wednesday, 28 April 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 13 years ago

“We traditionally think of biological parents as those who provide the ovum and sperm – those, that is, from whom the genetic make-up is taken. But in reality, the very flesh of this baby has been made by the surrogate mother. Although the architect of a cathedral takes all the credit, it is actually the stone mason who ‘built’ the cathedral. In biological terms the surrogate mother may not have given the genetic template but it has given the physical body to the baby. It is this that should really worry us about surrogate motherhood”

In mid-April the BCC reported research, which as a matter of fact has been known for some time, that In Vitro Fertilisation technology (IVF, that of fertilising an egg with sperm in the laboratory) can be used to cure a genetic disorder but which necessitates the DNA from a man and two women. Although there is technically nothing incorrect in the statements, especially when one reads the details, it is the kind of sensational news which proclaims science as the ‘enemy’. As the saying goes, ‘il tono fa’ la musica’ and certainly the report gave the impression that we are now creating children not from a man and a woman but from a man and two women. It smacks of the impression that the genome of the person ‘created’ has three originators and not two as nature has it. This is so far from the truth that although the article explained it well, it did not trouble itself, as is want of many journalists, to go into detail to explain what we mean indeed by a genome.

The true moral issue of course always remains whether IVF is a legitimate moral way of pro-creation, and, here that the technology is now not being used only for infertile couples but also to treat some genetic disorders. There is no embryo selection involved, and one can assume it can take place without freezing embryos, so what is in discussion is not a threatened life of a fertilised egg, but the appropriate use of the technology. So with this aside we can discuss the egg being created from three persons, and as it were, being presented as having three parents.

The reality is that this embryo still has two parents. What is being used of a second woman is the cytoplasm of the ovum. The nucleus, which contains the relevant genetic material which makes up half the chromosomes which will make up the parent is removed, and that of the woman who will be the biological parent is introduced into it.

The rationale behind this is that the cytoplasm of the ovum contains genetic material contained in organelles called mitochondria, which have nothing to do with the 46 chromosomes of DNA which make and define the new individual fertilised cell. Not that this genetic material is unimportant. In fact the cytoplasm of this second woman is being used because there is a muscular disorder which occurs because of faulty genetic material contained within the mitochondria. If the biological mother has this condition, she will transmit these to her offspring – not through the normal 46 chromosomes but through the cytoplasmic DNA which also divides. The cytoplasm is therefore the engine which controls what goes on in the nucleus.

Therefore the genetic material which goes to produce (along with the environmental factors, of course) the personality, as it were, is remaining unchanged. But a significant question is being indirectly raised here. In this case we are not introducing any genetic material into the 46 chromosomes which count towards our species. But what if we were? Our enthusiasm with genetics lies in the fact that if we have a genetic disorder we can fix it. Now suppose a genetic disorder is due to a faulty sequence of genes in one particular chromosome. If we had to replace that faulty sequence with a ‘proper’ sequence, we have to presume that the proper sequence, even if cloned to produce a number of copies, was ultimately obtained from some other human. So does that mean that we have a third parent? The obvious answer is ‘of course not!!’. But sensationalism would have it otherwise and the paradox of a liberal society is this shooting in one’s own foot. They first protest when someone raises an objection to the use of these technologies and then, for the sale of news, create something which does not exist. When one considers that we have millions of gene sequences, replacing a faulty sequence with a good sequence obtained from someone does not mean we inherit that someone’s identity or part of it. It is merely the faulty sequence which is being replaced to produce the same person without the defect.

Consider several genetic disorders such as thalassaemia, or sickle-cell disease which can be located to one gene of a sequence. Not replacing this sequence means you have a ‘Tom Jones’ with the disease; replacing the sequence means you have a ‘Tom Jones’ without the disease. It does not make Tom Jones as such any different other than he can now lead a life without the disease. It is only this environmental factor that can have an effect on his future personality and not any trait from a ‘third’ parent.

When it comes to discussing DNA found in mitochondria, which are structures needed for proper cell functioning but whose DNA does not form part of what is traditionally considered the ‘genome’ of humans, the above argument holds even more, for we are not even speaking of genes which are contained within the 46 chromosomes.

If one were to speak of a third parent, or, as in this case, a ‘second’ mother, it would be surrogate motherhood, which has been going on for years in liberal countries notwithstanding the amount of litigation over parenthood that it elicits. It is not only the psychosocial bond that the surrogate mother builds with the child that is growing in her that matters (the genome of the child was obtained by the fertilised egg of the genetic parents which was then implanted into the womb of this third person), but she is actually providing the building blocks of life. The genome provides the template for life, but it is the food the mother-with-child eats, that is converted into the cell-material of the baby, and the air she breathes which affects the child’s development. So who now is the true biological parent?

We traditionally think of biological parents as those who provide the ovum and sperm – those, that is, from whom the genetic make-up is taken. But in reality, the very flesh of this baby has been made by the surrogate mother. Although the architect of a cathedral takes all the credit, it is actually the stone mason who ‘built’ the cathedral. In biological terms the surrogate mother may not have given the genetic template but it has given the physical body to the baby. It is this that should really worry us about surrogate motherhood. No wonder that many end up in court, for the surrogate mother would often not want to give up ‘her’ baby – the baby she felt growing inside and that she ‘knew’ was being made from her very own flesh and blood. Instead of being given the genetic complement of a man only, she was given the genetic complement of a man and a woman. This child, in reality has three parents.

And yet here we are. Surrogacy has been going on for years and we never saw it described as someone who has three parents. But as soon as we speak about genes, even genes, as in this case, which have absolutely nothing to do with what we traditionally consider the genome of an individual, we speak of a third parent. Even if mitochondria have DNA, the DNA in mitochondria plays a role very different from the DNA which is found in the nucleus.

Mitochondrial diseases are very serious and around one in 6500 children are born with it. Mitochondria are inherited from our mother, true, but it remains an organelle which acts in the functioning of the whole cell. Mitochondria provide the energy needed for the cell to function and therefore one understands that if they do not work well you get disorders. But they do not contribute to the template of life which is our genes. It is not part of our ‘genetic heritage’. What is more, when these mitochondria reproduce into other cells, they do so at the expense of the ‘flesh’ (i.e. the building blocks) provided by the true mother.

It is only the first mitochondria in the single ovum provided by the second woman which acts as a template. It would be just the same thing if it were possible to simply replace the mitochondrion itself rather than the whole cytoplasm, But this cytoplasm is used only once. As soon as you have two, four, eight, etc cells, the material these cells are made of depends on the mother’s healthy diet and on the true genome which provides each individual with a new identity. The question of ‘forcing’ mothers carrying children in their wombs to follow healthy diets, and stop behaviours such as smoking and alcohol abuse is testimony to this. Cigarettes, for example, produce low birth-weight children, and diabetes produces high birth-weight children.

The media carries significant responsibility on how it presents news. This media-ethics should steer away from blank statements which are nothing other than that: Blanks. But as with bullet blanks, in the long run they are seen to produce no harm, but at the time still make a noise. Just as it takes time to recover from that noise of one, it takes time to recover from the ‘noise’ of the other. A considerable amount of damage control has then to be carried out.

The true moral significance of IVF remains whether it is a legitimate way to obtain children for infertile couples, to whom we should offer it to, which contains the essential question: Should we use it only to treat infertility or can we allow it for the benefit of these genetic conditions. As we face legislation on IVF, perhaps we can consider one Article of the law to pronounce itself on this issue.

Pierre Mallia is Associate Professor in Family Medicine, Patients’ Rights and Bioethics at the University of Malta; he is also Ethics Advisor to the Medical Council of Malta. He is also former president of the Malta College of Family Doctors.

  • don't miss