The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

It Will not go away

Malta Independent Sunday, 2 May 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

As though the Delimara power station extension contract has not caused enough controversy, we now learn that a planned Enemalta publicity campaign, designed to sell the idea that the new plant pollutes much less than the current power station, is to cost €34,000.

The Times news story I read was very brief on detail, but why on earth would we need a publicity campaign when we are being told to shut up and lump it.

Is the campaign to be a continuation of glossing over the dubious contract? The Auditor’s report stated: “Once the original tender specifications referring to emission levels were changed through the legislative amendment made in January 2008, the decision by Enemalta Corporation and the Director of Contracts to continue with the ongoing tender is questioned by the National Audit Office.”

A number of environmental non-governmental organisations have expressed their concern at “the major public health issues” that would result from the emissions of the Delimara Power Station extension.

“This prospect is even more alarming given the Auditor General’s revelation that the decision to go ahead with this project was taken in the absence of a contract for the export of the hazardous waste to be produced by the Delimara Power Station extension,” said the NGOs.

I read that three of five personalities who were invited to take part in the marketing campaign declined the invitation.

I was curious to know who the personalities not wanting to get involved were and I was directed to Karl Stagno-Navarra’s article in MaltaToday, which was much more detailed.

It informed me that programme presenters on the Labour Party-owned One TV station –Miriam Dalli, John Bundy, Alfred Zammit and Joseph Chetcuti – have all refused to take part in the campaign.

Their refusal to front the campaign will now leave production company 26th Frame with personalities from the PN-run NET TV and State-owned PBS, creating an obvious inbuilt ‘bias’ to the campaign, Karl reported. I am still in the dark as to who the latter personalities are.

Moving on, reading about Dr Louis Galea’s rounds, before he takes up his new post as a member of the EU’s Court of Auditors next month, I was surprised to see that the Auditor General, Anthony C. Mifsud, told him that “his experience in his 18 months in office was that both the government and the Opposition respected the independence of the Office”.

Was that just the official line? Did Mr Mifsud give Dr Galea a more honest interpretation in private?

Did he not tell Karl Stagno-Navarra, in a separate article to the one mentioned above, “We have come under attack, but we cannot react” when asked about what he thinks about the government’s reaction to the inquiry’s findings?

Why can’t the Auditor react? Besides, he can hardly regard the spin that both Prime Minister Gonzi and Finance Minister Fenech attached to his report as “respect”. Can he? I don’t think so.

In the PM’s own words “Nobody has the right to twist or misrepresent the Auditor’s conclusions”. I guess he was not including himself and Tonio Fenech.

Just saying that he will take note of the Auditor’s recommendations and insisting that he agreed with the Auditor’s conclusions, while at the same time ignoring pertinent shortcomings and instead seeing them as irrelevant to the validity of the contract, is not respecting the report, or people’s intelligence.

I would also like to know whether the PM shared the AG’s unease that “Enemalta’s behaviour on this ‘crucial issue’ (Enemalta had departed from the original tender document specifications when it did not disqualify the prototype diesel engine bids) caused concern as to whether the management of the tendering process could be considered as best practice”.

As to his intentions to implement the recommendations, that is still very much in the air until we see that objective put into practise.

And what about Minister Austin Gatt, who was responsible for the Enemalta portfolio when the deal was in progress?

Did he not show disrespect when he accused the Attorney General of not having “read the law”, when referring to Enemalta’s chairman Alex Tranter, who the Auditor General said should have resigned after declaring a conflict of interest during the procurement process.

I dealt with the resignation issue and Alex Tranter’s response last week, so I shall not be repeating those details.

“Nowhere did the Auditor say the process was vitiated, what he said was that with the benefit of hindsight, we could have avoided certain controversies if the process worked in a different way,” said the PM.

Well, the report tells me that the process was not worked in the way it should have been, add to that the shortcomings mentioned in the report – all of which lead one to think that the method was defective and its effectiveness was drastically reduced and that is, after all, what vitiated means.

So I found it rather ironic that the Prime Minister cautioned against “stretching the Auditor’s report like chewing gum”.

Anyway, Mr Mifsud will be able to substantiate and clarify his findings further when he attends the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) hearing on the Delimara investigation later this month.

As to the latter, I was curious to know what results could come out of the PAC investigation and I spoke to its chairman Charles Mangion, from the Labour Party.

“The PAC does not have any executive authority. Its role is to scrutinise reports, refer matters to the Auditor for investigation and make recommendations whenever the members agree upon a line of action.

“Now that the Auditor’s report has been published, the PAC will discuss its findings. Motions are voted upon in the conventional manner – i.e. a simple majority passes a motion,” he told me.

The PAC is composed of four members from the government and three members from the opposition including the chairman who does not have a casting vote.

Although our PAC structure is based on the UK’s public accounts committee, Cabinet ministers in the UK are expressly excluded from sitting on the PAC.

Whereas here Ministers Tonio Fenech and Austin Gatt both involved in the controversial report are on the PAC and will be voting on the outcome. So it looks like a fait accompli.

As for Tonio Fenech, I do not like putting the boot in, but he really does ask for it.

It is not that long ago that he was caught accepting favours from prominent businessmen, which the PM had said was no big deal and now he is putting his foot in it again.

“The Auditor did not find any irregularities. What he said was that he found shortcomings, which he put on the level of a lack of experience or a lack of coordination,” the finance minister told The Times.

It’s that chewing gum again. Shortcomings mean a defect or failure in a system or organisation, which sounds irregular to me.

As for “lack of experience or a lack of coordination,” it seems that the finance minister, like the PM, is satisfied that this €210 million project was seriously bungled by ‘amateurs’.

Mr Fenech insisted that the AG’s report found no irregularities for which anyone had to shoulder responsibility and stressed that: “the Auditor simply made a number of recommendations”, which the government should now make it a point to take on.

Our Minister of Finance is reducing a scathing report with serious shortcomings demonstrating bad practice to “simply” a number of recommendations and of course no one has any responsibility to shoulder!

The recommendations pointed to serious deficiencies. One of them stated: “Rules and regulations must be rigorously applied and followed without exception or fail. Quoting reasons of urgency does not per se provide the necessary authorisation for not following such rules and regulations.”

This indicates to most people that the regulations were not rigorously applied to hurry things along. Indeed the AG questioned “the undue haste with which the agreement was signed”, yet Mr Fenech blithely ignores the implications of the recommendations and the serious shortcomings in the report.

On responsibility, he gets himself deeper into the mire by stating that one of the men accused of lack of cooperation, Joseph Mizzi – the Maltese agent of the winner of the contract, Danish company BWSC – was a private person, not a government employee.

So that is supposed to absolve the government of responsibility does it?

The government is behaving as though it is only the Labour Party that is making a noise about this contract, but The Times, the establishment’s paper, which very rarely criticises the PN administration outright, has published two strong editorials

The first on 22 April, titled “Serious failure of public governance”, stated, “Only concrete action can help citizens regain their faith in public governance, whose reputation has taken such a battering from this report.”

The second on Thursday, headed “Government’s reaction weak, unconvincing”, said “However much the government tries to fend off the strong criticism being levelled at the way a Danish company was contracted to supply new generation plant for the extension of the Delimara power station, the hard fact remains there is much in the Auditor General’s report that raises concern over the award of the contract.”

Now I cannot see our Times change its allegiances as the London Times is doing, which after supporting Labour for the past 16 years is now backing the Conservative Party.

But if the Prime Minister and his government continue ignoring strong public opinion, Dr Gonzi will not need a Gillian Duffy to sink his chances of winning at our next general election.

[email protected]

  • don't miss