Not a good start for the new Speaker of the House, Michael Frendo. There was uproar in Parliament on Thursday night as the vote was being taken on the controversial Delimara power station contract.
Parliamentary Secretary for Health Mario Galea voted “yes” on the Opposition motion condemning the government over the way the contract for the extension was granted.
What intrigued me was that The Times reported, “Mr Galea was heard to mistakenly say ‘yes’ in favour of the motion.”
Who decided it was a mistake? Maybe Mr Galea was expecting more of his colleagues to vote “yes” and they chickened out.
If that were the case of course he would renege. Why should he be the only one to risk being shunned by his party and possibly lose his portfolio within the Health Department?
Then again maybe he might have made a mistake, but it is the assumption that all Government MPs will vote against an Opposition motion that rankled.
So all that government backbenchers’ discontent, not just on this issue, was just posturing after all and at the end of the day all MP’s will vote with their party regardless.
I have a lot of respect for Mario Galea; he had been the only parliamentary member to spend time discussing the issue around the petition to ban the dreaded bombi after it had been presented to both sides of the House in December 2001.
About 700 people, including many doctors and nurses at St Luke’s Hospital and the hospice movement, had signed it. But the rest of our members of parliament ignored it.
I bring this up because the ill effects of noise have hit the news yet again. More on that further on.
But getting back to Thursday night, the Opposition members walked out, since they insisted they had won the vote, when the Speaker suspended the sitting to hear the recording of what went on.
Michael Frendo wanted to ascertain whether Justine Caruana voted “no” as Deputy Prime Minister Tonio Borg alleged.
When the sitting resumed, the Speaker said the recording, which he listened to together with the Clerk of the House and two Clerk Assistants, was not clear and in terms of standing orders, since doubts still existed, he was calling a re-vote.
However, a number of people commenting on The Times online claimed that they clearly heard Ms Caruana vote “yes”.
The opposition motion was defeated on the re-vote, with 35 government votes against.
It has since transpired that nearly all the microphones in the House were off during the vote and that was why it was impossible to verify how Dr Caruana had voted, according to the Office of the Speaker.
In his speech winding up the debate, Dr Muscat made some disturbing allegations, which cannot be ignored.
He claimed that although the government had said that work on the power station extension was stopped until the auditor’s inquiry was completed, it had actually signed the contract with BWSC on the same day that the inquiry started, and it had presented the project to Mepa, which issued an outline development permit.
He said, “The so-called experts had not looked up BWSC and its reputation when considering the tender. Neither had they done so for independent consultant company Lehmeyer, which was blacklisted by the World Bank and which once had Mr Mizzi as its local representative. The auditor found that the Lehmeyer comments were instrumental in the selection of the bidder.
“Clearly, Mr Mizzi had an early copy of the specifications for the power station extension, but the auditor was unable to establish the source of the leak at Enemalta,” alleged Dr Muscat.
Earlier in the evening, Opposition leader Joseph Muscat raised a point of order and requested a ruling from the Speaker on whether Nationalist MP Charlo’ Bonnici could vote, in view of a conflict of interest.
Mr Bonnici was Human Resources Manager at Care Malta Ltd. His direct superior was the Chief Executive Officer, Alex Tranter, who was also chairman of Enemalta. Furthermore, Care Malta was owned by Zaren (Nazareno) Vassallo, and Vassallo Builders were the civil works contractors of BWSC for the building of the power station extension.
Dr Muscat pointed out that both Standing Orders and the Code of Ethics said that in circumstances where they had a direct pecuniary interest, MPs should declare such interest and may not vote. The same was said in Erskine May, the ‘bible’ of parliamentary procedure.
Deputy PM and Foreign Minister Tonio Borg intervened, saying that he did not see any direct, or even indirect pecuniary interest with the subject matter of the motion.
It took Michael Frendo three hours deliberation to rule, “he had seen Mr Bonnici’s declaration of assets and confirmed that he was employed by Care Malta Ltd.
“However Care Malta was not mentioned in the report by the Auditor General on the power station extension contract and the Chair therefore felt that Mr Bonnici did not have a direct pecuniary interest and should be allowed to vote.”
I must say that this is manipulating the concept of conflict of interest like Gonzi’s ‘proverbial’ chewing gum.
First of all, I would have thought that one’s job was directly linked to pecuniary interest.
Secondly, Care Malta might not have been mentioned in the report, but that the civil works contract had been secured by the boss of Care Malta, Nazareno Vassallo (although he might not have been mentioned by name in the report) did feature.
Besides, the Auditor said in the report that Alex Tranter should have resigned because of his conflict of interest since he was the CEO at Mr Vassallo’s Care Malta.
The name Care Malta might not have appeared, but is pretty obvious to anyone who can walk and chew gum at the same time, that anyone working for someone with a vested interest in the debated contract did indeed have a conflict of interest.
*****
Noise can drive you nuts
I do feel sorry for the man who lost it and admitted that his anger led him to violent behaviour.
I read that he put up with noise, rubbish and other inconvenience from a downstairs shop for over three years. He admitted in court that in a fit of anger he damaged the door and signs of the shop and threatened the owner, but said he would pay for the damage he caused.
There is no excuse for his reaction, one just cannot damage property and threaten people, but he has been let down by the authorities who allowed the intolerable disturbance to go on for over three years.
One can push an individual to breaking point with continual stress. Who is going to pay him for the damage caused to his well being?
This case has hit a very sore nerve, as is manifest by the comments online. Mepa, the police and other relevant authorities all came under attack.
One cannot say that all police officers ignore residents complaints, but there are still too many who do not take the responsibility their job entails.
For too long planners have put the interests of the commercial sector above those of residents and the community in general, with regard to noise, traffic and health and safety.
I know of a garage whose owner was given a permit for it to be used commercially in a residential narrow street.
There have been containers and large vans delivering huge bulks of merchandise, even on Easter Sunday.
Although I was pleased to see a recent Mepa decision, which was taken in favour of residents and refused a permit for commercial activity. Hopefully this will not be a one off.
In 2001, I had, as well as starting the campaign to stop the bombi, mentioned earlier, tried to start a noise abatement society.
I had been encouraged by the huge amount of emails I had been receiving as well as support in letters to the editor.
However, people seemed to be OK with complaining and encouraging me to carry on battling, but lacked the oomph to get actively involved.
But of course if things are allowed to ride they can only get worse. I think people have now, as we have seen from this last incident, have reached the end of their tether.
In the face of such obvious widespread and strongly felt feelings about noise abuse maybe the people who are trying to revive interest in a noise abatement movement, and who have plans to go public shortly, will finally be successful. I sincerely hope so.
The group, who have also recently registered as a Voluntary Organisation, has already conducted a preliminary survey on the perceptions of noise in Maltese society at this time.
I look forward to the results of the survey being made public, since I understand that it revealed a disturbingly high percentages of ‘yes’ answers to the questions: “Does noise annoy you?” and “Is noise damaging to health?”
There were an equally high percentage of ‘no’ answers to “Do you think that enough is being done to ensure that noise is controlled”. This if nothing else should convince the authorities that they need to act fast and effectively before too many more people go nuts.
[email protected]