One pious hope one hears expressed almost everywhere, is that had we stayed out of the euro, we would not have to pay for the Greek bailout, nor would we have to worry.
To look at things from such a ‘little islander’ point of view greatly simplifies the extraordinarily complicated reality of the world today.
A very recent article in the New York Times made this amply, and graphically, clear.
“In the decade since the introduction of the euro, the economies on the continent have become increasingly interwoven. With cross-border banking and borrowing, many countries on the periphery of Europe owe vast sums to one another, as well as to richer neighbours like Germany and France.
“Like the alliances that drew one country after another into World War I, a default by a single nation would send other countries tumbling. If that message was lost on anyone, there was a reminder last Tuesday when Standard & Poor’s downgrade of Spanish and Portuguese debt hammered stock markets everywhere, including in the United States.
“The first domino is Greece. It owes nearly $10 billion to Portuguese banks, and with Portugal already falling two notches in S & P’s ratings and facing higher borrowing costs, a default by Greece would be a staggering blow. Portugal, in turn, owes $86 billion to banks in Spain; Spain’s debt was downgraded one notch last week.
“The numbers quickly mount. Ireland is heavily indebted to Germany and Britain. The exposure of German banks to Spanish debt totals $238 billion, according to the Bank for International Settlements, while French banks hold another $220 billion. And Italy, whose finances are perennially shaky, is owed $31 billion by Spain and owes France $511 billion, or nearly 20 per cent of the French gross domestic product.”
In other words, even Britain, which is not in the eurozone, finds itself immersed in the maelstrom.
“This is not a bailout of Greece,” said Eric Fine, who manages Van Eck G-175 Strategies, a hedge fund specializing in currencies and emerging market debt. “This is a bailout of the euro system.”
The accompanying graphic makes it all the more understandable – and worrying.
Until a few days ago, some people were thinking that maybe the worst that could happen could be a Greek default. Now we know that a Greek default will only pull other countries down and that the scale of the other countries involved, from Portugal to Spain and Italy, both ‘too big to be allowed to default’ would simply collapse not just the eurozone but the economies of the West.
One fully understands the chagrin and the anger being felt in Germany and in the other ‘virtuous’ countries at having to bail out the profligate Greeks, but in reality there is precious little leeway.
As with the International Monetary Fund, the EU can hold on to its purse strings and only dole out the bailout money if concrete austerity measures have been taken and only if they have started to show results.
It is clear by now that the world’s speculators are betting on the collapse of the euro although most of the dark conspiracy theories being spun by the eurozone leaders would make more sense if they were to understand how markets work.
But, fundamentally, the situation has been brought about by countries, economies, banks, institutions taking off in lending and borrowing sprees far beyond what used to be deemed prudent and safe. Looking back, we can see now that much of the much-hyped growth of the past years was simply… hype.
And as these hype countries and institutions grew and prospered on the backs of double-digit growth, so too their manufacturing bases were being dismantled, their competitiveness undermined, and on a country basis their social security systems rendered completely out of touch with reality.
The result is what we see around us today: bond spreads widening, countries being downgraded by the credit agencies, deficit and debt figures soaring, as do unemployment figures (21 per cent in Spain), and countries teetering on the brink of revolution and social chaos. The terrible death of three unfortunate bank employees firebombed in their bank branch in Athens last week undoubtedly was a tragic accident but the anger felt by the rioting crowd was all too real.
Then, when the mud hits the fan, all sorts of strange things start to happen. The party in Opposition in Greece, which was in government until a few months ago, and which caused much of the deficit that has crippled the country, comfortably chose to vote against the austerity measures. As for the people who by their tax evasion, and the unions who by blocking any talk of realistic reform when it was still time – they will not pay the full brunt of the correction as much as the unfortunates on the government payroll, whose jobs will be cut, the pensioners whose meagre pensions will be cut further, and the country at large, brought up to think it merited a standard of living that in truth was far beyond it.
“I was in Latvia last summer,” wrote Gideon Rachman in the Financial Times – “a country that had already had to submit to an IMF-European Union programme in return for emergency funding. The consequences are extremely severe. It is like watching a whole country go through the economic equivalent of chemotherapy. The Latvians had to put up with double-digit cuts in wages and pensions, all of which deepened an already bad recession. I was surprised and impressed by the stoicism with which the Latvians took their harsh medicine. But I fear that the Greeks will not be so accepting – and there could soon be trouble on the streets.
“I can think of two good reasons why the Greeks are likely to be a lot less accepting than the Latvians. First, most Latvians knew that they had been through a bubble and their experience of relative wealth was sufficiently recent for them not to take it for granted. Before the bust, the economy had been growing fast. So the Latvians would point out that even a very deep and prolonged recession might only shrink the economy to the size it was in around 2004. Of course, a lot of people would get badly hurt in the process. But losing five years of growth did not seem like an unthinkable national catastrophe.
“By contrast, although Greece is not a particularly wealthy country, its people have got used to a relatively comfortable standard of living over the last 20 years – and many will bitterly resent seeing comforts they had taken for granted suddenly snatched away.”
Romania will have to enact sweeping austerity measures to avoid raising taxes and ensure delivery of the next instalment of a €20 billion IMF standby credit. The government announced last week that it will slash public sector wages by 25 per cent from June while pensions and jobless benefits will fall by 15 per cent.
There is, there must be a correction not just on a eurozone level but also on a country by country level, down to economic sectors, to industries, to businesses, to individuals.
At pan-eurozone level, 10 years after the creation of the euro, there is much thought being given on how to restructure and reshape the euro now that hitherto hidden fault-lines have emerged so dramatically. It seems clear enough that there can be no monetary union without some sort of political union and that the no default principle, which this current crisis has so dramatically unhinged, must be substituted by peer surveillance or something even more draconian. That’s all for the post-crisis scenarios, if we finally get there.
On a country-by-country level, we have often spoken about government deficits and debts, but that is only part of the story. The flip side is the state of private deficits and debts. There are countries with a moderate deficit whose economic situation is very fragile due to huge private debts. Nor is having a good credit rating any guarantee that a country will not get sucked down. According to a Euronews snippet just some days ago, Spain, for instance, had a better credit rating than Malta, but the events of recent days have shown how fragile this all is.
Here in Malta, just to mention the cases we know, we have the Air Malta problem, the Enemalta huge problem, the Middlesea problem – and those are only three. Then there are the companies in Malta that have close connections with Greece, and I can immediately think of three.
The rules of economics are really simple and straightforward, but all the fancy talk of the past years has made us follow chimeras. And politicians the world over seem to have consistently followed one policy line alone: the line of least resistance.
The upshot of all this is that we are all in it together and nothing short of a world cataclysm will get us where we were when things were simpler (just like it will take a world nuclear conflagration to make us primitives once again, scrubbing around for bare subsistence). The eurozone has no real alternative to helping Greece get out of its hell hole, not even small us, but there are lessons to be learnt both on the continental scale and on the national and even enterprise level.
[email protected]