The incidents which seem to throw doubt on the integrity of this government and its ministers never seem to stop. When every single contract ends up being seriously challenged, when certain departments seem to be unable to clean up their act even when they get new ministers, when almost every single project overruns by millions of euros, when even well-known government supporters start turning on each other in their chase for tenders, then it is no wonder that people start thinking that every smoke denotes a fire.
In my last article I mentioned that possibly, recruitment procedures may not be working well, in the sense that each party in government seems to feel obliged to recruit only from the ranks of its known supporters. But does this stretch to ministers, to the law courts, to the chairs and boards of corporations, authorities and all the other quangos that have been created and now seemingly can only be controlled with difficulty?
Would the ordinary citizen have expected that, after the bashing it had taken, the vehicle licensing department would once again be in the news for the wrong reasons? How many investigations does a department have to undergo before it is realised that any malaise within its ranks is so deep-rooted that drastic measures demand to be implemented? Following hot on the heels of the Fairmount controversy and the BWSC’s on-going saga, we now have allegations about another contract, that for the super-yacht facility.
We also learn that the ordinary citizen not only has to fork out the salaries of public officers, but also to pay the medical bills for the wives, children and dependents of such officers. Would it be in order to ask what these same dependents are giving back to the country in return for such largesse? Would it be in order too to ask why in these difficult times, and considering the size of the island, the grant of a car and free fuel should be an automatic perk of office, especially when that office does not ask its occupant to drive around all day?
The report on the EUPU unit within the Department of Education has put the blame fairly and squarely on top people in the Department who are responsible for the way its affairs are run. But these people, and many others who apparently were not directly connected with the embarrassment Malta suffered in the eyes of the other member states, have all been there for some time and they were all brought in either by Minister Cristina or her predecessors. According to the prevailing political culture of our fair isle, these were, and undoubtedly still are, trusted people.
I hesitate to go further because the list is endless and I would need time to look up my files to get a more or less complete list of all the accusations and counter accusations that have plagued this administration. So what is going wrong?
Well one answer may be the lack of good governance, which means the competent management of a country’s resources and affairs in a manner that is open, transparent, accountable, equitable and responsive to peoples needs. The principles of good governance include:
• Openness and transparency, so that all citizens can have confidence in the decision-making and management processes of government.
• Accountability, to ensure that everybody, including office holders, and members of any governing body, authority, corporation etc. are seen to be responsible and accountable for their decisions and actions, including the stewardship of funds. No responsible office holder, political or otherwise, should dismiss as hearsay allegations of corruption.
• Integrity, joined with straightforward dealing and completeness, based on honesty, selflessness and objectivity, to ensure high standards of probity and propriety in the conduct of affairs and decision-making.
• Clarity of purpose, so that citizens know why and how policies are decided on, what they are meant to achieve, what can the citizen expect from them, how much they will cost and how will the cost be met.
• Independence of the holders of public office from ministerial or other interference in decision making must be ensured.
• Effectiveness, which includes efficiency and represents good value for money.
Can any objective scrutiny of the above principles conclude that they are all, completely and fully, embedded in Malta’s public life? I dare say not. But the story does not end here. I too, like so many others, consider that Lawrence Gonzi has been doing his best for the country constrained as he is by a slim majority and international problems together with those that are of the government’s own creation.
I also think that he is being consistently let down by those he trusted, or even over-trusted. This may have led to the creation of a siege-mentality that almost caused a rebellion within the ranks of his government. His predecessor never suffered any qualms about getting rid of people who did not deliver or were found to be wanting in judgement. Perhaps its time for the present prime minister to follow that act and give his Augean stables a thorough clean-up, because I fear that otherwise more squalls will be on the way.