The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

We Have lost funds to save funds?!

Malta Independent Sunday, 6 June 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 15 years ago

It is so sad that so many young people have lost opportunities to study abroad due to mismanagement by the EU programmes agency in Malta (EUPA), which led to the suspension of EU funding for educational programmes.

Having been involved in a local NGO EU funding exercise with a UK partner, some years ago, I know that the whole exercise is no picnic and that it is essential to have trained and adequate human resources.

I seem to recall that at some point, after I had thrown in the towel because of the lack of the appropriate human resources, the government was offering NGOs help to be able to handle the intricacies of following the necessary requirements.

But it seems that even the government cannot handle the finer points of EU funding. The Ministry of Education is designated, as the National Authority with the responsibility of regulating EUPA, the National Agency and the head of EUPA is the national coordinator.

EU’s Lifelong Learning (LLL) and youth in Action (YIA) programmes are implemented by EUPA. The funds for the two programmes were suspended; affecting hundreds of young people, after the European Commission said it was not satisfied with EUPA’s actions.

The EC had noted that the “national agency could not cope with the programme management requirements because of lack of human resources and because of the high staff turnover”.

Yet, this agency was not a cash-strapped NGO but the national agency answerable to and under the umbrella of the National Authority, aka the Ministry of Education.

The Prime Minister’s response was “the EU may have demanded the recruitment of more people for capacity-building purposes, but this did not happen in order to save funds”.

Was he quoted correctly? So we have lost funds to save funds?! Was this pointed out to him by anyone? Anyway, I have not seen the government skimping on other projects, the new parliament building, for example.

And “capacity building”? What on earth does that mean? Enough people to do the job properly, I presume.

The Prime Minister also told reporters that the EC was only complaining that some information it had sought was not given on time. Not quite I am afraid. Not meeting deadlines was not the problem. Bungling was.

The cancellation of the funds was due to “persistent lack of assurance that EU funds are managed to the required standards”.

In May the EC informed the National Agency representatives that although the declarations had been received within the established deadline, suspension was still being considered regarding the participation in the LLP and YIA programmes, as “it was still not convinced that the National Authority was carrying out its monitoring function effectively”.

On 7 May, the Education Ministry, in its National Authority capacity, was told in a letter that the two programmes had been suspended since “the financial systems and procedures in place in the National Agency (EUPA) do not provide sufficient assurance on the legality and regularity of transactions”.

The European Commission had first highlighted deficiencies in the management of funds by EUPA nine months ago. It was not satisfied with the control mechanisms used and recommended that changes be made by last September.

The EC report also complained that duties were not separated well enough, with the person giving advice to an applicant later evaluating the same grant application.

Despite a Ministry spokesman’s assurances that “everything is in hand” and that “the situation is being monitored closely to try to get the funds rolling again”, it does not seem that the cash is going to “roll” for a while yet.

I was amused by the Ministry’s statement insisting, “The agency implemented and was seeking to implement the recommendations made by the Commission.”

It has either implemented or seeking to implement the recommendations.

Whatever, it seems the agency’s efforts failed and the inquiry report said that the National Authority (the Ministry) which managed the programmes “consistently failed to take the necessary action to bring its internal management procedures in line with the European Commission’s minimum requirements.”

The agency’s (EUPA) shortcomings in key compliance areas included, but were not limited to, checks on grants to beneficiaries, treasury management, segregation of duties, closure of agreements and documentation of procedures.

The issues were highlighted by the European Commission in various communications and monitoring visits. Many appeared as early as 2006 and remained unresolved at the time of the monitoring missions of May 2009 and January 2010.

“If the Commission recommended we get more staff we have to go through the normal procedure for employing government employees,” the Ministry spokesman said.

Well yes, but has the procedure started and if yes, when did it start? The problem has been rolling for at least four years. Do government appointments take that long to be filled? Or did the procedure not start at all in order to save money, as the Prime Minister suggested?

Following the inquiry instigated by the Prime Minister, three officials were found responsible for the debacle and it was recommended that disciplinary action should be taken against them.

The Board of Enquiry concluded that there was “a strong element of human error in allowing the situation to deteriorate to the point that the funds were suspended”.

The Board felt “the whole affair could have been avoided” and that “The positions of the officers responsible at the National Authority – the Permanent Secretary at the Ministry of Education Christopher Bezzina and the Director Policy Development and Programme Implementation Robert Tabone – as well as the National Agency Co-ordinator Mauro Pace Parascandolo – are no longer tenable.”

It pointed to a lack of leadership on the part of Mr Pace Parascandolo as well as inadequate awareness of the obligations and responsibilities. It conceded that the management weaknesses of the national agency predated the permanent secretary taking up his post.

However, it felt that at the point when the first version of the Declaration of Assurance was rejected by the EC, the alarm bells should have been set off through the system and “all necessary resources within the national authority (the ministry), and possibly outside it, should have been mobilised and the concerted action taken”.

There had been “error of judgement in the way the matter was handled by both the Permanent Secretary and the Director of Policy Development and Programme implementation within the National Authority,” said the inquiry report.

The message from the European Commission regarding the risk of suspension of funds was clear and repeated, in writing, on more than one occasion. “Decisive action should therefore have been taken by the National Authority and the National Agency as soon as the risk was detected.” What little progress had been made was too little, and fragmented, the Board said.

Although conceding that the management of EU funds is very taxing and EUPA high turnover of staff could have contributed to the difficulties in meeting compliance targets (particularly in the finance unit of EUPA), the Board contended that the main underlying factors were a non-systematic approach leading to ineffective management systems.

“Precious time was lost unnecessarily between September 2009 and March 2010”. The Board concluded that both the permanent secretary and the Policy Development and Programme Implementation director just sat on the issue.

The three officials have now resigned. They said that they did not agree with the conclusions of the report and were offering their resignation without any prejudice towards any action they might take in the future.

Now if they can prove, especially the permanent secretary Christopher Bezzina, that they had made the position clear to the Minister, Dolores Cristina, then their heads should not be the only ones to roll.

[email protected]

  • don't miss