The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Women’s Political emancipation

Malta Independent Monday, 7 June 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

“In a free and fair democracy, citizens should not encounter formal and informal obstacles to full participation in the political system. Yet, several decades after the introduction of female suffrage in Malta, the number of parliamentarians remains admittedly low and seems unlikely to shift dramatically”

That Maltese women should fully exercise their political rights and obligations as citizens of a liberal democracy is an argument that few would contest. However, affirmative action, or policies that aim to address the gender imbalance in sectors like politics, is highly controversial.

The debate surrounding electoral quotas to increase the number of female members of Parliament (MPs) is polarised because it raises questions about what is meant by equality in a democratic political system. Unfortunately, Malta’s standing with respect to the number of MPs and MEPs is at odds with other EU member states and the policies promoted by all EU institutions.  According to a European Union Commission report, in 2006, only 20 countries around the world had 30 per cent or more female MPs. With less than 15 per cent, Malta has a poor record, ranking behind developing countries like Rwanda. Even worse, Malta, along with Cyprus, is the only EU country with only male representatives in the European Parliament.

In her report, No Room at the Top, Dr Frances Camilleri-Cassar reports that: “although women are over half the electorate in Malta, their presence in the House of Representatives has never been higher than the 1951 ten per cent figure.” It is distressing to note that the current figure, which stands at 9.3 per cent, is lower than that of 14 legislatures ago.

So how can we address this situation? The struggle for the political emancipation of women has been taken in several steps. Universal suffrage was the first fundamental step in women’s political emancipation, followed measures which removed formal barriers that excluded women standing for public office.

In a free and fair democracy, citizens should not encounter formal and informal obstacles to full participation in the political system. Yet several decades after the introduction of female suffrage in Malta, the number of parliamentarians remains admittedly low and seems unlikely to shift dramatically.

In part the low figures are the result of ‘informal’ rather than ‘formal’ barriers. The removal of patterns of these ‘informal’ barriers is infinitely more difficult because they are not immediately evident, and involve the transformation of societal institutions including politics, culture and family.

A political landscape dominated by men; a patriarchal culture placing men as the sole possessors of political and economic power in the household, business and commerce, the workplace and the community; are just some of the informal barriers rigging the chances of Maltese women seeking to become politicians.

Countermeasures like quotas or, as the British Labour and, latterly Conservative parties, have used ‘all women shortlists’ have ensured a minimum representation of women that currently stands at around 20%.The aim behind gender quotas is to overcome the informal barriers that are preventing women from holding public office. Detractors argue that quotas are illiberal and unfair. And, there is no doubt that gender quotas, by themselves, are not the whole solution.

Detractors choose to ignore the less visible process of candidate selection within parties. Although it is voters that make the final authoritative decision on who is to represent them, it is the political parties (and not the electorate) that get to select the list of candidates that will stand for election.

Indeed, not compensating for informal gender societal bias is akin to the judge consenting to a female athlete competing with weights around her ankles. For the advocates of quotas, the ultimate aim is to remove these metaphorical ‘weights’. However, since these societal ‘weights’ involve a lengthy process of transformation, the competitor needs to be allowed to balance out the ‘weights’.

Addressing this imbalance is crucial to increasing the quality of Maltese democracy and also to the cohesiveness of our society and economic productivity. First, it bolsters the visibility of women in public life and not in traditional ‘caring’ roles. It entrenches them in the system with the aim of making the use of quotas unnecessary in the future. Increasing the number of female politicians will facilitate women’s say on public affairs. It also cuts both ways - men working 60-70 hour weeks leave little time for their family, and are not economically productive.

Gender equality is a priority for the EU It is one of the basic principles of EU law, with the treaties clearing stating that the EU is to promote equality between men and women in all its activities and to take appropriate action to combat discrimination based on gender.

Political authorities must transform the broader context and aim to transform Maltese culture. Besides quotas, the remedy must include the engagement of women at the grassroots level too. Quotas alone will not ensure an overhaul of the gender bias in Malta. Still, they can ensure a quantum leap in the number of women parliamentarians, and that alone would be a historic achievement.

[email protected]

www.edwardscicluna.com

  • don't miss