The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Scandals, Like the poor, will always be with us

Malta Independent Sunday, 13 June 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 15 years ago

In a vibrant democracy, it is very normal and should be acceptable, that scandals become the focus of national interest.

It would be far more surprising (and worrying) if a long period goes by with no hint of a scandal on the horizon.

Obviously, in a country with two or more parties, the party/ies in Opposition will be making most of the running about uncovering scandals or getting people’s minds focused on them. That is perfectly understandable and acceptable: the Opposition is there to scrutinize the operation of the government and it would not be doing its job well if it allows the government to become nonchalant when carrying out its duties.

But even more than the Opposition, the role of uncovering scandals in most countries falls on the media.

In our country, it so happens that the Opposition has a powerful media machine. And it also happens that the local media is generally weak where uncovering scandals is concerned. Dependent far more than in other countries on advertising media and less on sales, and hemmed in by a judicial system whose libel laws are quite stringent and where access to libel cases has a lower threshold than in other places, it is thus more easy for the Opposition to discover a scandal and more difficult for the media to do the same. Hence the prevailing perception that the Opposition is all about scandal-mongering.

Now this, a result of the prevailing situation, does not really work in favour of the Opposition, much as the Opposition tends to think so.

For, as we see around us, the Opposition frequently goes into a strident, screaming mode where all it seems to say is there are scandals here, there and everywhere. There are days where almost all the news items on the main One News bulletin scream SCANDAL from beginning to end.

In the end, people may simply become numb and immune to allegations of scandal. They either conclude that all and everyone is on the take or else they conclude that this is what the Opposition seems to say day in, day out. And that, come the day when the Opposition take over, they will be doing exactly the same.

But the reality at ground level is that on a normal day there are far, far more scandals around than would be discovered by either the Opposition or the media.

There are scandals that nobody gets to know about, but which exist. Many of these would be the scandals that work, for no one of those who are involved would reveal the scam, unless at the cost of heroism.

Those that are revealed many times are uncovered not by police or other investigation, not even by internal audit practices, but because some dissatisfied participant spills the beans. Had it not been for this ‘whistleblower’, the scandal would have remained undiscovered.

Without going into details, we all remember the VAT scandal, etc.

Some of this whistleblowing is done through and to the Opposition. A few others appear first in the media. Very few go directly to the investigators, the police.

But there are others, many others I would say, that are never made public because they are discovered by the government itself and whose revelation to the public would contribute to undermine public confidence, which no government willingly allows.

How many would these be? We can have no idea, for in truth all we the public get to know about the inner workings of government are few sketchy details.

Then later on, perhaps much later on, we come to a sort of hazy understanding that the real reason behind some sudden resignation (which, unlike an appointment, is hardly ever announced in the media), or behind some appointment as against another possible appointment derives from some hidden murkiness.

In principle, there should be enough operational safeguards that would eliminate the possibility of corruption. And if these operational safeguards are kept oiled and in order, they should block mischief out. Many times, as we read the conclusions of yet another inquiry into something that went wrong, we see clear evidence that had the normal procedures been followed and observed, none of this would have taken place.

So many times, lack of personnel, though it saves the country millions in salaries, cost it perhaps as much if not more because procedures had to be skipped for lack of personnel. Then those who misguidedly thought they were doing the country some good because they were saving money, realise the folly of their actions.

For corruption is very human. It is evident that the human element, especially if unsupervised and in a culture with less moral restraint than in those countries with a strong emphasis on personal responsibility, will quickly find a way to thwart procedures and to derive personal material gain. Many times, as we see over and over again, the real material benefit would not be that large: this, many times, has people who come to know that such or such a scandal did take place, scratch their heads in frustration that such a scandal could be entertained for so small gain.

The red line for a government, for a leader, is when despite a scandal being uncovered the perpetrator is defended and protected. Or even when the perpetrator is allowed to go scot-free when his ill doings are known and proved. This however does not mean that any time the Opposition dreams up a scandal, the person it targets must inevitably step down. If this were so, we would not need courts, trials, systems of justice even. All we would have is the Opposition naming someone and this someone then has to go.

There is a subtle but real difference between this argument and defending a decision that may have come from a twisted decision-taking process. The fact that the decision in question could have been tainted by something illicit in the process does not mean, ipso facto, that the decision was wrong. While ensuring that there was no monkey business involved, it is also the government’s duty to ensure that any decision that has to be taken is the right one for the benefit of the citizens.

At the same time, the public at large just does not have the slightest idea of the pressures that accompany most government tenders involving many millions. What we get to hear is generally a very skewed description of matters, many times (but not exclusively) from the point of view of the failed bidder. But many times there would be a complementary and opposite version as well: for while the failed bidder may claim that the successful bidder used untoward help to get his success, the successful bidder, the adjudicator, and sometimes even the third-placed bidder may all have their own stories of how the failed bidder tried as hard as anything to get the bid. In other words, there are no saints and virgins in this game: at most there would be successful and unsuccessful corrupters.

In this country of ‘saints and fireworks’, to use Professor Boissevain’s famous title, most, if not all, tend to get a ‘saint’ to help them with the rough bits.

All this makes far more imperative the duty on those who are in the ruling seat to be rigorous, not to take things lightly, to be careful about even the slightest details, to follow procedures, and to be ready to lay their own personal integrity on the line. Not everyone can do that. It’s one thing to shout Boo and claim corruption, and it’s quite a different thing to be able to pocket a fiver with nobody seeing, and not doing it.

[email protected]

  • don't miss