The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

Who Calls the tune?

Malta Independent Sunday, 20 June 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 17 years ago

Dr Adrian Vassallo (PL) tabled a parliamentary question asking whether access to hard porn is legal in hotels in Malta and Gozo. He was right to ask the question since the law seems to be equivocal in this respect. And for asking this simple question, unfortunately rather simplistically framed in an Iranian Ayatollah context, hell has descended on the good doctor’s head and he has been made a figure of fun. The point that needs to be debated is simple: if the law as it now stands lacks clarity, then all the government has to do is to have the courage of its convictions and decide either to legalise the viewing of adult films in hotel bedrooms or not. 

Edwin Vassallo (PN), and here again his remark could have been better framed, pointed out that the consequences of private actions often spill out into the public domain and therefore one needs to question certain assumptions. If, to prove their liberalism, a couple decide to have children outside marriage, it is, of course their own private concern. However, should the relationship break up, as many of these transient relationships do, which is why three children a day are being born to single mothers, whose duty is it to pick up the pieces? If it remains the duty of the couple themselves, then of course their decision and its results remains their own and nobody has the right to judge or interfere. But if society finds itself having to pay for the consequences of that private action, by keeping the now single mother and her offspring fed and housed by the contributions of the taxpayer, does the private decision remain solely the concern of two consenting adults?

The liberal and conservative basis

Very interesting was the reaction of the liberal camp. Western liberal democracies are characterised by respect for the ideal that individuals should have the freedom to determine what they ought to do. And personally I am no friend of any intrusive authority. Yet this philosophy carries at least one serious problem. If everyone is free to act as s/he chooses, what exists to ensure that people will recognise their obligations to one another?

Historically, a liberal theory of politics was linked to a conservative theory of society. By simply assuming that liberal citizens were tied together morally by tradition, culture, religion, family and loyalty, liberal theory was able to emphasise the benefits to be gained by the free exercise of political rights, since a strong civil society could always be counted on to cement the moral obligations that politics neglected.

But as the moral world associated with civil society is taken less and less for granted, as the fragmentation and corrosion of moral responsibility due to the marketisation of society takes further hold, then the question of who is responsible for others when people refuse to be responsible for themselves, becomes more urgent.

The walk behind the talk

But back to the beginning. I can well understand both MPs’ concerns. One, like me, is a doctor who, for the past 30 years, has been in direct contact with Maltese families and has seen the gradual fragmentation of our family ties and some of the bitter results of the permissive society. The Nationalist Vassallo was concerned by the social effects of this permissiveness with its implicit connotation that ‘what I say goes’ and ‘ I have a right to do as I feel, when I feel and how I feel’. The rest is assumed to be society’s responsibility.

Like me, Dr Vassallo is witnessing the hardships and sufferings of those women who are left to support their children and shoulder all responsibility for them, while their male counterparts waltz away into new relationships. These women either end up on social assistance (meaning living on or below the poverty line) or, if they opt to work, have to leave the children to be brought up by their grandparents or – the worst scenario – turn them into latch-key children who go back to an empty home while the parent is at work.

Like me, Dr Vassallo must be witnessing the huge number of men and women on tranquillisers because of the pressures modern professional lifestyles are causing. He must also have come across children who are treated as mere objects as they are shuttled between one parent and another, or have to bond with, at times, an endless succession of “fathers” who take over the family home.

The break-up of the family has results far more pernicious than the platitudes often mentioned in the press. She walks into my surgery to ask for advice about a problem. I tell her she needs an operation. Her answer is that she has just discovered that her husband had been cheating on her, so she left him. Now with very little means at her disposal she will have to wait her turn to get the operation on our NHS, and that may take some time.

Like me, Dr Vassallo must also be aware of the ever-increasing number of young single women having abortions abroad. “Recent discussion on making it simpler for women to administer abortion-inducing drugs at home underlines the growing belief that abortion is essentially a matter of individual decision and not the kind of major moral choice that should involve a sharing of perspective and judgment.” That was the Anglican Archbishop of Canterbury’s, warning to his countrymen in 2007. Today Britain has the honour of having the highest rate of teenage pregnancy in Europe.

Who is responsible

for moral order?

Earlier, I asked the question of who is responsible for others when people refuse to be responsible for themselves?  The answer has to be that it is up to the government to protect the moral order that makes society possible. Thus today we see the state taking on the role of carer in the case of elderly parents or relatives, and of the missing husband when it comes to single motherhood. The problem is that when the government assumes moral responsibility for others, people are less likely to do so themselves.

In a contemporary world, where individual actors are not tied together by sentiments, culture, reciprocity and such like, the only civilian agency capable of providing moral guidelines would appear to be government. But then does it make sense to complain of state intervention?

The citizens of market democracies understand the freedom they possess, and appreciate its value. But they are confused when it comes to recognising the social obligations that make their freedom possible in the first place. They are unclear about the moral codes by which they ought to live. Neither the liberal market nor the democratic state is comfortable with explicit discussion of the obligations.  Both emphasise rights rather then obligations. Both value procedure over purpose.

The paradox of modern life is that the more people depend on one another owing to an ever-widening circle of obligations, the fewer are the accepted guidelines for organising moral rules that account for obligations.

Society needs guidance

The themes of civil society include autonomy and responsibility. That means we need to take responsibility for our own moral obligations. If modernity means a withering away of such institutions as the family and the social and religious institutions that once taught the moral rules of interdependence, then people need to find other rules to govern behaviour if they still want to enjoy that supreme gift called society.

The question facing us is whether we can live in societies organised by states and markets while recognising that reliance on states and markets does not absolve us of individual responsibility. The two MPs are not alone in their concerns.

  • don't miss