What do the European Supervisory Authorities (ESAs) consist of?
As part of the proposed European System for Financial Supervision, the Commission, following the recommendations of the Larosière Report has proposed the establishment of three European Supervisory Authorities which will form part of the European System of Financial Supervision (ESFS). The three ESAs consist of the European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority, the European Securities and Markets Authority and the European Banking Authority.
The intention here is the creation of a ‘single rule book’ that will enhance the possibility for effective supervision and certainty within the EU. In the Parliament there seems to be a generic consensus with regards to the need for a single rule book, nevertheless MEPs have also expressed the wish to extend the scope and competences of the ESAs. The decision making process that will be undertaken is that of co-decision and therefore this means that EP and the Council will have to find a common position on the proposed regulations. This might prove difficult seeing as the current positions are inconsistent and finding a compromise will only be the result of difficult negotiations. The Reports concerning these regulations have now been voted on and adopted by the Committee for Economic and Monetary Affairs and the trialogues involving negotiations between the Parliament, Council and Commission are currently underway.
In the context of recent events it has become necessary to give particular importance to large complex financial institutions. The term ‘too big to fail’ has been thrown around in the last years and has been especially significant with regards to the bailing out of large banks with public funds. The option of carrying out such supervision at a member state level by the competent national authorities does not seem to make much sense – especially due to the cross-border dimension of the industry and the systemic risk involved. Therefore the Europe option has gained momentum and we are now seeing the eventual setting up of these bodies.
A solution being found at an EU level would imply that ESAs would be able to dictate rules and measures when national supervisory authorities have failed to reach an agreement as well as imposing stricter supervision on those large institutions that the demise of which would threaten the entire financial system.
However this does not imply that the ESAs would function autonomously but rather, they would have to work in consultation with and through the competent authorities within the member states that would be legally obliged to follow the instructions of the ESAs.
One of the major issues of contention that is being debated during these negotiations involves the powers that may be legally derogated onto these supervisory bodies. On this issue the Commission has stated that the legal position is as follows: “There are clear and strict limits to the autonomous power of regulatory agencies in the current Community legal order. Agencies cannot be given the power to adopt general regulatory measures. They are limited to taking individual decisions in specific areas where a defined technical expertise is required, under clearly and precisely defined conditions and without genuine discretionary power. In addition, the agencies cannot be entrusted with powers which may affect the responsibilities which the Treaty has explicitly conferred on the Commission.” The debate is complex and hence it remains to be seen whether the wishes of the EP can be upheld legally.
An important logistical issue that will also need to be addressed concerns the seat of the ESAs. The EP is strongly in favour of a single seat for all three bodies rather than going for the option of them being scattered all over the EU. In recent committee meetings, it is Frankfurt that is being given prominence – possibly as it is the banking centre of continental Europe. The logic here is that it would also be positive to see the creation of informal channels between these agencies facilitating the timeliness of a possible response during times of crisis. The Council however seems well opposed to such an idea – the outcome will be the result of tough negotiations at the highest political level.