The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Image And reality in politics

Malta Independent Sunday, 4 July 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

The Obama administration is enjoying a very low dose of popularity. Commentators judge that while the BP tragedy is mainly responsible for this low rating, many Americans are now wondering if their President is nothing more than just a great orator and a master of the sound bite. The head of the American forces in Afghanistan and some of his aides certainly don’t think much of the leading figures of the Obama administration.

In the recent elections in the UK, we saw former prime minister Gordon Brown suffer on television due to his inability to be slick and his lack of the gift of the gab, qualities which both Cameron and Clegg had in plenty. So are political leaders now to be recruited only from those who feel confident when facing television cameras? To what extent is spin dominating the workings of government?  Obviously, this question applies here with the same force as elsewhere.

Well, slick talking has always been around and many great political leaders were also capable orators. On its own, spin has never thrown up great leaders, but nowadays it is often the trap that brings down governments as they rely on salvaging their reputations by presenting an image that can be very distant from the reality. Do such strategies work?

The many kinds of spin

Well, one hypothesis of spin says that it comes to the fore when a government has no ideological agenda of substance behind it. In the case of the UK this would mean that Blair took the country into a very unpopular war because he wanted to kill the belief that the Labour Party was a bunch of mealy-mouthed pacifists. His Princess Diana speech was an astute act of politicking; it lacked sincere feeling and was calculated to gratify the hounds of public opinion and, in the process, created an image of himself as a man who understands the people. In other words, spin doctors everywhere rely on distracting attention away from the grim reality by offering the public a different bone to chew on.

The second version of the spin hypothesis is a critique of the above. It claims that governments do of course have an ideological agenda and, like all ideological operations, their greatest wish is to appear not to be ideological. It recognises the emphasis that we tend to attach to presentation and appearance. It understands the power of the media.

The third position is that since spin is believed to supply a political image divorced from reality, the latter must exist somewhere else, perhaps in the domain of politics outside “vested interests”. The UK paper The Guardian once carried a composite picture of Tony Blair and his spin doctor Alastair Campbell asking the question which of the two governed Britain. This was a clever ploy of shifting the blame by

misleading people into whitewashing Blair and making them think that the “evil one” of the two was responsible for what was wrong. It indirectly suggested that the malaise in government might be cured if it got rid of the person/s polluting its policies. All the voting public had to do was to retain its faith in the possibility of at least one leading member of the government being an honest, sincere politician who was only there to serve. The last election here in Malta was run on precisely this premise.

In 2002, Campbell himself admitted that Labour’s attempts to control the media had been partly to blame for public antipathy towards politics. He admitted that, for a while, spin had been seen as something positive because when in Opposition all you have is words. A party in Opposition can devise policies but it cannot change people’s lives.

He then went on to admit that when Labour came into government, “we hung on to some of the techniques and ways of opposition for too long.” How long is too long? One decade, two or more?

So, which one of the above three analyses is correct? Which one, in other words, is the underlying truth and which have merely the appearance of truth? The suspicion might arise that in fact there is no truth lying beneath the veneer because the veneer itself is the truth.

No spin no politics

This is not saying, of course, that contemporary political reality has no substance. What is called spin has become an integral part of political reality and is central to the operation of contemporary party politics. It includes the defining and the getting out of the message – whether it’s how good your team is or how bad the others are – and keeping the politicians, as the jargon goes, “on the message”. It is about trying to influence how the media, or in the case of Malta NGOs, and the general public records and reacts to that message. Although spin concentrates a lot on form, it has not, from the politicians’ point of view, meant the abandonment of policy. The “spin doctor” can only be replaced by a superior form of spin that manages successfully to pass itself off as plain-speaking honesty.

After all, image or appearance is the predominant concern of all politicians, including those whose reputation is for “speaking their minds”. The curse is that spin makes it easier for integrity in politics to be substituted by the appearance of integrity – and these are vastly different things. This may explain why subjective identification with party politics is slowly dying: this applies also to Malta, as the generation that is still animated by their experiences of our recent past, grows old and dies out. We often see around the EU voting taking place in an attitude of pragmatism or even resignation: landslide victories are achieved even with low electoral turnouts. Paradoxically, the appearance of mass enthusiasm is often created in a situation of prevailing apathy. And turbulence abroad sooner or later makes its way to Malta.

The general effect is to compel people to think in terms of interests rather than in terms of what is the truth. It strips away their humanity and replaces it by the inevitability of accepting “modernity”, globalisation and market forces, pragmatism and the world “as it is” – in other words a situation that seems impervious to change.

Spin and dehumanisation

What makes us specifically human is our capacity for thought. Contemporary party politics, by focusing on image to the exclusion of thought, often denies this capacity.

The American businessman Henry Mayer once asked: “If you found a way to make all political advertising rational and accurate, or even if you improved its rationality and accuracy greatly, what would you have to do?”

His answer: “You would have to eliminate politics as we know it.”

  • don't miss