The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

Marilyn Monroe’s Chest X-rays auctioned

Malta Independent Wednesday, 14 July 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

It is very rare that I get to stay in a Sheraton Hotel, but the Ministry of Health of Dubai treats its guest lecturers well. One of the perks is getting The Gulf Today daily in your room early morning, and as my theory of the relevance of bioethics states that not one week passes that one does not get a bioethical issue in the news, a news item on patients’ rights did not fail to catch my attention. The front page of 29 June boasted an article entitled ‘Monroe chest X-rays auctioned for $45,000’.

Los Angeles: The apparently endless market for images of Marilyn Monroe now extends to inside the bombshell’s body. A set of three Monroe Chest X-rays from a 1954 hospital visit sold on Sunday for $45,000 at the Hollywood Legends auction at Planet Hollywood Resort and Casino in Las Vegas. Julien’s Auctions, which sold the X-rays, estimated that they would only fetch a total of about $3,000. Other Monroe-abilia that sold included a chair from her last photoshoot that went for $35,000.

The obvious question at this point is: Do the patient’s rights and privacy extend after a person’s death. Around the world legislation on this issue is not the same. In some legal systems it clearly does, in others not and still in others (no surprise Malta) it is ambiguous but can be interpreted that it does. The other issue which is often raised for people in public life is that they should tolerate a certain amount of infringement into their privacy and rights.

This may all be true, but in reality we are speaking about rights of people in general. Where would we draw the line? Supposing I discover X-rays of Dun Karm Psaila; does that give me the right to own them, given that patient information is now considered to be owned by the patients themselves – and that includes their hospital records? If they are mine, can I auction them? Should I not be tied to protecting the privacy of an individual? Of course we are not speaking about scientific studies here. It would perhaps be justified, following a decision by an ethics committee, to study what a famous person died of or suffered from. Such may require the use of investigations that were done during the lifetime of the individual. But to sell X-rays of a superstar as memorabilia in an auction not only reduces health to a commodity which can be purchased but infringes on the privacy of us all. For if I cannot be sure that someone will protect a popular individual’s privacy after death, then the privacy of each one of us is at stake. If no one except someone concerned with patients’ rights is worried about medical records being given to the public, who is to worry about us mere mortals after we die.

This case brought to mind two similar episodes related this time to politicians. The first was Francois Mitterrand’s case of prostate cancer which was revealed to the world by no one less than his own General Practitioner in a book written after the former premier’s death. That someone reveals (not merely speaks about) private medical issues, is already bad enough, but that one cannot trust one’s own doctor is really cause for concern. Why should this doctor have revealed the condition of his patient if not simply to make himself popular? It would have been fine should a doctor, in his own biography, deal with patients he has treated, but revealing their names and conditions is simply against any medical ethics known to man. Doctors cannot and should not have the luxury to speak about their patients frivolously, even if they are given permission by the patients themselves. Unless there is a solid reason which is important to the advancement of science, or perhaps history and fact, then there is no reason for doctors to breach their Hippocratic Oath after the person dies. We should not even know that this doctor treated Mitterrand; he could have merely referred to a politician. That he did reveal it means he sought something other than the common good – his personal popularity. Of course if I am the Prime Minister’s doctor and I say so publicly it will make me more popular.

The second was the agony I went through when Alfred Sant was hospitalised and how the media capitalised on his condition. I agonised because not only did the editor of a local paper make a claim on television that when he balanced the privacy of this politician and the ‘right’ for the public to know, he came out in favour of the latter, but a media person whom I respect came out in a two-pager defending him. Now it is clear that when politicians are hospitalised the media and the public would want, and perhaps have a limited right, to some information. But this information should be given in proper time and fashion by a representative of the politician himself and not by investigative journalism. There is such thing as ethics of journalism and of respecting people when they are ill, respecting the privacy of their condition and having the decency not to politicise further the issue should be the ethics of the day.

A medical man wrote in the New England Journal of Medical Practice, some years ago, that people have a right to know the health status of the politicians they elect in office. Therefore if a candidate for presidency have cancer, then the people should know. This ethic is debatable. What constitutes a disease serious enough, other than terminal illness perhaps, which the public has a right to know about before voting. Even if this were the case, the knowledge should be revealed in a timely fashion and certainly not because someone asked a friend working inside hospital about the condition of the individual. Back to Malta, it also speaks tonne-loads of the ethics of professionals when they discuss things between themselves which do not need discussion.

But back to Marilyn Monroe. Presumably the chest x-rays were taken privately (as it would be too scandalous where they to have been released by a hospital). They were part of her belongings. It is interesting to know where were they all this time. Who was keeping them? Who was their custodian? Should we be able to question whether something like an X-ray can actually be sold for something other than for research purposes. What if they find that the X-ray showed a shadow? One can imagine the expert advice that will be sought and the speculation of what she had etc. etc. this would release. Confidentiality in healthcare is an absolute unless the person concerned poses a danger to others (or themselves); this includes having a transmittable disease which is listed on the ‘communicable disease’ list. Even that the X-rays showed healthy lungs would still be private; but if they showed signs of chronic lung disease due to smoking, it would be infringing on the confidentiality owed to patients.

The problem is that confidentiality is an obligation only for doctors. Here no confidentiality was breached. What was breached was privacy – something completely different, although confused by many. If privacy was an issue, then everyone would have to respect it and not only her healthcare providers. Julien’s auctioneers would simply not have been allowed to purchase and sell the object. Now this does not mean that if I had to write a biography about someone and knew about his or her condition, I could not write about it. Needless to say, if I came to know about the information whilst in the practice of my profession, I cannot mention it. But other people often discuss illness. They describe things which reasonable people might find interesting and which reasonable people can easily find without looking into personal records. But if I take an X-ray and it is in my wardrobe; should it be found after my death by someone? Should we not question whether this piece of investigation is private?

We need not only to ask whether the person concerned would care about his or her X-ray being shown in public. For someone like Marilyn Monroe may not care less – but the very fact I make this statement shows the conclusion and speculation I may derive and which leads me to make a character judgement. The real question to ask must adopt a reasonable person standard. In general, do people care less about the information that is revealed after their death? Some may not care less; others, perhaps more conscious of their condition/s, would not want to. Even for research we give patients the right not to participate. So why should we breach that right once the person is dead? People continue to live in the memories of others for decades, and centuries, in the case of Marilyn Monroe.

But what displeases me most is that X-rays, done for a medical reason, are now being displayed on some wall (as certainly there was no contract signed to respect privacy), and whenever someone looks at them, the owner will reveal the identity as a trophy. Indeed after spending $45,000, one could imagine that the purchaser has already planned a party to display the X-rays to all. It is not the Monroe factor alone; it is the mere abuse of medical investigations when they are no longer required.

We often speak about insurance, employers, schools, etc. not having a right to certain knowledge and tests done. If we do not stand up for our own privacy, how can we prevent people and companies who have at least some legitimate claim on the medical information? It is not the information itself which is dangerous; it is the way it is handled. Our handling of Dr Sant’s health revealed a lot about our attitude as a people. It is not the fact that we may have a right about the health of an individual or not which is at stake. It is that we allow people to ask inappropriate questions. For someone had to ask someone else (probably an insider) what Alfred Sant was suffering from and the breach of ethics started right there! Should that question have been asked in the first place? The editor’s true choice did not lie in balancing privacy against the public’s right to know; the true choice lay in accepting a piece of investigative journalism which was ethically dubious. Certainly a piece of information obtained by a breach of confidentiality of the informer is like buying something with money you know is stolen.

When dealing with healthcare, the rules of respect for patients apply to all, even if the patient happens to be a politician. We need to wait for the appropriate press releases. Otherwise, as in the case of Monroe, we would be using medicine as a commodity or to promote our business.

Pierre Mallia is Associate Professor in Family Medicine, Patients’ Rights and Bioethics at the University of Malta; he is also Ethics Advisor to the Medical Council of Malta. He is also former president of the Malta College of Family Doctors.

  • don't miss