The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

Referenda And civil rights

Malta Independent Sunday, 18 July 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

The referendum is the best example of direct democracy where the electorate decides for itself by removing intermediaries in the form of their elected Member of Parliament

The only country in the world that has a system of direct democracy is Switzerland. However much we may envy the Swiss for that blessing, we have to keep in mind that we labour under a different system. That said however, for anybody to claim that the use of referenda is inherently undemocratic borders on recklessness.

The American Journal of Political Science contains a research paper by Barbara S. Gamble entitled “Does the popular vote destroy Civil Rights?” I think my readers must agree that the title couldn’t be more appropriate in the present circumstances.

When she reached the conclusion that between 1959 and 1993 anti-civil rights initiatives in the States enjoyed an extraordinary measure of success, she extrapolated that result to mean that therefore referenda were inherently anti civil rights. Well that may have happened in the States in that particular period but drawing that conclusion was another reckless statement.

Taking Gamble’s methodological approach, two other researchers went to Switzerland and, after measuring the same initiatives such as housing, public accommodation of minorities, gay rights, AIDS policies and other minority interests, they came up with very different results. 

At Federal level, 80 per cent of the issues went in favour of civil rights campaigns. At the level of canton and city, Switzerland too shows that referenda do not stifle civil rights. This research speaks clearly against the proposition that voters in a referendum tend to stifle civil rights. That is tantamount to saying that a people do not have a social conscience. Naturally, not every issue arising out of a minority interest is automatically a good one that the nation has to take on board. Addressing minority problems is a must if one is to enjoy a stable society, but we must bear in mind that we are living at a time when to simply state that an issue is a minority one, or a civil rights one, is expected to make it automatically sacrosanct. It doesn’t.

Naturally, in any referendum there are side issues. For example in Switzerland, when public housing for minorities came up, the rural areas voted against; but that was because the issue meant a strong redistribution of funds from rural to urban areas. Rural communities were simply not interested in financing minorities in other jurisdictions without receiving any benefit for themselves. This is why the question being asked in a referendum needs to be free from bias. There must be only a single policy dimension otherwise you get skewed results.

Referenda with a

clear dimension

And here I cannot agree more with Dr A. Bencini, writing in another section of the press, who expressed doubts regarding our ability to conduct a referendum in the proper way or to ensure a clear result. Yes, our history books tell us that the referenda on Integration and Independence were both contested in their time, but then we contest everything and anything. Still, his point that clear rules should be established before any referendum on divorce or any other subject is taken is incontestable. As is his clear statement that a referendum is the best example of direct democracy where the electorate decides for itself by removing intermediaries in the form of their elected Members of Parliament.

Should the short but unfortunate history of referenda in Malta put us off having another one? Hopefully not! It is indeed unfortunate that when Labour changed the Independence Constitution, a number of clauses subject to a referendum were dropped, thus depriving the people of having a direct say in their affairs. Nor did succeeding governments ever put them back.

The family and civil rights

At this point it may be useful to determine what civil rights are. Traditionally, the concept of civil rights” has revolved around the basic right to be free from unequal treatment based on certain protected characteristics (race, gender, disability, sexual orientation etc.). They need to be distinguished from civil liberties, which are more broad-based rights and freedoms that are guaranteed by the Constitution. The Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, deriving from the Declaration of Human Rights, acknowledges rights to food, housing, education, health care and other forms of social welfare as having claims on society and are indeed obligations that the political authorities of that society have to deliver.

Of great significance in the Convention is Article 10, which talks about the family and states:

The widest possible protection and assistance should be accorded to the family, which is the natural and fundamental group unit of society, particularly for its establishment and while it is responsible for the care and education of dependent children. 

Article 10 then goes on to define what needs to be done to protect the mothers and children of the marriage. That is what the word family in this Covenant means.

Article 3 of the same Convention goes on to protect the equal right of men and women to the enjoyment of all economic, social and cultural rights. However, Article 4 prudently adds that the State may subject such rights to those limitations necessary for the promotion of the general welfare in a democratic society.

The Common Good

And here comes the rub. Laws are imposed upon society to regulate the members of the community. This can only come about by all striving to attain a common goal. But this goal can be no other than the common welfare. Consequently, all laws must, in some way serve, the common welfare. Whether divorce does that must be the point of the present debate.

Cart before the horse

The Prime Minister has stated he would put the issue to the people. President Fenech Adami disagrees because he believes it is Parliament that should take the decision.

I believe the best way is a third one. The government must take a stand on the issue, and then submit that decision to the electorate. It cannot possibly not know its own mind as otherwise it would quite rightly be accused of passing the buck. 

I also believe that such an issue should not form part of the book of promises for a general election. Elections are held so that the people can pass judgement on the government’s management of the country. Health, education, the environment are all high on the agenda. But the economy, as always, reigns supreme. To try and swing an election by making it a pro-divorce or anti-divorce issue is to give it an unjust dimension.

  • don't miss