Malta is under attack. The European Commission has warned the government to hasten the reform of state-funded health care as well as the pension system. It argues that the ever-increasing proportion of older people in our society will create greater demands for health care. It claims that the number of retired people in Europe compared to those financing their pensions is forecast to double by 2060. If these forecasts are correct, then without corrective action a bleak future beckons.
As a medical practitioner and an entrepreneur providing hospital and care services, I have already made some of my views on health care known. But when it comes to pensions, dare I ask how we have come to such a pass? One reason undoubtedly is an exceedingly low birth rate, which is resulting in a slowly diminishing working population. Together with the citizens of Europe, we are so dizzily waltzing with Mammon that we are failing to realise that when the music stops, we might very well be too giddy to stay on our feet.
Pushing up fertility rates
So, independently of deficits, welfare, pensions and other problem areas, in the interests of our own people we require incentives to combat the decline in the fertility rate, which now stands at around 1.4. The initial aim would be to campaign to attain a fertility rate of 2.0 in a decade and indeed move up to 2.7 by 2030. France is doing it, so why cannot Malta do the same?
Improved female fertility would provide a substantial part of the solution. But, as I have said in other articles, we have gone beyond short-term solutions that apply only as far as the next election. This country and this people deserve better. We require more productive, high value-added investments that create jobs. As a result we would be able to improve the participation rate of those wanting to work. With more flexibility, childcare centres and the like, there could well be an improvement in female participation rates.
This would obviate the need for a working mother to get up in the early hours of the morning in order to park her one-year-old child with her parents and arrive at work on time. The sad incident that happened last week demonstrates the urgent need to put in place systems that will help working mothers balance motherhood with work commitments.
However, no single measure will, by itself, be sufficient to solve the pension problem. So a reform of the system, albeit a less radical one, would still be required. The European Commission and many other interested parties keep stressing the need to create mandatory second pillar pension schemes. The impression one is given is that practically every member state of the EU has them. This impression is false.
Second pillar pensions not universal
Only a few countries have Second Pillar Pensions on a nation-wide basis, and the vast majority of pensioners have to rely on a contributory state pension on which to live. It is alarming that today, in an EU that even in times of crisis is willing to pass on millions of euros to its elites, 80 million citizens are at risk of poverty. The plan to reduce this figure by 20 million by 2020 is hardly an encouraging statistic.
In Malta, the position is not all that good. The authorities keep mentioning adequacy of pensions without defining what adequacy means. The fact is that thousands of older people, who have made a valid contribution to the country’s economic well being in their time, are today living at risk of poverty – one that is real, not perceived. I meet them constantly and I know. While the EU average of over-65s at risk of poverty is 19 per cent, in Malta the figure was already 22 per cent in 2008. I do not believe that it has gone down. Substantial numbers of our people merely exist and lack that which makes life bearable. These brothers and sisters of ours require an improvement and not a cutback.
There is a similar problem for those at or near the top of the tree. In their wisdom, governments since 1987 kept the Maximum Pensionable Income (MPI) frozen at the 1981 figure of Є15,720 (Lm6,750). In 2005, COLA (the increase given annually to maintain the value of the minimum wage) started being added. So in January 2010, the MPI reached Є17,115, which is roughly equal to the maximum of those on Scale 11 in the public service. The maximum pension of Є11,410 which can thus be paid means that thousands of workers will see a substantial fall in their standard of living when they retire. Here it is pertinent once again to ask what can be cut back.
Keeping the majority consumer
group in pocket
Pensions’ reform in Malta is difficult, not just because of the instances cited above, but because occupational pensions just do not exist. Most industrial and commercial concerns are so small that it would be uncompetitive for them to subscribe to a second pillar scheme. And even if they did, would the lot of most of those in employment be substantially better?
What no one should forget is that, independent of society’s obligation to older people, the incomes of people in this category need to be truly adequate in the interests of the economy itself. They are the future majority consumers and if they do not have money to spend, the economy will jam up.
So yes, reform needs to be undertaken but my advice is to go piano pianissimo.