The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

J’accuse: Fairly Light

Malta Independent Sunday, 22 August 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

I type this week’s missive in the capital of former West Germany at the start of a 10-day whirlwind tour of the Palatinate and Rheinland-Pfalz. In a circular tour that starts and ends in Dusseldorf, I will be following the course of the Rhine for most of the trip until I take a little detour from the contested territory of Alsace (at least before the halcyon period of EU membership settled disputes once and for all) to veer through Strasbourg and Luxembourg before dropping my travel companions off at the airport north of Bonn.

Walking through the quiet streets of Bonn on a cool summer evening after a sumptuous meal of blood-and-liver-sausages (topping a mouth-watering apple compote and mashed potatoes that would make grandmas worldwide kill for a spoonful), it is hard to think of the goings-on back in the land where controversy springs from the purchase of a bunch of fairy lights. Is it poetic justice that lands the administrators of the island into such messy situations every time they dabble with the forces of nature and electricity? My travel companions tell me that just before they embarked on this trip of Germanic gourmand ecstasy and sightseeing there was an umpteenth power failure that led to airport operations grinding to a slow pace. Plus ça change they would say.

Anyway, as I was walking along the dimly-lit promenade beside the Elector’s Palace in Bonn, I couldn’t help but wonder how far from political goings-on you could get before you become completely disinterested in the answer to the question: “Is Paul Borg Olivier a new padrino in the making or is he simply a misunderstood political wunderkind?”

Il Padrino

For that is the current hot story, is it not? It’s hard to see where it really begins, but it has a particularly spicy episode in a pub named after England’s Rose in which the Secretary General of one of Malta’s two willy-nilly major parties is overheard bullying an OAP councillor into signing an “impeachment” letter directed at the current out of favour Sliema mayor. The investigative team at MaltaToday had a field day with the whole story and before I quit the Duchy to cross the border into the land of Kolsch and Riesling, I was watching their particular angle on the whole affair with interest.

Let’s try to get the story straight, starting from that very moment when PBO (I hate initials too – signed JRZ) and his side-kick cornered a mature adult long past the age of consent into signing a document impeaching a fellow local councillor who – up until the incidents in question – had run on the same party ticket as all the other characters involved in this Maltese version of The Sopranos. Why was PBO at Lady Di pub with a 60-year-old councillor (sorry but MT’s fixation with the age got me stuck to it too)?

The Prelude: months before all this it would appear that (allegedly) Sliema mayor Dimech (a young turk aged 33 – a traditional age for crucifixion in some circles) had behaved illicitly and had abused his mayoral power by asking for a commission on a tender/job. There are the entrails of another intriguing affair here, since the dramatis personae is actually spiced by the fact that the person involved in the tender in question has close ties with Dimech’s PN sponsor (ex Sliema mayor and backbench MP Robert Arrigo). The tender victim (pardon the horrible pun) of an alleged backhander gone wrong should therefore have actually been within Dimech’s extended circle of trust. At least that is what a normal human being would assume. But no. The issue of the proposed (and refused) bung is taken as read by most of the investigative journalists involved.

Which brings us to the next step. An investigation ensues when government and (hear, hear) party authorities report the case to the police. Sliema Local Council slips into momentary paralysis and until Dimech’s calling of an emergency meeting we almost forget about the whole ruckus. Then Dimech first bungles by calling an emergency meeting at the wrong time (‘illegal’ is too heavy a word here) then, when the meeting is actually held, we are regaled with a plastic interpretation of Kafkaesque proportions – as the councillors present seem to be chanting phrases according to a prearranged script.

Big Kahuna Burgers

Before you know it, Dimech is summoned for questioning at the police station and, according to whom you believe, he caves in and admits his wrongful dealings. Even if we were to set aside allegations by “friends of Dimech” (Dimech himself is never reported to have said this) that the whole business was a frame-up and that Dimech was forced to admit his guilt, the story retains a high level of appetising attraction. To begin with we get the PN acting ultra vires of its own rules of procedure and expelling one of its own without a fair hearing. To be fair, Dimech was given a choice – resign as mayor or else... When he chose the “or else”, Dimech was kicked out of the PN, which only means that he can carry on representing but not as a PN councillor.

Which is when the PN went for overkill. PBO and JP Debono donned the hats of John Travolta and Samuel Jackson and in a Pulp Fictionesque twist set out to obtain the votes of the remaining Sliema councillors in order to force the impeachment of the recalcitrant mayor. It was not Ezekiel 25:17 but it was the full brute force of a PN spin trip gone absolutely Pete Tong. For PBO did not count on one thing – volition. It transpired, much to everybody’s chagrin, that PN ‘burokrats’ seem to think that their councillors will just drop their pants whenever asked and allow themselves to be truly rogered upon request.

Sorry. Is my imagery too harsh? Well, let me try the mild way. When PBO and JPD set off for a pint and a chat with Madame Camilleri at the Sliema pub they probably were thinking that she would sign off her friend and council companion before they could say “Please”. Turns out they could not be any wronger (that’s more wrong than wrong). Camilleri sobbed and cried and stood by the received version (imagine PBO shaking his hand a-la-Cleese and yelling “thank you MaltaToday – thank you very bloody much”) that Dimech had been “framed” and that he was innocent and hence not deserving of a kick on the backside.

And here, amidst trumpeting of choirs and drum-rolls, did Paul provide us with the (mis)quote of the week: “Your mother or Dimech”. What the bloody hell? When MT presented this phrase (complete with an undecipherable video that looks like it’s been filmed by someone with Parkinson’s and provides the kind of proof an alien abductee would be proud of), we had a fun time at J’accuse trying to understand if PBO had lost his wits completely and turned into a knuckle-duster bearing thug.

I dare you, I double-dare you!

Say what? You see. It turns out that Camilleri is the kind of Good Samaritan who still takes good care of her nonagenarian mother (parents – they’re for life, not just for Christmas). We are quite sure over at J’accuse that PBO was not threatening a premature termination of life for the councillor’s mother – at least because this would be contrary to party principles on abortion. So how best to interpret this phrase that fell bang in the middle of a moment of coercion? Our first instinct was to blame it on PBO’s impatience – maybe Camilleri’s phone would not stop ringing with requests from her nonagenarian mother and PBO was simply airing his impatience and urging Camilleri to concentrate on more urgent matters.

Unless that is the answer then we can only speculate in a not so investigative manner that PBO has some kind of hold on Camilleri’s mother. A sleazy retraction of favours dished out earlier? Special attention within administrative levels? Who knows? What actually matters is not the import of the sentence but that two high-level party officials were actually witnessed bullying a government official within its administration in order to fetter her administrative discretion against her will. Now that is not something to go about lightly.

There may be a crisis at local council level, what with all the small-fry aspiring politicians being forced to quit their political career at an early stage because of their inability to understand the onus and responsibility of public service. Dimech-Gate exposes more than just the inadequacy of local council level politics, though. Far more than any BWSC scandal may hope to achieve, this heavy-handedness by a political party is exposing the warts of a system designed to produce robots and extended arms while the central machinery lives off the wreckage as much as possible.

Those who attempt to poison and destroy my brothers

The so-called small fry are being (rightly) grilled for misappropriation and mismanagement of public funds but, correct me if I am wrong, we still have no law about the transparent funding of political parties, right? While Nikki Dimech risks his career for €240 a month and Elisabeth Vella gets fried for €80, no one can explain the millions of euros channelled to the PLPN establishment and how this probably fetters discretion in the awarding of most government tenders involving millions of euros.

We do have a lone ranger on the PL side of the equation: Evarist Bartolo has once again mentioned the infamous “JS List” this week. Last February it vanished into thin air. This time Bartolo has been more explicit: “The PN has a system of fund-raising where companies win government contracts and donate money to the PN. They are all part of the PN’s JS list.” Now that’s some heavy stuff – stuff that goes far beyond the microcosm of Nikki Dimech and his fairy lights. I’d hate to see PBO in action trying to suppress this kind of nasty information – it’d have to be some big kahuna offers that nobody could refuse.

Are we on the verge of some form of ‘mani pulite’ cleansing? Probably not. MT’s investigative shit-stirrers notwithstanding, we will remain the country where such allegations of large-scale corruption are met with a cosi fan tutti shrug of the shoulders. We lack a magistratura in the Italian sense of the inquiring magistrate that could kick off an operation as Italy witnessed in the 1990s, and so we risk running straight into the ‘business as usual’ adage – and boy, what a business that is.

So what’s in the suitcase?

Fans of Tarantino’s Pulp Fiction movie incessantly speculate about what is in the suitcase retrieved by Vincent Vega (Travolta) and Jules Winnfield (Jackson) for their Mafia-like boss (Marsellus Wallace). It turns out that we never get to really see the contents of the suitcase because that is what the film producers decided. Their aim was to allow the audience to fill the suitcase with their own imagination. The suitcase is filled with whatever you want it to be filled. Like some of our news spinners, the producers counted on our affinity to fill the gaps in tales and build conspiracy theories in our heads.

My suitcase is packed for the remaining nine days of my road trip. It’s been spanking great weather until now from Koln to Bonn to Kongiswinter. Whoever says that German cooking is boring should be punished with a quarter-of-an-hour’s gruesome interrogation by PN’s dynamic duo. Long live the blutwurst, the liverwurst and the sauerkraut – top that up with a Kolsch or a Riesling and you’ll soon be wondering what was all the ruckus over the fairy lights about. Prost!

www.akkuza.com is in the land of Lorelelei and Der Ring der Nibelungen. Bear with us till September, but we are busy cultivating our Romano-German culture. There really are some sausages you cannot refuse!

  • don't miss