It may be that love, as the song goes, makes the world go round. It can also be that what many times pushes politics forward is revenge, many times personal revenge metamorphosed into feelings of injustice.
Take, as an example of this, nearby Italy. Luciano Gaucci used to own the Perugia football team. He was, maybe is, an extravagant person and his ownership of Perugia was turned by the big media, and also by his many mistakes, into a farce.
Then the club was declared bankrupt and Luciano was forced to flee Italy.
Then he lost his girlfriend, Elisabetta Tuliani, who became the girlfriend of Gianfranco Fini, the President of the Italian Parliament.
Fini had risen to succeed Almirante as the head of the almost-fascist Movimento Sociale and had inched it towards the centre. After joining the alliance headed by Silvio Berlusconi, the two merged their parties into one, Partito della Liberta in alliance with Umberto Bossi’s Lega Nord.
However, in recent months, Fini, more as a former head of a party than as the President of Parliament, started feeling nervous with the direction Berlusconi’s government was taking and with the many scandals that were erupting.
His first step was to disengage his amorphous group from the ruling majority. That effectively robbed Berlusconi of his majority. Things in Italy are moving towards a vote of confidence in Pparliament, which is where that majority can be found missing. An election would then follow, even though Fini still needs time to rebuild his party.
Enter Gaucci, intent on revenge. The story began to spread that Fini’s old party, Alleanza Nazionale, had a house in the exclusive Boulevard Princesse Charlotte in Montecarlo and that this had been purchased by Fini himself, or his girlfriend’s brother.
This allegation has been the rage over the past days, even to the point that evidence first led to an offshore company Printemps Ltd and to Santa Lucia, the island in the Atlantic where no less than a minister, Lorenzo Rudolf ‘Doddy’ Francis confirmed on Friday that the house had been sold to Giancarlo Tulliani, Elisabetta’s brother.
Fini and his associates claim this is all an attempt by Berlusconi or his allies to discredit him. There has even been a lawyer, formerly of Lega Nord, who claimed the house belongs to his client, who is not Giancarlo Tulliani.
There the matter stands, as of yesterday: Fini still keeps Berlusconi’s government hanging by a thread. Sometimes he votes against the government, as he did last week, but then the leftist Opposition loses the vote because some of its members either abstain or vote with the government. A vote of confidence is coming up and Fini can either decide to pull the plug or else keep the Berlusconi government in power until it suits him to pull it down.
Meanwhile, what goes for political debate still focuses on the house in Montecarlo and Gaucci’s revenge – all this while the Italian economy is still in the doldrums and urgently needs reforms. You see, that, in a way, this is how politics works – people are interested in the small picture of who owns a house in chic Montecarlo, who is sleeping with whom, than all the macroeconomic issues that must be tackled.
What happens in Italy, happens elsewhere too, and it also happens, mutatis mutandis (with the necessary changes), in Malta. The past weeks have seen a resurgence of some bad cases about which it would not be amiss to speak about as the politics of revenge. We have had the outburst of hurt and revengeful feelings associated with Dom Mintoff’s near death experience, we have and still have the Chris Said ‘affaire’, and the incarceration of a private investigator is today bringing out once again the anger and hurt felt by a man, John Dalli, who felt, feels, he was unjustly targeted and forced out and who, even now that he is a Commissioner of the European Union, still insists that the ones who did it must be identified and face the music.
People, not just here, but here too, instinctively slot themselves into either the ‘for’ or the ‘against’ camp.
There have been people who expressed themselves very strongly in favour of Mr Mintoff and people who have expressed themselves very negatively about those years. There will undoubtedly be people who ‘feel’ for John Dalli and, equally, people who either minimize the issue or who make it clear Mr Dalli should remain in Brussels, while he says he is more than ever present in Malta. As for the Chris Said issue, most people admit this was a private family issue in which Dr Said, as lawyer for one party, found himself sort of involved, but there have even been voices taking sides between the woman and her former husband. But mainly, the issue was instantly raised to a political level regarding the involvement or non-involvement of Justyne Caruana who comes from the other side of the fence.
Is all fair and permissible in love and in war? Rather, should private vendettas have political consequences? Whatever our ethical thinking on these and similar issues, we can rest assured that private vendettas will still occur, here and elsewhere, and that people’s feelings of injustices suffered could completely distort people’s vision and objectivity. For, in a way, such feelings of personal grievances also form part of the vast humus on which a person’s and later a country’s choice rest. Very few people in fact choose only for objective, non-personal, reasons. The rest, which includes ourselves, many times choose for very personal reasons. In a small community such as Malta, politics is not just local but also personal.
We may think that our society has given itself the institutional means to channel and regulate personal feelings of grievances, but note that of the three cases I mentioned, only the Chris Said issue is subject to a court’s scrutiny. Even so, such is our daily experience, people whose grievances are not accepted by a court rarely feel the court has delivered them justice.
Otherwise, who’s to gainsay John Dalli from saying and believing he was badly done by? Who’s to tell him there was no conspiracy against him? Who can prove to people who still believe Mintoff was the man who pulled the poor up by their bootstraps that he had a dark side too, and who can prove to those who feel he was the worst thing to happen to Malta that he also kicked Malta into modern times?
Can such feelings of injustices suffered ever be assuaged or at least sublimated into a positive thrust? Some think that only gaining or regaining power could do the trick, but a long view shows this is hardly the case. Yesterday’s victims tend to become tomorrow’s oppressors, creating further victims down the line. And so it goes on. I, and many of my age, was surprised by the vehemence that Mintoff’s infirmity caused, like a sore that bursts open. Even after all these years, those feelings of hurt have been just under the surface all the time, waiting to burst out. Similarly, and it is not a manufactured feeling, people are still hurt by the church’s political sanctions all those 50 years ago.
I began with Italy and with Italy I will finish. One hundred and fifty years after unification (that’s next year) and despite all its apparent modernity, there are areas in Italy where the hurts of the past are still very much alive in people’s minds. So too in Ireland, for instance, let alone the Balkans. It is a very wise people which learns how to integrate past suffering and learns to overcome anger and injustice with a renewed sense of justice. That, however, is only a pious hope in the experience of so many countries. And although it is less so in Malta, cases such as we have been seeing show us the wounds have not been healed at all.
[email protected]