The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

The Politics of power

Malta Independent Sunday, 3 October 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 17 years ago

It was a supremely confident Lawrence Gonzi who strode into the Cabinet Room at Castille on Thursday to announce the Whistleblower Bill.

In front of him he had all those who are anything in the administration – permanent secretaries, directors general, chairmen of government corporations – the lot. All sitting prim and proper as schoolchildren waiting for the headmaster (In fact, many of them rose up when the head – sorry, the PM – entered.

Yes, Lawrence Gonzi is supremely confident these days. His parliamentary majority is still of one, but it’s like it’s five or ten. Those who up to a year ago could have rocked the boat are now onside, some of them were actually sitting in front of him, as docile as the rest.

John Dalli is off his back, up in Brussels with the high and mighty – so much he had to take a page or two just to remind people he is still around.

As to opinion polls which mark him as less popular than Joseph Muscat, or not winning the next election, Lawrence Gonzi just does not care about these things. He won the last election, didn’t he? When everyone thought him down and out.

For this is Dr Gonzi’s fundamental mindset, the politics of power, the power of politics. He has been trained in the exercise of power, unassailable power, power that cannot be taken away, ever since his childhood from that supreme practitioner of power that was his great-uncle, Archbishop Sir Michael Gonzi.

Many people do not understand this and they tend to underestimate the man. He was always at the top of the institutions he formed part of, in private practice, in Catholic lay organizations. When he made the move to the Nationalist Party, he came in as Speaker, then as party secretary, then as minister later on as heir apparent. Flexible, unassuming, down to earth, careful and temperate, untouched by money or taint. But no pushover he, no weakling, he knows how to wait and how to bait his opponents into mistakes of their own doing.

He has surrounded himself with a small team of ministers, small because he likes it that way, it keeps administration simple, a team of loyal members who will not try to undermine him or row against him. There is no dissent around the Cabinet table – OK there may be dissent on this or that issue, there are turf wars, but no focus of opposition and no one agitating the unsatisfied backbenchers and pushing them to rebel.

Like a supreme power broker, Dr Gonzi knows and understands that the people around him are of limited abilities but he defends them to the hilt, more if they are Cabinet ministers, less if they are backbenchers but he still defends them even against his ingrained assessment.

Yet, make no mistake – he knows and remembers everything, and when the chips fall down he strikes, as he did as soon as he won the election. People he had been defending against all logic and out of pure loyalty for months, suddenly found the door closed.

He has become so confident in the exercise of power he is now becoming somewhat careless and superior in its exercise. I can see no other way to describe his attitude on the Fosos when ‘interviewed’ (if that’s the right word) by Charlon Gouder. The whole approach by the party was: Let’s get Charlon and have a laugh. And it was a Lawrence Gonzi that rarely lets slip – a thoroughly partisan Gonzi talking to partisans.

Well may he rejoice for he has survived the terrible first two years of the legislature with a very slender majority. Heads of government around him at the EU Council may have greater majorities but have fallen. Basically, he has offered the unruly a share in the government and they have jumped at it. See them strutting at every photo op and you realize how potent this drug is. Not that they’re doing anything much – some of them are incapable anyway and there are some really funny stories going round.

Permit me once again to draw a parallel with Italy. I was sitting there thinking last Thursday that some of our docile firebrands could take some private lessons from Fini who has now got Berlusconi, to use the English phrase, by his smalls and curlies. Significantly too, Berlusconi and his henchmen have been trying to entice people away from Fini by promising them ministries and other plum posts.

Other leaders may perhaps rule by opinion poll, not so our prime minister. The Opposition may rant as much as it wants on BWSC. Dr Gonzi has his sights fixed on the economy – and thank heavens for that! A government-by-poll would have driven us into the wall by now.

Even so, Dr Gonzi himself has his own limits, derived mainly from an incomplete appreciation of macroeconomic issues, and those around him are even more limited. Hence one finds little debate on the choices facing Malta in the bigger eurozone out there, and also a rather weak understanding of the weaker points of our economy – from what is going on in the financial sector to the issues regarding regulators.

His advantage, his big advantage, however is that Malta now has the EU, the ECB, the Maastricht Treaty commitments it signed, watching over it. Just like Archbishop Gonzi was covered by the august power of the British Crown in those years 1958 – 1962 when democracy was suspended.

His latest venture is a textbook example of the man. He issued the Whistleblower Draft because it was in the electoral manifesto and he intends to follow through all that the manifesto said down to the last detail. Other leaders would be more cavalier, but that’s the man for you.

On his specific orders, the bill goes to the outer limits of the experience of other countries. He and his team studied their laws and avoided their mistakes. He extended the act to cover not just the public sector but also the private one.

One wondered last Thursday why he did not invite the captains of industry along with the permanent secretaries – perhaps he was afraid they would rise up and tell him he never consulted them on this and anyway this is not what they want from the government.

It will not work, cannot work, with one exception and proviso about which later. It cannot work because the person who complains has to go to what will be known as the Whistleblower Official in every enterprise or department and trust his identify will not be revealed to the person he is complaining about.

The only way I see it working is in those cases when the person making the complaint stands to benefit from the downfall of the person reported. It was explained that there are safeguards to prevent this but I bet this is precisely what will happen.

Take the other enforcement actions we know about – the fumes reporting by SMS fell, it seems, into disuse. As to the huge Mepa backlog of enforcement notices, the last thing they were saying is they will draw a line with the new system coming on stream – which to some of us sounded dangerously like declaring an amnesty. The Ombudsman receives complaints from people about their own situation.

The new bill is about criminal or harmful actions which should be reported. There is a huge army out there of customer service, websites where you can report shortcomings, and an even bigger army supposedly to stop people from going wrong. Yet, traffic is left to its own devices, and parking tickets are only for those who park badly.

Dr Gonzi, after we had all been complaining for months, has had the decency at last to apologise for non-service from ARMS but the situation has still not gotten any better.

His most significant comment on Thursday was that the immediate predecessor to this bill was the reform in local councils when the government began sending in its own appointed executive secretaries instead of allowing council secretaries to be heavily dependent on the mayor for their re-appointment. Within 48 hours, he said, this new system was bearing fruit. It did indeed – look at the Sliema shambles.

So while we have had mayors resigning for many small or inconsequential reasons – even for allowing a daughter to access Facebook on the council’s laptop, we have had a councilor alleging improper action by an MP, and Dr Gonzi pointedly said the MP had denied it. End of story. We had a minister admitting not asking the maid for a VAT receipt. End of story. We had the secretary general of the party in government facing charges regarding non-payment of VAT. End of story.

But then we had a parliamentary secretary who resigned on a story regarding his private professional life. True, it’s a case of whether he said the truth or not, but why should this intrude on his political life, I asked people. Would a minister who hit somebody who died have to resign, I asked, to be told there was indeed a minister who did that. End of story. It’s only fair to state that the persons I put my question to, all said Chris Said did the right thing to resign.

I still see a tremendous dissonance between this and the other cases. Before the Whistleblower Bill and the Commission against Corruption Bill become laws, I still think we are setting up a kangaroo court for those with an axe to grind, providing further fuel to hatred, envy and the lot and not really tackling what is going wrong. We will be going round in circles and not really getting to grips with what needs to be repaired.

[email protected]

  • don't miss