The New Year resolutions come early for the judiciary and the rest of the legal profession. At the start of every forensic year we hear about what should be done to improve our justice system.
Delays in the courts always feature and there are many disgruntled people who would like to see a tsunami to clear the entire backlog.
In his inaugural speech on 1 October, at the opening of the forensic year, new Chief Justice Silvio Camilleri promised to do his utmost to increase efficiency and reduce court delays.
He said the time has come to stop passing the buck and that everyone who worked in the Law Courts had to start taking responsibility for their actions.
“One has to stop blaming everyone and everything except oneself,” said the Chief Justice.
So is everyone working at the Law Courts going to take this on to make the Law Courts work better? I asked two leading lawyers on RTK on Wednesday.
According to Toni Abela, also one of the Opposition leader’s deputies, “One would need a huge investment to make the Law Courts efficient”.
That of course is beyond the Chief Justice’s control and does not answer the question of whether everyone was going to chip in and do his or her bit.
“There is no doubt that some lawyers do use the current system for their own ends,” said Andrew Borg Cardona, president of the Chamber of Advocates, who also said, “Lawyers are not paid enough and that is why they have to spread themselves very widely.”
Both insisted that there was only a small minority of lawyers who abused the system and that most of them have a life of sheer grind.
I almost ended up feeling sorry for them.
A very important item in the Chief Justice’s speech regarded the efficiency of the ‘manager’ of the whole shebang – the Commission for the Administration of Justice.
It was time to re-examine the legislation, which set up the Commission for the Administration of Justice 16 years ago, he said.
“Certain issues, such as a more transparent and effective commission in view of the experience gained have to be addressed,” said Mr Justice Camilleri.
The Commission was meant to serve as a watchdog on the judiciary but, like other so-called watchdogs, they don’t even bark let alone bite.
A few yaps then on to the next item on the agenda does not make an effective watchdog meant to safeguard the democratic principle of justice being seen to be done.
The Commission is composed of 10 members: the President of Malta, as chairman; the Chief Justice, as deputy chairman; the Attorney General; two members elected from among the judges of the Superior Courts; two members elected from among the magistrates of the Inferior Courts; one member appointed by the Prime Minister and one member appointed by the Leader of the Opposition; and the president of the Chamber of Advocates.
So basically, it is a legal brotherhood, which of course has its drawbacks because professional ‘brothers’ tend to look after their own.
A mooted idea that there should be some lay people on the Commission to give it more credence was shot down by one of its members Andrew Borg Cardona – on the Commission as the president of the Chamber of Advocates.
He said the Chief Justice could chair the Commission, but he did not agree with suggestions that have often been made to include members of the public, reported The Times.
He obviously wants a closed shop. His reasoning, as explained to me on RTK, on Wednesday, was that lay people would not have any legal knowledge.
I am sure that a couple of lay people on a board of six to eight legal experts would be put right on any legal points, while the lawyers would get a much needed injection of grass roots perceptions.
“This is a constitutional body and, therefore, its competence should be respected and its direction observed,” said the Chief Justice on the Commission.
So why is the Commission’s competence not being respected and its directives ignored? As everybody knows, respect is earned and if directions are not followed up, people will ignore them.
“The Chief Justice may have alluded to the case some years ago when two members of the judiciary were rebuked and asked to resign from senior posts in sport organisations, since holding those posts breached the code of ethics,” opined Kurt Sansone, writing in last week’s Sunday Times.
The two judges ignored the Commission and there has been no comeback. Some imply that there are other members of the judiciary who are also breaching the code, but who for some reason seem to be beyond reproach.
So is the Commission applying two weights and two measures? Maybe, that is why the Chief Justice said that more transparency was one of the issues that need to be addressed.
Mr Justice Camilleri said that the judiciary was duty bound to account for its behaviour, including in public and social life.
The administration of justice was not only concerned with the way proceedings were conducted in the courtroom but also on how judges and magistrates behaved socially, he said.
Adding, “The Constitution’s protection to the judiciary in the carrying out of its duties was not a privilege to the judiciary but to the public because the safeguarding of independence and impartiality of the judiciary was beneficial for justice...
“Independence did not mean that one could do what one wanted... That was not independence but a devaluation of it...
“It did not mean independence from the ethical rules of correct behaviour and discipline, aimed at keeping the judiciary away from any shadow of mistaken perception of a lack of impartiality,” said the Chief Justice.
It is that perception that is so important to have corrected if our law courts are to have the respect they deserve.
It is also why, I presume, the Commission for the Administration of Justice was set up. Judges must be seen to be impartial.
Most of our judges are hardworking, lead irreproachable lives and conduct their cases with utmost integrity, but we cannot have judges, who not only flout certain conventions but also flaunt it publicly, sit in judgement of others. What they do privately is another matter.
[email protected]