The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

Jeffrey And Joseph should both think before they speak

Malta Independent Sunday, 17 October 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando has certainly made a mess of the advantage he gained by bringing before Parliament a Private Member’s Bill on divorce. He went from zero to hero but has now put a rocket under all that with some very loose talk and what’s more, to the anti-government MaltaToday.

He would have retained his advantage had he just kept his mouth shut after being called in by the Prime Minister for a meeting which nobody else knew about – or so it was thought. And if somebody did find out and ask him about it, he would have improved his image still further with a tight-lipped: “I am not in the habit of discussing what has been said at private meetings. Yes, we discussed divorce, but that is about all I am prepared to say.”

Now it turns out that Pullicino Orlando not only told MaltaToday about the meeting before it was held, but that when he emerged from that meeting, the first thing he did was ring the newspaper to say what was discussed and to embroider the subject matter with a few conclusions to which he had jumped.

When challenged about this, his response was that the Prime Minister had given him permission, should he be approached by the press, to say that the divorce bill would be debated in Parliament next year and that there would be a referendum afterwards. Yet permission to say such-and-such if confronted by a reporter is not the same thing at all as permission to ring the press yourself to divulge what was said. It especially cannot be construed as permission to ring just the one newspaper that happens to be the Prime Minister’s sworn enemy because its owners have never forgiven him for beating their own horse, John Dalli, in the party leadership battle. If Pullicino Orlando understands that MaltaToday invariably has an ulterior and negative motive where the Prime Minister is concerned, and still continues to collaborate and exchange information with its editor, owners and reporters, then it is fair to conclude that he shares in their objectives of undermining the Prime Minister. And if he doesn’t understand what MaltaToday’s motives are, then he is daft and should know a great deal better.

When Pullicino Orlando discussed with the Prime Minister what he might tell reporters who found out about the meeting, he did so in full knowledge that MaltaToday knew about that meeting already – because he had told them. That really wasn’t very nice at all. The story here is not the one that Pullicino Orlando ‘leaked’ to the newspapers. The story is the fact that he did so at all, to whom, and why.

We got a day’s worth of headlines about a referendum next year, and the Prime Minister’s office released a statement saying that no such thing was discussed. Pullicino Orlando then qualified his earlier words by saying that he had reached his own conclusions about the referendum, having assumed that one would be held after the debate in Parliament.

I put my head into my hands on reading that, and groaned in despair. Pullicino Orlando has been a Member of Parliament for many years now. He knows that a parliamentary debate on a proposed piece of legislation can end in one way only: with a vote. A bill is debated, then the house votes Yes or No – or Yes/No/Yes/No/Liar/I Heard You, followed by a fight and insults flung across the floor. Parliament does not debate a Bill and then suspend the debate, saying ‘Right, let’s put that on hold for a while and check out what the people think by holding a very expensive and time-consuming referendum and derailing the country for a year or so.’ This is not the way it goes: parliamentary debate – referendum – parliamentary vote according to result of referendum.

Nor can a referendum be held after the parliamentary vote. As Eddie Fenech Adami pointed out the day before yesterday, that could actually be unconstitutional. If Parliament votes, then that’s that: a Yes vote means we get the legislation, and a No vote means that we don’t. The only scenario in which a referendum can take place after Parliament legislates is an abrogative referendum, to repeal that legislation. That is, if Parliament votes in favour of divorce, and divorce legislation is enacted, then it would be possible to hold a referendum to repeal the divorce law. Italy did that, and the No vote won, which is why Italy still has divorce.

I am glad that Fenech Adami spoke out once more against holding a referendum on divorce, which he describes as a matter of principle. He has a lot of clout and his views carry plenty of weight, so perhaps he might knock some sense into the referendum maniacs. I am curious to see what the prime minister has to say about it, on Bondiplus tomorrow night. So far, he has been quite cryptic, talking about the decision having to be taken by the people. This has led most – including rush-to-MaltaToday Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando – to conclude that he means a referendum. I thought that, too, at first, until I realised that we are but two years away from a general election and that this is what the Prime Minister probably means. There is no point in holding a referendum, even if you agree with having one for divorce in the first place, and then having a general election soon afterwards. Divorce is not EU membership. ‘Let the people decide’, at this point in the proceedings, must mean a general election.

Perhaps I should point out here, because many of you will have missed it in the hullabaloo, that the only big political party which can include divorce in its 2013 electoral programme is now the Nationalist Party. The Labour Party cannot do so because its leader has committed it to a free vote on divorce. For those who are unfamiliar with these arcane matters, anything a political party includes in its electoral manifesto is a pledge, which means that all MPs standing on the party ticket are committed to that pledge, must support it, and have to vote with the whip when it the time comes to legislate. So if a party pledges divorce, in its electoral programme, all MPs who are elected on that party’s ticket must vote Yes when the divorce bill is brought before Parliament.

Joseph Muscat has gone on record several times over as saying that Labour MPs will be allowed to vote as they please for or against a divorce bill, and this means he cannot commit the Labour Party to divorce legislation in its 2013 electoral programme. This is tragic for the Labour Party, as the divorce field has now been left wide open for the Nationalist Party to grab for itself.

Lawrence Gonzi, a lawyer, experienced politician and above all, former Speaker of the House, hasn’t committed himself and his party to a free vote for precisely this reason: he wants the Nationalist Party to be able to include divorce legislation in its 2013 electoral programme should it be thought best to do so. The Nationalist Party can’t pledge divorce if Gonzi does the stupid thing Muscat has done and promise a free vote. I wonder whether Muscat has understood by now just how he has painted himself into the tightest of corners on the single issue he has touted to brand himself as a liberal.

www.daphnecaruanagalizia.com

  • don't miss