Malta has been in the charge of the same Nationalist administration since 1987, apart from a 22-month span between l996 and l997. During that period, its vicissitudes have taken a turn for the worse due in part, but by no means exclusively, to the recent adverse conditions in the inter-national market place.
One can argue about the nature and scale of these adversities, but there is no room for argument over the end result. The economy has stalled. In fact, it started to shrink for a time, rather than grow. There has been a dearth of foreign investments and Malta has started to lose its competitivity at a significant rate. And while the administration has been struggling for survival, it has had to bear the remorseless yoke of a structural deficit of its own making, and to incur mounting national debt that has caught the eye of interested Malta watchers.
It is high time we persuaded politicians to stop looking the other way and for businessmen and trade unions, interested in their survival, to stop moaning and to be positive.
All those with a stake in Malta’s economic survival must pull up their socks and be prepared to be open-minded, if the attempt to regenerate economic and social activity is to have a dog’s chance. The PL’s call, inviting the cooperation of all progressive forces to join hands in order to achieve a turn-round, was sound, in that it was all-inclusive and free of doctrinaire shackles. In a climate of tolerance and consensus, the cross pollination of ideas could yield positive results.
It is the social partners in particular, and civil society in general, that have the highest stake in this initiative. Whether or not there will be an active and spirited national debate will indicate to what extent public opinion is on the alert, and whether opinion leaders are comatose or not. Malta could produce the leadership that justifies and deserves national confidence.
There are grounds for confidence in Malta’s potential to achieve sustainable growth – an objective it achieved against not inconsiderable odds when it switched from a fortress to a national economy on assuming independent status.
The momentum achieved at that time has been lost and the challenge now is to recoup that lost ground. Malta needs all hands on deck, and everything depends on its ability to remain competitive in a globalised world of unforgiving competition.
A number of avenues for effective action could be explored. They include a reduction of the tax burden, improving the level of education and orienting it to Malta’s needs, upgrading the tourist sector, and better utilization of Malta’s available resources through outward-oriented initiatives.
The health and pension problems ought to be tackled in order to open up social perspectives – all of which bear in-depth, thorough discussion with a view to early initiatives.
This is a time for red meat and not for picking bones of contention. Much depends on whether the powers-that-be will succeed in triggering constructive public debate, leading to the coordination of the necessary initiatives to achieve concrete forward movement. Time will tell.
In my personal view, the very core of the problem is the quality and managerial competence of the top rungs of the civil service, which is the chief human instrument of state power, and the ‘software’ of our system of governance.
Politicians might find ways of agreeing on new initiatives and new experiments. But, whoever is in office will have to depend on the managerial skills or otherwise of civil servants paid to do the job. There are competent civil servants in the ranks, but there are others less qualified and even less disposed to assert their authority. There have been isolated incidents when civil servants of integrity have stood up to encroachments on their prerogatives and unfortunately have been crushed rather than rewarded.
The Maltese civil service distinguished itself under the trying conditions of the last world war. Its top officials were able to cope with the formidable challenge of post-war social and economic development. Unfortunately, things have changed for the worse.
In large part, this deterioration was brought about by the arrival of overpowering politicians, intent on usurping power for their own personal aggrandisement. We have reached a stage where ministers glory in sole performances and some, if not all, of their top civil servants play the role of willing stooges. Each time they occur, such situations are ugly to behold.
Setting apart the issues of competence, integrity and authority, the topography of the Maltese bureaucratic landscape has also changed with the emergence of several agencies, authorities and quangos. What was once intended to be a unified service has thus been fragmented, and is being manipulated from quarters removed from direct parliamentary scrutiny. The Enemalta story eloquently bears this out. The lamentable story of ARMS Ltd continued to drive home this point to a government that has been sliding from impotence to paralysis.
Under ideal conditions, the civil service should act as a permanent piece of ballast under the Constitution, on the basis that one can have a very volatile legislature and an equally volatile ministerial executive – a situation that calls for a high degree of balance and permanence. This state of affairs prevailed for long periods in post-independence Malta, and the civil service as a whole failed to stand up to political encroachment. It opted to hunt with the hounds and run like a rabbit. It lost its élan, never to retrieve it.
Excessive interference by domineering politicians, and by faceless unelected interlopers, operating from far-away places under the wing of wily politicians, led to the abdication of responsibility by many high-ranking civil servants.
At the risk of repeating myself, I submit that, deplorable though all this might be, it should not be allowed to mask the superior reality that, by and large, the Maltese civil service has not produced of late anything like enough top-notch managers and administrators to sustain its vitality and its historical reputation.
An efficient bureaucracy needs top people with initiative and a depth of field, who can take decisions and provide leadership. In spite of launching a major, very expensive, reform more than 10 years ago, the Maltese civil service never came round to delivering the goods. It has been found wanting due to lack of managerial acumen in many sectors. The bureaucratic rot has eaten its way into the heart of an otherwise healthy apple.
The right solutions have to be found. They do not depend on additional structures or on the invention of new and more expensive ways to feather the nest of complaint yes-men. The decisive sorting out has to be done by the stakeholders in Malta’s future, with the willing involvement of the political class.
The alternative is a clear and present danger to Malta’s survival.