The danger I am speaking about today has nothing to do with cosmic danger, even though this universe as we know it is hurtling into space at an incredible speed.
Yet we know we are in a planetary system that somehow is self-contained and centres around the sun, where seasons follow each other and night follows day. So we don’t really mind.
The danger I want to speak about today has nothing to do with our cosmic surroundings. We are in great danger indeed, for no one seems to know which is the best way forward for the European economy in these post-recession years.
On Thursday, along with a hall-full of other guests, I attended a mesmerizing HSBC business breakfast at which the main speaker was Karen Ward, Senior Global Economist at HSBC Bank plc UK.
Using very simple terms she led us through the succession of crises the world has been through these past two years – the housing crisis first, the banking crisis then, and now the sovereign crisis. A fuller report of what Ms Ward said will appear later.
She then analysed the policy options that countries and continents could have to tackle the present crisis but one after the other she struck off these options because they are not allowed in the eurozone. At the end one was left with either praying, or insisting on an austerity that will kill off any chances of growth or else – or else nothing. There are no other options left, except to default.
The eurozone cannot allow inflation to refloat the economy, cannot devalue the currency, cannot do nothing or it will end up like Japan – waste an entire decade in deflation. More austerity will see serious riots and social unrest, governments being toppled down.
This is the euro’s first big crisis and it is increasingly clear that while there is no realistic option of decoupling the separate currencies that make up the euro, there are serious engineering flaws in how the euro is structured.
Edward Scicluna, who was sitting next to me, confirmed Ms Ward’s pessimism. From his point of view as Vice-Chairman of the EP committee on economics, coming from so many round tables and what not in Brussels, he could only confirm that no one has any idea how Europe can come out of the present impasse.
This was also confirmed by three long articles on the Financial Times last week which told how Europe survived by the skin of its teeth from near-cataclysmic disaster last April and May but which also left one thinking there may be similar or even worse scenarios at some point down the line.
Let us take a wider view: on the one hand there is a US that is in serious difficulties as an economy, with so many unemployed, with growth that has not come, with government debt increasing all the time, and yet all it seems it can come up with is something called ‘quantitative easing’, which, as Ms Ward told us, is just another word for printing more and more money.
On the other hand there is the world’s second economy, China’s, whose currency is according to most overpriced but which holds masses and millions of US bonds. If China were to do as it is being asked to, revalue its currency, its exports will become costlier and its sales will drop, hence millions will be put out of work.
In the case of Europe, there was a time, at the beginning of this year, when with Germany’s surge in exports, surprising growth was registered. But since then, the euro has appreciated and its trend, which was heading towards parity with the dollar, is now heading to $1.50, thus making any European export costlier than its competitors. Hence, growth wound down and an anaemic economic climate was engendered.
It is against this background that tomorrow week’s Budget must be seen. The constituted bodies have had their fun coming up with wish-lists all summer. Those not around the MCESD table have had their run of banging on the door and asking to be let in.
When all is said and done, what matters is how Malta positions itself over the coming months, years. That is what is imperative now. That is the only yardstick with which the Budget must be measured.
It is in Malta’s strategic interest to position itself as the only Nordic country in the entire Mediterranean, the only ‘virtuous’ country in the swathe of southern European states with high deficits and even higher debts.
If Malta were to go along the trend of Greece, Italy, Spain, etc it would suffer even more than them for the smallness of the open island economy would work harder against it.
Nor is it an option, at least for the foreseeable future, to exit from the euro. Nor would it have been far better had Malta never joined the euro. Can anyone imagine how the world crisis would have impacted on a small isolated economy?
There has been far too much government hype on the growth registered in Q1 and on the tourism figures. As to the first, just like Germany but obviously in a very different dimension, the growth spurt has evaporated. As to the second, you speak to people from the industry and they tell you they did not see a 12% increase in their sales. And apparently even the government has been complaining its revenues did not see any 12% spurt.
There are areas of the national economy that have done well or are doing well, but these tend to be in the high-end sectors of financial services, online gaming and the like.
Other than that, there are vast areas of the national economy that are still in deep recession, from construction to manufacturing, from retail to the self-employed. Some of our problems are indeed self-inflicted, as is the case of retail with more and more outlets competing for less and less shares of the cake from people who have less and less money to spend. Or as is the case of construction where contractors find it does not pay them to work on their own projects, and it does not pay them either to work for others as the mark-ups they make keep getting smaller and smaller.
The government still does not seem to have understood how vital it is to reduce government expenditure and to bring about some order into the chaotic way of doing things, cut down waste and streamline itself so that people do not waste valuable time running from one office to another just to get a permit, do not have to face multiple regulators sometimes in conflict between themselves. Nor does it seem to have understood how essential it is for it to deliver its services seamlessly and without hiccups, roads that are a delight to travel through, and to see to it that the private service providers do not screw up people – for that is a clear government duty too, in case market economics have made us forget it.
It would have been swell if the government were to remember its electoral pledge to cut down on taxes, but it does not look like this is the right time to do it, not while we are still outside the 3% deficit Maastricht mark and at a time of slow if any growth.
It would also be ideal to raise the minimum wage or even better to substitute it with what Red Ed is calling ‘a living wage’ though to promise it to the least productive part of the country that is the people on the government wage bill rewards those who least account for growth in the economy.
While the French riot on the streets, and the Greeks clamber all over the Acropolis, while the Italians change their government, and assuming no nation sinks in default, wait for next Wednesday and listen to the cries of rage coming all the way from Britain when David Cameron announced the meat and bones of his savage cuts.
We do not, so far at least, have anything of this here, but I still do fault the government for not doing what Cameron and the rest are doing – check and control the waste and the fraud in the social assistance sphere. People tell you “U iva” why tackle these when there is so much corruption and waste at the top? Maybe that is true as well, but that is, to my mind, the swiftest road down to Greek, and Portuguese, and Italian, and Spanish, etc levels.
We must not, we just cannot allow ourselves, to go there.
[email protected]