True that JPO’s private member’s bill (PMB) came in rather unexpected fashion, considering that few would have imagined that the issue would be brought up by an MP from a deeply conservative party under the watch of a deeply conservative prime minister with deeply religious roots.
Also, few would have expected the PMB to be served in the time of this legislature as Joseph Muscat’s pledge to present one in the next legislature, and which set the tone for the debate, gave assurance that society would gear up to the matter in a couple of years.
Perhaps the Archbishop’s first reaction that the PMB came like ‘a bolt from the blue’ shows that the Church itself was unprepared for the debate at this time, possibly because its authority and resistance on matters related to divorce had remained unchallenged for so many decades that it took it for granted that divorce would never be introduced in Malta.
But what I find strange about the Church’s overtly bullish reaction against the introduction of divorce, particularly Mgr Said Pullicino’s reference to mortal sin, is that it is silent on already existing legislation in place undermining the Church’s authority, to some extent, on marital issues. I am referring here to the civil annulment of marriages.
The Labour Government of 1971-1976 had introduced legislation – without the need of a referendum – introducing civil annulment of marriages as a parallel to annulment proceedings before the Ecclesiastical Tribunals. The ordinary courts can declare a marriage to be null and void for specific reasons mentioned in the civil law as contrary to Canon law.
To this very day, marriages are annulled with the blessing of the Civil Courts and couples – even with children from the first marriage – can re-marry before the Marriage Registrar, and in fact, have been doing so for decades. They obviously cannot re-marry in the Church for the obvious reason that the Church does not recognise the annulment of the first marriage obtained before the Civil Courts.
It is because the Church still considers a marriage annulled by a Civil Court to be perfectly valid and it would be contradictory for it to allow one of the spouses or both to re-marry in the Church.
But if the Church considers a marriage annulled by a Civil Court to be still perfectly valid, then judges, lawyers and re-married couples who have had recourse to the civil law regime have been living in mortal sin since the early seventies.
Is this not consistent with Mgr Said Pullicino’s views?
John Dalli
He is in the headlines again.
It seems that although he has been kicked upstairs to the European Commission by his eternal rival the Prime Minister, this has served little consolation for him, if at all, as his failed attempt to lead the Nationalist Party still seems to burn inside him. His missive about false allegations made against him which, according to him, should now be investigated, speaks volumes. He is still seeking justice for the wrongs he says have been committed against him. He may have his good reasons to pursue this course of action.
But has he not forgotten that it was he who had wrongly accused Joe Ellul Grech of forging Mr Dalli’s foreign bank documents and mailing them around the islands? Well, Mr Ellul Grech had to endure years of criminal proceedings because of Mr Dalli’s allegations but was acquitted in spite of Mr Dalli’s allegations. I was Mr Ellul Grech’s lawyer then.
If Mr Dalli thinks that heads should roll because he was wrongly slandered and bad mouthed, then should he not be thinking of his own head too?