It made me feel proud to be a Catholic – not that I am not usually proud – but we all know the suffering that many people who cherish the Church are going through, both with taking advantage of unfortunate criminal acts and also because perhaps we all suffer from time to time by some member of the clergy who may want to misinterpret us or simply give us a hard time. It is certainly not a cause to lose one’s faith; but it can put you off for years. It is a moment of personal growth as well and can be a mild form of spiritual ‘night’ as described by St John of the Cross.
Of course, my immediate reaction as an academic involved in bioethics is: why not issue such statements for the so many areas of bioethics which need illumination? Clearly there are many areas which cannot have their position changed – such as abortion or euthanasia, etc. But there are many other areas of controversy where one needs to move with one’s conscience, even after having been informed. And these areas are clear even to those of good faith – they are areas where priests, in their pastoral care, have provided people with their moral support and good guidance for ages. But it so happens that the official teaching may have to be put in good light so as not to allow people, be them priests or laity, to turn the suffering of humanity into a crusade. We are not speaking about sin; if we were, there would be no bioethical ‘dilemma’ here as it were. I can think of a few which come to mind, which I am sure the reader would be most familiar with:
In vitro fertilisation
We all know by now that the official position of the church is that in vitro fertilisation is considered illicit by the Catholic Church, primarily because it bypasses the conjugal act, and also because of consequential moral problems. However many consequential moral problems have been overcome. Last week we witnessed the Nobel Prize for the inventor of IVF and a monsignor said that he was responsible for the many embryos that were frozen. Clearly this is not the position of the Church. We have the Nuclear bomb – yet we never blamed Einstein or all the other scientists, from Pauli to Rutherford for studying the atom and its mysteries and possible help to humanity. Science can never be held responsible for a good which is abused. Clearly many couples take the advice of their parish priests or moral theologians that they know and they are always encouraged to be informed and make an ethical decision based on their own conscience.
End of life extraordinary treatment – removal from life support
There are many who are put on life support when it soon becomes clear that there is no hope for life. Medicine cannot remove someone from life support unless the criterions of Brain Death have been reached. Yet we often forget that the teachings of the Church allow us to choose between what is ordinary and what is extraordinary treatment – and this treatment has nothing to do with the state-of-the-art of the treatment itself or with what the doctors think. It is a personal choice (for my grandmother, it was not going to hospital), and it is respected as so. Pope Pius XII said that doctors can never treat without the consent of the patient. The patient has a right to refuse and failing the competence of the patient, the families’ decision must be taken into consideration. We forget that historical cases, won even in court, were by Catholic families helped by the Church, to remove people from life support and allow them a dignified death even though they were not yet brain dead.
Persistent vegetative state
The recent case of Eluana Englaro and the Terry Schiavo case have given rise to the controversy which exists regarding those in a persistent vegetative state. Again the former case showed how misleading even Catholics can be when they forget how to apply moral teaching which are their to guide us all. Clearly if a persistent vegetative state arises as a side-effect of a life support system, which I could have omitted, then why should I be kept on physiological feeding for 17 years? When patients do not want this form of treatment, we cannot paternalise and say that it is ‘ordinary’ care. Families should be allowed to participate, again on their conscience and in the light of Catholic teaching, to decide for their loved ones if there were no prior decision on the part of the patient.
After all it is not ordinary care, in the sense that it is a life support which, simple as it is, requires expertise of personnel, constant periodic monitoring by physicians, and is given only to ill people. People who are dying naturally stop drinking and feeding, and this should be done only perhaps to keep them comfortable in their last moments, and not to force-feed them for 17 years in a vegetative state. Again, some families may be comfortable with this, and based on conscience will keep their loved ones alive in this state.
There are so many other areas where not only dialogue but clear guidance as this one on divorce, will help people facing these difficult decisions. The Church has often helped, as was the case with the Gozitan Siamese twins; society can have it another way. Focusing on informed choices and conscientious decision making is clearly a way forward rather than crusading against scientist or people who disagree.
Pierre Mallia is Associate Professor in Family Medicine, Patients’ Rights and Bioethics at the University of Malta; he is also Ethics Advisor to the Medical Council of Malta. He is also former president of the Malta College of Family Doctors.