Here we go again. Like divorce, the ‘should women work after they have children’ is one of those tiresome debates which raises its head every so often.
In the case of divorce, it was JPO who dragged it out of the cupboard again this summer, dusted it off, and thrust into the limelight once more. I cannot, really cannot write about this subject anymore without becoming rigid with boredom, except to point out that by putting it to a referendum the Prime Minister has neatly (and rather slyly) sidestepped taking any political responsibility.
If the ‘Yes” vote passes he can soothe the conservative faction by saying “it was not my government which introduced it but …that’s what the people want”.
And if the ‘No’ vote passes he can turn to the liberals and say, “I tried, but heqq the people don’t want it.”
Either way, it’s what can only be described as a cop-out. The country really cannot take another long drawn out referendum campaign.
Come on Joseph Muscat, just put it in your electoral manifesto and let’s get on with it.
Baby, baby
Now, the talk of the town is the European Parliament’s vote to extend maternity leave to 20 weeks to all EU member states.
Cue the predictable uproar.
I don’t need to repeat the arguments by the Malta Employers’ Association and Malta Business Bureau on this issue… actually, I could have practically written out the statements they released myself because their reactions are completely understandable. The first thing any employer must have felt when reading about the EP vote was overwhelming dismay, if not despair, at the thought of the havoc which this new legislation will wreak on his/her overheads.
Employers can hardly be blamed for taking stock of all the women in their company who are of child-bearing age… and shuddering.
To be honest, most women were not surprised at this reaction either. It is obvious that while it might sound like a great leap forward for women who want to continue working after having children, the reality is that it is opening the way for prospective female candidates on the job market to be silently discriminated against.
Meanwhile, on Friday, the government announced that it will vote against this proposal during the European Council, together with the UK and The Netherlands. According to the Malta Confederation of Women’s Organisations, “this is a hard blow to Maltese families and especially to mothers who expect better treatment from government”.
The MCWO also noted that the UK is much more generous than Malta and offers 52 weeks of maternity leave. This is paid in full for the first six weeks and then mothers get £123 a week for the next 33 weeks. Likewise, The Netherlands already offers 16 weeks fully paid maternity leave (two weeks more than Malta). Malta offers the minimum possible maternity leave…14 weeks.
I spoke to Lorraine Spiteri, from the Women’s Study Group who is also a member of the MCWO. She pointed out this salient fact:
“Malta is one of the few countries in Europe where the cost is pushed onto the employer and thus the employer becomes a sort of social service provider. As a Confederation we do not agree that the employer as a private entrepreneur should shoulder this financial burden. In countries with the longest maternity and parental leave (where it is paid by the state), the levels of female employment are much, much higher than ours.”
Indeed, why is the cost pushed completely onto the employer, and why is it pushed on to the employer of the woman? The company for which a prospective father works doesn’t take a look at this 20 or 30-something newly married man and think, “Good grief, if he has children, I have to fork out money for paternity leave and pay for someone else to replace him while he bonds with his baby.”
And yet, it is becoming patently obvious that these thoughts do flit through the minds of employers who are interviewing women when there is a vacant post. Some go so far as to ask a woman point blank about her plans to have a family – even though on paper, this is illegal. Whenever I explain this to women they tell me, “but I wanted the job, what was I supposed to do, argue with the people interviewing me?” They’re right – it’s not like good well-paid jobs are thick on the ground at the moment.
If the new law is passed, paternity leave for the father will be increased to two weeks, which is just about manageable (depending on one’s job), but even this must have caused employers to reach for their calculators.
Girl power
What it all boils down to is whether it pays a company to invest in having women on its workforce, even if it means a dent in its finances in the short-term so as not to risk losing an experienced female employee who is good at her job, in the long-term.
I took a quick tally of the women employed with my company, Standard Publications. There are 27 women as opposed to 23 men (including part-timers). Of these women, 11 are mothers – three of whom have had babies while working with us and came back after maternity leave, while the other eight have grown up children and have been working for many years with this company. Clearly, this is a company which not only believes in women, but also believes in making it easier for mothers to continue working as it does offer them a measure of flexibility when necessary. This flexibility not only has not been detrimental to the women’s productivity, I would say that it has made them better employees. They want to get the job done quickly and efficiently and let’s face it – multi-tasking is most women’s middle name.
Without taking any merit away from my equally hard-working male colleagues, I have no hesitation in saying that our company would definitely be the poorer without the female factor. Most women I know have a very strong work ethic, and when they know that they have a house to run and children to take care of when they get home, they are virtual workhorses.
While I’m on the subject, may I just add that I object to the myth which is often perpetuated that women don’t work well together, because in my experience (over the years, I have worked with eight different organizations) this is simply not true. No, it is not just women who are prone to catty and bitchy behaviour. People are people and difficult characters come in all shapes and genders.
So while the proposed extension of maternity leave means an employer will now weigh his options more carefully when he is about to choose who to employ, I ask employers reading this to make a quick assessment of their current workforce and ask themselves: how much do their female employees contribute to the company?
If the answer is that they give a substantial perhaps crucial contribution and are a great asset, then I would say investing 20 weeks’ salary in a woman, is an investment which is very sound.
[email protected]