The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

Lies, The PAC and ethics

Malta Independent Sunday, 24 October 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 17 years ago

If our noses were to grow like Pinocchio’s every time we told a lie, then we would not be able to take a leisurely walk down Republic Street or along the Sliema promenade. We would be “crossing noses” all the way.

Mark Twain once said: “If you tell the truth, you don’t have to remember anything.”

He’s right.

But people lie. They do it all the time. However, it is one thing telling your manager that you arrived late because of heavy traffic, when the real reason is that you woke up late after a long night out, and another thing calling a friend to tell her you saw her husband with someone else when he was just having a good laugh with work colleagues during his lunch break.

It is even worse when it is people in authority who lie, or who try to hide the truth, or who only tell part of it, the part that suits them most. Unfortunately, we have too many examples of such cases, and notably the ones that stick out the most are the lies that are told, and sometimes written, by politicians. It could be because they are more in the public eye.

In an ideal world, one would expect politicians to stick to the truth more than other people. But that’s in an ideal world. If one were to gauge people from different walks of life, it is probable that politicians would be at the top of the list when it comes to lying.

Yet, those politicians who are caught lying should be punished more than the ordinary man, simply because of the position of authority or responsibility they hold. They are role models to whom people look up, and they have a great influence on others.

There is only one way in which politicians can be hurt, and that is if they are rejected. The people have a lot of power in the

“number one” that they write against a politician’s name once every five years. And they should go for the politician whose nose is the shortest.

* * *

I do not intend to go into the merits of who is right or who is wrong in the way the BWSC contract issue is being tackled in the Public Accounts Committee. Both the government and the Opposition have presented valid arguments as to why the PAC should not summon witnesses other than the Attorney General (government side), or whether they should be heard by the parliamentary committee (Opposition side).

The general public does not easily understand the technicalities of the debate that we had in two different sittings of the PAC. It is only those familiar with parliamentary procedures and legal jargon who are able to sift through the two divergent positions.

And this is probably why the public perception is that the Opposition’s stand seems to be clearer than the one taken by the government.

The Labour Party wants the PAC to hear witnesses again, the government is opposing, and so the government looks as if it has something to hide. That, in a nutshell, is the PL position.

The government’s arguments are more complicated, and the reasons that are being given for its refusal to hear the statements of witnesses on the BWSC contract at PAC level only serve to strengthen Labour’s stand.

The government may be technically right in saying that the re-hearing of witnesses would nullify the work already carried out by the Attorney General. However, the decision to oppose the PL’s request is not the best strategy the Nationalists could have adopted.

To the man in the street, such tactics are perceived as being a way by which the PN is trying to hold back something, even if this is not the case. And we all know that, where politics is concerned, perception counts more than the truth in the eyes of the public.

The longer the matter remains a subject people are talking about, the better it will be for Labour. And the Nationalists seem to be playing right into Labour’s hands by delaying a conclusion and prolonging the public debate on the issue.

I would not be surprised if the BWSC contract issue stays with us right up to the next election. Neither would I be surprised if Labour has other things up its sleeves that it will gradually make public when the time is ripe.

* * *

Whether it’s one, 10 or 100 journalists who hold or have held a position in any organisation, it is still not correct for them to do so. Being a journalist and occupying a role in an organisation can lead to conflicts of interest because one cannot serve two masters.

Yet, it seems that here in Malta, anything goes. Abroad, in countries we aspire to follow, journalists are prohibited from having official roles in any organisation that could be directly linked to their job. In Italy, for example, journalists cannot even take part in advertisements. If they do, they risk losing their journalistic licence.

Here in Malta, however, there are journalists who occupy roles in organisations that could potentially lead to a conflict of interest in their reporting. It mostly happens in the sports sector.

Whether it’s the Malta Olympic Committee, the Malta Football Association, or any other organisation, it is wrong for journalists to occupy an official position. I will repeat what I wrote two weeks ago. If journalists want to occupy these positions, the media that employs them should ask them to choose between that position and their journalistic duties.

When the two roles are mixed, it is a big dent in the credibility and professionalism of the journalists, as well as the credibility and professionalism of the media that employs them and the organisations that give them official roles.

I think it is too much to expect the Institute of Maltese Journalists to take a position on this matter. But I don’t want to shout too loudly. It would disturb their slumber.

[email protected]

  • don't miss