The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Ramblers’ Corner - Malta Goes European

Malta Independent Sunday, 31 October 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

While the Opposition was hammering the government in our hapless political system, the real issue that needed to be discussed was not addressed at all. Like on several occasions in the recent past, the party with the most seats in Parliament outclassed the Opposition. Not with arguments, but with a pathetic display of voting power with which the smallest possible majority outvotes the biggest possible minority. How the horrible decision could have been taken that started this battle remains a closely guarded secret, like a kind of banking secret.

While both parties were fooling each other and wasting time, I had some interesting reading to do. As a frequent visitor to the Mepa website, I am always impressed by the sheer dedication of Mepa employees. Not only is the reading very interesting, it is also very informative. Due to my professional background, I am always interested in matters that concern Malta’s national electricity grid. Knowing that the issue was to be discussed by the Public Accounts Committee, I expected the Opposition would have done the reading I did, and found it interesting too.

While browsing the Mepa website I found an application from Enemalta for a “landing point and terminal station in Malta for a submarine electrical connector with Sicily”. This means Enemalta is considering sourcing electricity supply from Sicily for Malta’s future needs. Of course I had heard about this idea before but there always seemed to be arguments that would make it either impossible or not economically viable. I was therefore pleasantly surprised that Enemalta had finally seen the light and decided to file an application for a terminal station. Before proposing a location for this station, Enemalta explored no less than 26 sites. All these locations had their pros and cons but the man Enemalta put on the job did his best to produce a report in which he mentioned them all, and came up with a very good conclusion – that the proposed location for the terminal station has to be next to the entrance of the Maghtab landfill. The cable itself would therefore have to land at Qalet Marku and trenched to the station.

So far so good as this cable would be a really big help in providing Malta’s energy needs. Still, I wanted to know what it was that brought the writer of this report to the proposed location. After all, yet another piece of green is going to be lost and, as a Rambler, I am not particularly in favour of that. On the other hand, almost anything is welcome that hides any part of Maghtab from view. Not only do I now understand why the location at Maghtab was chosen, I also realise that we have no need for the Delimara power station extension.

Personally, I find some of the proposed locations in Pembroke also quite plausible, not only because the development would finally deal with countless unused buildings in that already ruined area, but also because the tunnel needed for the connection to the national electricity grid will only be one third in length.

Did I mention there is no need for the Delimara power station extension? Yes, I believe I did and here is what happens. The power station in Marsa has to close by no later than 31 December 2015. It is of course important that Malta secures the electricity supply before that date is reached because generating capacity will be reduced by 210MW with the closure of the Marsa power station. Do not worry about the technicality of this, just stick to the numbers and they will make sense. The extension of the Delimara power station will give us an extra generating capacity of 140MW. If you are still with me this means that, after building the Delimara extension and closing Marsa, we will still be short of 70MW of generating capacity. Not that it will be dark at the beginning of 2016 but there will be insufficient spare capacity, so to speak. The demand for electricity in 2015 is estimated to be around 535MW, which means that there may not be enough capacity.

The reason behind Enemalta’s proposal for the underwater cable to Sicily is to ensure there will always be enough capacity available in Malta. The option to build extra generating capacity either at Delimara or another location is not discussed in this report. It is very possible that another operator besides Enemalta would enter the market to provide electricity, and this will put Malta in line with European regulations for a free market and do away with the monopolistic position of Enemalta.

The arguments in favour of the cable to Sicily are quite interesting: security of supply, cleaner generation, economies of scale, an open market, less fossil fuel burn, no additional fuel storage capacity, and so on. Most important of all is that closing the Marsa power station will solve half the pollution problem brought about by power generation and render possible Malta’s chances to meet its climate-change obligations by 2020. Argument 5 is a good one, “the local reduction of large noise and visual signatures associated with power generating infrastructure”. Power stations are ugly sights that must be minimised as much as possible.

Given that green methods for generation of electricity (solar and wind) remain uncertain, these solid arguments for an underwater cable are like music to my ears as a Rambler. They embody what the Ramblers have been saying about our local energy production all along. The only thing that I am missing in all these arguments is the need for education aimed at a drastic reduction in electricity usage. After all, we can’t continue to use more and more electricity and run out of natural resources at the expense of our environment.

What Enemalta proposes is to lay two undersea cables, both with a capacity of 225MW. The present Delimara power station has a generation capacity of around 270MW and it is expected that wind energy will generate around 100MW in the future. It could be my imagination but even without wind energy we’re almost good. The report states that this cable is required to ensure secure supply, to improve air quality and to meet future environment targets. To top it all the investment needed for this cable is around 25 per cent less than for a power station extension, besides the cost for the disposal of the chemical waste which will be produced by the new Delimara extension.

Still, there is something that I, as a Rambler, do not understand. How is it that our Honourable Members of Parliament argue over a power station extension we do not need and do not want when the solution is so clearly written in this report? The proposed technique is very polluting and no solution for this pollution has been found yet. I believe this fact is known to Mepa and I cannot imagine the Authority giving the final go-ahead before this important issue is solved. Malta does not need, nor want, another Marsa power station in another location. If Malta wants to meet its environmental targets the government should not change the standards but take any chance to reduce pollution. Why did nobody think about putting another cable in the sea? It is after all cheaper and a lot less polluting than a power station.

For the Ramblers’ Association of Malta the choice is clear: better 10 cables in the sea than one power station on shore. Let us safeguard the environment that is left and let us not extend the Delimara power station. Importation of energy from mainland Europe will be cleaner and cheaper. Who knows, maybe some competition will be good for Enemalta and we might all benefit in more ways than I mentioned here. After all, I have to live here too and the expensive energy from the Delimara extension is not good for my wallet.

However, it might be possible that there is another reason why this report was concluded after the Delimara contract was signed, even though the studies date from years ago. Who knows, maybe what is bad for my wallet is good for someone else’s!

www.ramblersmalta.org

[email protected]

  • don't miss