The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Smoke On the water

Malta Independent Tuesday, 23 November 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 17 years ago

In-Nazzjon and other PN-friendly newspapers promptly informed us on three separate pages that, thanks to the testimony of the Auditor General, the following resulted: L-ebda korruzzjoni (no trace of corruption); Ma kellux ghalfejn imur ghand il-kummissarju tal-pulizija (the AG had no reason to call in the commissioner of police); and L-Awditur Generali jerga’ jikkonferma – l-ebda korruzzjoni fl-estensjoni tal-power station (the Auditor General confirms that there was no corruption in the power station extension).

They did this without bothering to mention that such conclusions were reached purely and solely on the basis of the testimony that was forthcoming.

Closer scrutiny of his testimony shows that in his own words there might not have been any fire but there sure was quite a lot of smoke.

In an original version online – which was eventually doctored in the final printed version – a leading local newspaper highlighted various bizarre findings.

Mainly that:

• the NAO found no hard evidence of corruption but that it saw many coincidences which made one wonder;

• that although there was no evidence, in view of the information available to the audit office, there had been a lack of co-operation from some people whom the NAO had questioned;

• that when asked what smoke had been found, Mr Mifsud, the AG, said that there was a series of coincidences throughout the process;

• that, for example, Enemalta always held its meetings with BWSC after having met the other bidders;

• that it was also strange how consultancy firm Lehmayer initially offered its services and was turned down, and then Enemalta itself sought its services a month later;

• that lack of cooperation was evident mostly from BWSC agent Joseph Mizzi;

• that, according to the Deputy Auditor General, when questioned, Mr Mizzi had not been forthcoming about his meetings with BWSC and he also refused to answer questions;

• that Mr Mizzi had also not replied to questions on emails sent in 2005;

• that the original auditor report had claimed that the tendering procedure should have been stopped when the emission thresholds were changed;

• that, as pointed out by the PL side, BWSC had congratulated Mr Mizzi for his contacts and intelligence work;

• that the Auditor confirmed that Mr Mizzi was accompanied at the NAO meetings by a former Enemalta lawyer although he was not employed by Enemalta at the time;

• that when Minister Gatt observed that Mr Mizzi had ceased to be an Enemalta employee 20 years before this case and that he had allegedly been passed over for promotion, the Auditor said that was not within his remit;

• that when Minister Gatt implied that Mr Mizzi was not the ultimate beneficiary but his former employers ASL, the Auditor is reported to have said that Mr Mizzi could have benefited on a commission basis;

• that it was pointed out by the PL side that, although Mr Mizzi subsequently left ASL, BWSC had insisted that he should continue to represent them;

• that the Auditor also mentioned that some Enemalta visitor registration documents were missing.

The fact that all these points were ignored and glossed over by the Nationalist-leaning media speaks for itself.

The continuation of the proceedings on 30 November is likely to reinforce the true reasons why the government members had resisted testimony being given in front of the PAC by certain key witnesses. Particularly since according to the legal advisor of the NAO, the testimony of witnesses who appeared in front of the NAO could not be made public.

I am confident that, although there will always remain gullible persons in our midst, particularly those who are easily impressed by Castille-led and orchestrated media spin, public opinion has been sufficiently alerted to the strongly evident ‘Smoke On the Water’ that ensued from this case. Notwithstanding the emasculated manner in which the PAC has been operating of late, and seems predestined to do in future.

No wonder PN media control freaks like Gordon Pisani were to be seen unusually present for part of the proceedings of the PAC meeting.

Further confirmation of the unease in high quarters and also that, once again, all is not well in the state of Denmark (no puns intended because of BWSC!)

Dwejra – proof of a dysfunctional Mepa

An environmentalist emailed me last Friday to ask me whether, in my opinion, the Mepa environmental chief was having his strings pulled politically, whether he was naïve or else technically incompetent.

From the knowledge and information I have, Mr Seychell is a competent person who knows his stuff well.

Whether he is naïve or not I am not in a position to tell.

Which leaves us with the third option.

If his recent interview was meant as a government face-saver over the Dwejra debacle it was definitely counter productive.

It led to an even more vociferous public outcry by adding more fuel to the fire.

Apart from also revealing gross insensitivity towards the environmental sector he should have been safeguarding, Mr Seychell should have put our minds at rest that development should be subservient to the environment rather than trying to sell us the hollow argument that if the economy does well, the environment usually does better.

As a top environmentalist remarked in her blog, his interview offered a good insight into why environmental degradation in Malta meets very little resistance.

Mr Seychell not only contradicted himself on whether any ecosystems were involved or not in the Dwejra incident only for him to end up eating humble pie by withdrawing his claim that there was no ecosystem in the rock, but he also made the bold assertion that the habitats in the area had not been affected when no assessment had been made yet.

Even worse if in the case of the JPO-Mistra project – yet another Natura 2000 site – the Mepa auditor had insisted on an appropriate assessment, was such an assessment carried out in Dwejra before the permit was issued?

Even his claim that there is a buffer zone at Dwejra has been proved wrong by the SAC Natura 2000 which scheduled the Dwejra Area in one chunk.

We were also kept in the dark as to whatever happened to the Dwejra management plan as well as what stage has been reached in its implementation process.

All these are symptoms of a Mepa that has become even more dysfunctional in spite of the so-called reform, ever since the Prime Minister assumed full political responsibility for it.

As he solemnly pledged to do during the 2008 election campaign on the basis of his ‘safe pair of hands’ mantra… particularly to make us all forget the goings-on in the days of George Pullicino.

At this rate, Nationalists will soon be clamouring ‘bring back George Pullicino’, which would indeed be saying something!

  • don't miss