The recent parliamentary report has again given rise to the question on embryo freezing; something which is a ‘side effect’, as it were, of Invitro Fertilization (IVF).
Since life begins at conception embryo freezing cannot be viewed other than an ‘insult’ to the development of the early human being. Nevertheless with careful legislation the embryo can indeed be protected.
What this amounts to is a decision on the part of parliamentarians on whether infertile couples can receive IVF treatment. This decision, even though the process has great reservation on the part of the Catholic Church, can nevertheless, from a secular point of view be seen as possible whilst protecting values of family and the embryo itself. If it is in the government’s interest that IVF be offered it then has to move from that premise to how it is going to protect these two fundamental issues.
The government has already taken the position that embryos should grow in a healthy family environment; the couple has to be married failing which heterosexual couples will be considered. One assumes that criteria will have to be met in order to see what constitutes a ‘stable’ relationship. But if our normative values accepts IVF for couples it is not accepting IVF for single individuals and neither gay couples. The gay rights movement has indeed protested formally and may indeed go up to the European Court of justice making a claim on human rights.
Whether the European Court of justice can challenge our constitution is another matter. It is here that I often point out that the second article of the constitution states plainly that the official religion is the Roman Catholic one. This does not mean that all laws have to follow canon law or be approved by the Church. It does mean however that the constitution recognizes that the Catholic religion is what is cherished by most as our normative values. One acknowledges that this is already being challenged, but until such time as two thirds of parliament decide to remove it, then the values which parliament should look after in this case are family and protection of life at all its stages.
Having said that there is the question of what to do with the frozen embryos. It has already been alluded that they may be donated. This has proved to be a stumbling block because it was not answered immediately. My position to the government is that once it decides that it is in the countries best interest to provide IVF to infertile couples, it should also be in the States’ interest to protect the embryo and see that it does not remain frozen for an indefinite period of time. Certainly IVF can only be provided within Good Clinical Practice (GCP) guidance.
This means that one cannot obtain only the eggs that will be fertilized and implanted into the mother. Obtaining eggs involves stimulating the woman’s ovaries, which invariably produces a considerable number; whilst at the same time being an invasive procedure. It is not about cost; it is about safety and good medicine. This mean that on the one hand we cannot obtain just two eggs, whilst on the other hand, in order not to be left with too many frozen embryos, one cannot fertilize a large number.
A minimum number which GCP allows would need to be established, which ascertains that only a minimum will be left for freezing. The question is what to do with the embryos that remain. It should be established that it is not in the States’ interest that such embryos remain frozen in limbo indefinitely. A stipulated period of reasonable time, say, three or four year, should be given, within which parents will have custody and counselled give these embryos a chance. Should this time expire the government would take over custody, and donate them.
Of course this requires a number of articles in the law. The first is that parents should be counselled and their rights and obligations explained. Secondly when the State takes over custody, it guarantees that it can only donate them to couples (which would qualify under the same definition of the law of what constitutes a legitimate couple) and not donate them for research purposes or other.
Thirdly, if parents separate they would still be given the same period of custody unless they give them up to the State. Once the State takes over couples should be counselled that the gestational mother (the mother who adopts the child and has it develop in her womb) would be seen as the biological mother and not the genetic parents. There will be no visiting rights etc. Anonymity should be maintained unless for medical reasons.
Naturally one may look at this situation as treating embryos as a commodity. But the intention of the State is certainly not this but to protect the embryo from undue time in a freezer. Otherwise, besides the insult to the life of the embryo you can end up with one twin being born decades after the other. In this situation the embryo is guaranteed development within a short period of time, preferably by the same parents. If parents abrogate their responsibility, the State has the duty to protect that same life and see that it develops. Naturally this call for clear counselling and amendments to the law as necessary. If one cannot accept this, then one should contemplate whether one should have IVF at all.