The things people spoke about and the things you read about in the two English-language newspapers which existed then just weren’t the same thing. Reading the newspaper was like ploughing through dispatches from another reality.
For the last few months, I’ve been feeling the same, and asking myself whether the growth of the media pool has led to the creation of a sort of alternative fish-pond, with those who swim in it speaking mainly to each other and building up issues and stories that don’t really exist.
I can see how it happens. You socialise together, see each other at umpteen press conferences and media events, speak to the same lobbyists, politicos and stakeholders time and time again, and then you run away with the idea that what you think is a big issue really is one, and that others are discussing it as avidly as you are.
I can also see why my perspective is different. I don’t socialise with others who work for the media, speak only to my immediate colleagues in the field, don’t take calls from politicians (don’t call me, I’ll call you), go to perhaps one press conference in two years and hardly ever go to media events.
My life is conducted, strange though it might sound, away from media circles and in regular life among regular people – to put it that way. So my perspective is different, and I know when something has failed to galvanise people’s interest because I can see and hear it, and that is quite apart from the fact that it has failed to galvanise mine and I’m a bit of a bellwether when it comes to these things, probably because of so many years of immersion.
The Dwejra sandstorm is one such non-starter. How long is it going to be before certain sections of the media realise that nobody cares, and that the whole thing has been blown right out of proportion? No doubt, some Alternative Person will come right back at me with the rejoinder that People Should Be Made To Care, to which I have nothing to say but this: Newspapers exist for their readers, and not the other way round.
If those who are whipping up a storm in their own little bubble really wish to know what people are saying about Dwejra, it is this: “Kemm se jdumu jeqirdu dwar id-Dwejra? Don’t they have any real stories to write about?” Mark-Anthony Falzon wrote an excellent piece about this for The Sunday Times this week. I was quite cross at him because I had planned to say the same myself, and he beat me to it. But there you go.
As I write this (Tuesday), I can see that there is yet another Dwejra sand story to chew on. Let’s see for just how much longer this thing is going to be teased out, while readers remark to themselves whether we are really so very fortunate that we live on an island where the big issue is sand chucked on a beach when it shouldn’t have been. It was worth two pieces at most.
And what to say about the coverage given by the newspapers to the death and burial of a bishop (please, not ‘passing away’)? The death of Nikol Cauchi took up most of the front page of one newspaper while the European Commission’s approval of a life-saving loan for Air Malta was shoved into a single-column story-bar to the right.
His death – not a tragic or newsworthy one by any means, but the sort of death that occurs at the end of a long life – might have been important to people working for the newspaper, but it certainly does not mean it was important to the newspaper’s readers, who were more concerned about the fate of the national airline, which would have had to file for bankruptcy like other airlines before it, had the loan not been approved. That was the kind of coverage that would be appropriate when, say, Mintoff dies. It is not appropriate for a mere bishop whose name and face most people don’t know and who had impact on precious few lives. He was a nice man by all accounts and a prominent one, but there are many such here and heaven forfend they should all get that kind of overblown treatment.
Talk about not getting your priorities right: something that narrowly saves the national airline from bankruptcy, and which should be considered in the context of the terrible fall-out the collapse of Air Malta would have had for the country as a whole, is almost knocked off the front page and left clinging by its fingertips to the side by the death of a bishop. It’s unbelievable.
It’s bad enough that politicians are out of touch with people’s lives; we certainly don’t need to have our newspapers go down that road too. Look at the way that Joseph Muscat and the Labour Party continue to harp on about the skandlu tal-BWSC. Yes, they’ve captured the imagination of their supporters and yes, they’ve also captured the imagination of those who didn’t like the government anyway. They’re preaching to the converted, but the rest of us are bored rigid and couldn’t give a damn.
All we pick up is the nag, nag, nag, negativity while we try to get on with our lives. This might be hard to swallow, but Mr and Mrs Average don’t really care how a power station is bought and sold. All they care about is how that power station will affect their lives: will it give them better service or worse? The Labour Party would have had more success in getting us to listen if it managed to find evidence that the new power station extension is going to poison us all in our beds. Joseph Muscat understands this, and he actually tried that gambit first. But when it failed (some creditable environmentalists crawled out of their sand-holes to rubbish the rumours) he was forced to borrow from his former mentor Alfred Sant, with the well-worn ‘I am morally convinced there was corruption’ tack.
Yes, I know it’s terribly difficult having to fill a newspaper or news bulletin every blessed day, whether things happen or they don’t. But where news doesn’t exist, you really can’t create it, especially not out of sand or smoke.
www.daphnecaruanagalizia.com