Try to imagine what it means to be an Air Malta employee right now. Or what it means to be an Irish person. Or Greek, or perhaps Portuguese or Spanish.
We are not talking here of the poorest of the poor, of the ‘untouchables’ of today’s European society, either those with no right of residence or citizenship, or those on the margins of society.
But those who until a few months ago, before this nightmare began, were considered to be solid members of the middle class – people with a job and presumably with a family to go back to. People with a modest but certain standard of living that could, of course, be better, but which seemed as rock steady as the mountains.
Now all that has come unhinged. There is no certainty any more. What previously was a given, it was assumed that life would go on, has now become seriously in doubt. It is in doubt that there will be any future tomorrow. It is in doubt that a once certain job remains so for the future.
Let’s forget Air Malta for a minute, whose problems are company-specific, although common enough in the sector. Let us widen our view to this tsunami that ever since 2008 has shaken the entire world and that, over the past months and weeks, has produced a tsunami with seemingly a mind and volition of its own, which first threatened to engulf Greece, then, when the European nations came to its rescue, seemed to have gone to sleep, to come up and out with renewed vigour and threatening energy to attack Ireland. And which is now threatening to sweep first Portugal, then maybe Spain, certainly at the end the entire eurozone into oblivion.
Other countries are already being lined up as sacrificial victims to the behemoth – maybe Italy, Belgium, possibly even Cyprus. Where is Malta in this queue of sacrificial victims? Will there be ever an end to the tsunami?
Over the past two and a half years, the world’s economy has seen an incredible whirlpool that has sucked in huge sums of money. Just consider the two waves of financing that the US government has ploughed into the system – and America is not out of the woods yet and one day will have to come to terms with the money it spent in its two waves of Quantitative Easing.
To read the specialized press these days is an exercise of bafflement – how no one seems to have any clear ideas about what is going to happen and what may be done to avoid the worst.
Ironically, the greatest uncertainty concerns the future of the euro. It is by now completely clear that the creation of the euro was riddled not just by no sign of political substance to back the creation of the single currency but later by a very lax oversight of what had been solemnly promised but equally solemnly forgotten.
Having said that, it is now incredibly difficult to see the way ahead. Some such as Angela Merkel speak of a new treaty with almost automatic suspension of the delinquent nation members, problematic though this may be. Others see no future whatsoever except eventual country defaults and countries leaving the eurozone. But even this, as a post on BBC News showed, is incredibly difficult to do. Once locked into the euro, only a country bent on suicide can take the exit path out of the euro.
Those who for one or another accident of history have not made it to the euro – such as Britain or even Hungary as its prime minister told us last week – thank their lucky stars. The others, those caught inside, look over their shoulders to see if the tsunami is coming their way.
The crisis has many heads. The one in the US was caused by the housing boom that went overboard. That in Greece was caused by happy accounting and lax tax collection. In one and the other there was huge complicity by the banks and the financial institutions which recent monetary and economic theory wanted to be left completely alone.
But it was in Ireland that the banks were allowed to go to completely insane levels. Last Tuesday’s Financial Times had a riveting graph which explained that the size of the problem in Ireland was $731 billion in the Irish banking system mostly now related to assets that can only be worth a fraction of that. Of this huge sum, British banks hold $149 billion or 6.6% of GDP, German banks $139 billion or 4.2% of GDP, Spain $14 billion or 1.0% of GDP, Japan $27 billion or 0.5% of GDP, the US $69 billion or 0.5% of GDP, Belgium $54 billion or 11.7% of GDP and France $50 billion or 2.0 of GDP.
That explains why in or out of the eurozone no member state can disregard the situation in another member country. It was already evident during the Greek crisis when a Greek collapse would have involved banks in Germany and elsewhere and it has again surfaced big time in the Irish crisis.
One also has to remember that the Irish government, right at the beginning of the crisis broke ranks and declared the government solidly behind the Irish banking system. Knowing what we all now know about the very less than solid banking system, especially the Anglo Irish Bank and its happy lending, such blanket support seems highly suspect.
The result is – the result is the austerity budget announced on Wednesday – “It is a plan that will hit every citizen and sector of the Irish economy, but will hit working people, students and low-income earners the hardest, a move that has already provoked both a deep fury from many but also a bitter resignation amongst others.
“Key measures include a slashing of welfare benefits, a hiking and broadening of income taxes, a sharp increase in university fees, the imposition of property taxes and water charges.” It is a crisis that will be felt most on the backs of the poor.
There are some reflections to be made here. Most of the media parrots that quote from each other blame Angela Merkel for exacerbating the crisis when she wondered why ever the people who made money from the growth registered in the past years – the financial institutions, the banks – could not be the same people to at least pay part of the expenses of the aftermath.
Such questions were also asked in the US, but obviously over there no one replied. On the contrary, Democrat Barack Obama put in trillions of Quantitative Easing and QE2 into the banks and financial institutions, into car manufacturers (big big lobby) and those who made huge money by what in effect was a series of pyramid schemes have been generally allowed to enjoy the fruits of their ill-gotten gains.
In a more social EU, the same is happening. Over summer, after the Greek crisis, consciences were assuaged by what was called stress tests conducted over selected representative banks. Very few banks failed. None of the Irish banks failed. And now we are being allowed a glimpse of how toxic their asset bases were.
Inevitably, the crisis is having political repercussions – the Irish government is as good as dead. The Italian one is just hanging on. Governments who took courageous decisions such as that of Latvia have been promoted in elections. Other governments, like the Greek one or the Hungarian one, came to power promising tax decreases and wage rises and have had to impose austerity measures.
Retaining or defending the euro cannot constitute the be-all and end-all of economic policy. One has to go back at the basis of the single currency and what it was meant to be. It was supposed to be a corner stone of the single market, which in turn was meant to be not just a continental market which would have a vaster public than any single country but also a force that removes any inequality of treatment. Apart from the domino theory that has brought one country after another to the brink, one must examine whether the much-boasted single market has really and effectively been put in place (not really, for the wide services sector has been kept out of things) or whether the single market is just another of the EU fictions.
It is also, more in the EU than in the US, a job-less recovery and, again, it is the young and the people on the margins of society that most suffer. A recovery that avoids the collapse of the economy or a default but which allows unemployment levels of 20% or more is a ghoulish recovery. It is not enough, not by a long chalk, for the EU to avoid total collapse without finding the force to be the ideal that led countries to unite behind the EU ideal.
The EU was born as a steel and coal union of those countries who had fought each other for centuries, united in their desire to be free of wars. Slowly, the European dream was born as more countries from the core of the continent joined the core group of founder members. The European dream grew more and more ambitious and this led to dreams of a single market serviced by a single currency. The European dream has faded in the continent’s heartland, but it is still hugely attractive to those countries still outside it, especially in the Balkan peninsula.
Now the single currency is battling for survival, with no guarantees it will survive – on the contrary there are many who bet it will not. It will be hugely problematic to survive and hellish if it does not. Mere survival is however not enough, the euro will remain a battered currency, subject to the whims and schemes of speculative pressures.
For an EU which so many times battled against pressures to turn it into a variable geometry or speed, it has become one. There is a eurozone and an outside of eurozone. Inside the eurozone there are the virtuous countries and the problem countries. Soon, perhaps already, the core of the eurozone will once again be Germany surrounded by those with similar policies, let’s call them German clones. Outside that, and one numbers the UK and perhaps also France, multiple centres are being created, with differentiating currencies often at odds with the euro, certainly competing with it. The dream of a single currency uniting the continent is already over.
Out of the chaos of a badly-baked dream maybe one day will come a new inspiring dream. But that will be too late for the people getting hurt today.
[email protected]