The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

The Living wage paradox

Malta Independent Sunday, 28 November 2010, 00:00 Last update: about 17 years ago

Pope Leo XIII issued his encyclical Rerum Novarum (Of New Things) in 1891. This encyclical remains one of the defining documents that embody the basic principles of the Catholic Church’s social teaching. At the height of the West’s industrial revolution, the Pope sought to address a number of significant issues relating principally to the worker’s rights and conditions in a world that was increasingly polarized by excessive capitalist practices and the stirrings of extreme Communism.

Among the salient points of the encyclical, Pope Leo raised the concept of the ‘living wage.’ At the heart of the concept lay the wish for a decent wage that would not only compensate its receiver but also guarantee a decent living both for himself and his family. Clearly this concept is not the same as that of the minimum wage. The latter ensures a ‘basic’ price for labour without delving too deeply into the purchasing power of the same basic pay. In a sense, Rerum Novarum was the basis of the many changes and labour reforms that would be made over a hundred years.

Forty years after Rerum Novarum, Pope Pius X1 took up the many social and economic questions raised by his predecessor in the encyclical Quadragesimo Anno (In the 40th Year). Once again the Church spoke of the need for cooperation between employers and employees. The Pope denounced the exploitation of workers, the determination of fair wages, the importance of respecting private property and the necessity of social order. Effectively, these two encyclicals remain cornerstones of the Church’s social teaching.

In the meantime, the debate on labour and its regulation remains a timeless relevant topic. The development of labour laws, the reforms relating to work practices and the continued improvement of workers’ rights and obligations remain key in maintaining a cohesive and fair environment for anyone who wishes to work and in turn fulfil one’s aspirations in an increasingly competitive and challenging world.

Fast-forward 119 years from the ubiquitous Rerum Novarum. The Leader of the Opposition, Dr Joseph Muscat, announces with some pomp and circumstance his “new” and innovative vision regarding the concept of a living wage. In a nutshell, Dr Muscat reiterated notions that have been around for more than a century. Essentially there is nothing wrong in all of this. At the heart of the living wage is a wish for a wage packet that would cover the basic ‘expenses’ of the individual and his family (although it remains unclear what constitutes basic expenses!)

For a time, the debate regarding Joseph Muscat’s proposal remained cool. Things started to heat up when the Labour Leader was invited to Bondiplus a few weeks ago to flesh out his understanding of a ‘living wage’. During the discussion it became increasingly evident that beyond the magnanimity and virtue of Muscat’s belief in the idea of a living wage, very little consideration (if any!) had been given to the actual mechanics and economic implications of such a proposal. Dr Muscat appears to believe that a living wage will emerge from the simple generosity of employers while eschewing any concrete proposal to lead by example (should he be Prime Minister!) and revalue state and government employees. It was also pointed out that any such revaluation would cost tens of millions of euros each year.

The story continued to unfold a few days ago at a Malta Employer’s Association business conference specifically aimed at discussing Labour’s living wage proposal. The idea floated by Dr Muscat a couple of months ago had clearly drawn the attention of employers. A number of pertinent questions were raised. How is this living wage to be calculated? As it would be based on a basket of necessities, how would these be chosen? How would such re-jigging in wages affect Malta’s productivity and competitiveness? Would this calculation be based on the individual worker’s income or on the family income?

As no concrete proposals were provided, Dr Muscat could only allay these fears by insisting the living wage would only be a voluntary yardstick. Labour would not impose the living wage and would only implement it by ‘social consensus’ (whatever that may possibly mean!). Dr Muscat concluded that he was open to “suggestions” and that if the living wage proposal were untenable “any other alternative” would be considered. The lasting impression is that although Dr Muscat knows what he thinks he wants (or wants to project to the electorate), he seems unable to provide sustainable measures to implement it! This in itself is the paradox of Labour’s proposal regarding the living wage.

Let me make myself clear. I am pretty sure that no one is against raising the living standards of employees. It is equally true that higher wages should translate into better standards of living (I am informed that this is also debatable due to inflationary pressures.) What irks me is the way that the Opposition continues to project itself as unprepared in its political arguments and proposals. Without debunking the merits of a living wage, it is amply clear that Labour will exploit any reality that it would deem fair game in its quest for votes without clearly substantiating its arguments and proposals. This lack of clear direction is evident in other issues that are continuously fudged in an effort to instil uncertainty and lack of confidence without any clear and concrete alternative solutions.

Sadly, I believe our country deserves so much better!

[email protected]

  • don't miss